None of the Above - Long
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Brodie,
Not meaning to argue with others, but trying to pound or lever that spur out will increase the possibility of damaging your lathe's spindle.
Instead, go to a good hardware/industrial supply and get a 1-1/4" x 8 hex nut which will match your lathe's thread. Also get a 1-1/4" heavy steel washer.
In your shop, you'll cut a piece out of the washer at the exact diameter of the inside hole so you have a "U" in a circle. Next you'll cut the nut in half.
Lock your spindle. You slip the washer onto your spindle with the opening down just behind the spur, then put the two piece nut on the spindle between the washer and the spindle shoulder. With a large adjustable wrench bring the "nut assembly" up to the washer and continue applying pressure against the washer. Your spur will pop out. You'd do well to put a towel or material in line to catch the spur because when it comes loose, it's coming out of there fast with some force behind it.
Before you reinsert the spur or another MT accessory, you need to check both tapers to make sure they are clean and smooth. your current problem was most likely caused by grit or other foreign matter on the taper surface, and you're likely to have a gall on both surfaces. The grit digs into both metal surfaces and serves to lock them together. Pounding or trying to twist the thing out will only increase the damage to the surfaces. The Gall can be repaired with a taper reamer (the BEST way) or a bit of sandpaper wrapped on the male taper to take the high spot off the surface. To prevent this from a repeat, always clean the taper before inserting the spur and make sure the spur is free of dirt and dust as well.
Good Luck