Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Help my spur drive is stuck!

Posts

Help my spur drive is stuck!

#1

Help my spur drive is stuck!

Brodie Brickey

>I am without a doubt an idiot. I'm not sure how I did it, probably too much pressure, but I was turning a block of cedar round last night and when I went to remove the spur drive I couldn't get it out. Not with the knock out, not with the pliers. Its stuck in my PM2035 and to say I ain't happy is an understatement.

I do most of my work with a faceplate and chuck and since it was a closed box endgrain turning I had this thought that I didn't want a big hole in the top of the box so I used the spur.

The spur does have a hole perpendicular to the MT2 just below the spur head. Tonight I'll try a screwdriver and use that and a block of wood as a fulcrum. Any other thoughts on getting it out?

Needless to say, I won't be using this spur drive again.

Brodie

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#2

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi Brodie,

I would stay with the knock out bar option and add some some penetrating oil and a bit of gentle heat....spary it in from the front and the headstock too....

Just glad it wasn't a Chuck!

:-)

take care,

Jim

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#3

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Been there, done that... Like Jim said the knockout bar. If it's really tight use a brass (steel) bar and a hammer through the spindle. It will come out.

Let us know,

Doug

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#4

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

John Kyler

>I would use the knock out bar, oil, and a dead blow hammer.

But I would also wrap the center in a rag so when it goes flying as a projectile etc......

John

Golden, CO 38 inches deep and just now the snow is stoped.

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#5

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

John Lucas

>I agree with John and some of the others. You just have to hit the knock out bar real hard. Not a bunch of gentle raps, one good solid one. As suggested put a towel or something over the drive center or it will become a rocket.

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#6

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

Bill Howatt

>Sometimes when the spindle gets warm from normal running the spur gets pushed further in and then when it cools it is harder to get out. Try running it and getting it warm again.

Do not try to twist it out. A big sharp rap with a big hammer on the knockout bar is much more effective than several lighter taps.

Bill

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#7

None of the Above - Long

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Brodie,

Not meaning to argue with others, but trying to pound or lever that spur out will increase the possibility of damaging your lathe's spindle.

Instead, go to a good hardware/industrial supply and get a 1-1/4" x 8 hex nut which will match your lathe's thread. Also get a 1-1/4" heavy steel washer.

In your shop, you'll cut a piece out of the washer at the exact diameter of the inside hole so you have a "U" in a circle. Next you'll cut the nut in half.

Lock your spindle. You slip the washer onto your spindle with the opening down just behind the spur, then put the two piece nut on the spindle between the washer and the spindle shoulder. With a large adjustable wrench bring the "nut assembly" up to the washer and continue applying pressure against the washer. Your spur will pop out. You'd do well to put a towel or material in line to catch the spur because when it comes loose, it's coming out of there fast with some force behind it.

Before you reinsert the spur or another MT accessory, you need to check both tapers to make sure they are clean and smooth. your current problem was most likely caused by grit or other foreign matter on the taper surface, and you're likely to have a gall on both surfaces. The grit digs into both metal surfaces and serves to lock them together. Pounding or trying to twist the thing out will only increase the damage to the surfaces. The Gall can be repaired with a taper reamer (the BEST way) or a bit of sandpaper wrapped on the male taper to take the high spot off the surface. To prevent this from a repeat, always clean the taper before inserting the spur and make sure the spur is free of dirt and dust as well.

Good Luck

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#8

Re: None of the Above - Long

Wilford Bickel

>If light rap on knock out did not do it - don't keep pounding, do what Mark details! I have also read that after cutting nut in two halves, if you have a large enough pair of vice grip pliers they work well to hold the 2 halves on the threads.

Is there any chance you were using CA or finish and allowed some to drip onto the spur/spindle area? If so I would try dripping a little acetone on there to see if you "glued" it into the spindle and to let the acetone cut the glue.

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#9

Re: None of the Above - Long

John Lucas

>Mark I won't argue that your method is a good one. I have a split nut in my box of tools and it really does work. It's kind of a pain keeping the wrench on the nut but it does work. It's just that most of the time when I have a friend with a stuck drive center I go over and hit it pretty firmly and it always comes out.

Sometimes you can cut a piece of wood the right size and wedge a cold chisel or drift punch inbetween the wood and drive center and knock it out that way. I've used that method on a lathe that didn't have a hollow spindle.

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#10

Re: None of the Above - Long

Brodie Brickey

>No CA Glue was used in the making of this situation. Its kind of funny, before I put the spur in the taper, I stuck my finger in the taper to make sure it was clear. I'll try the knock out one more time and then go to the nut. Somehow I have to get this thing out tonight so I can finish my projects. I've still got 2 bowls, 6 mugs, and one lidded box to finish.

Thanks for all the advice. I'll let you know how it 'turned' out.

Brodie

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#11

Re: Alternative

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I canned the KO bar that came with my Stubby. Instead I got a 1-1/4x8 flat-cap nut with a 7/8" hole center-drilled in the cap. That goes on and then the drive is inserted. Pops the spur out every time with a fairly light tap on the wrench. I don't have to worry about the KO bar hitting and denting the sides of the taper which will just make matters worse the next time.

All the Poolwood (now Silverdrive) lathes use a drilled capnut as the spur extractor because they're solid spindle lathes. Risk there is you don't want to forget to spin on the extractor nut before you seat the spur. Then your ONLY option is the split-nut method.

I've had spurs get stuck in several lathes. I tried the "hot/cold" "penetrating oil" and "bigger hammer" methods. But the simplest and easiest, and completely reliable way is the split nut routine, which also happens to do better than anything to prevent damage to the tapers because it pulls the spur out rather than pushes it out.

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Alternative

Keith Tompkins

>Perhaps if you do a lot of spindle turning, thread a nut on the spindle before you install the center....that would simplify getting off a stuck center. Moisture from a finger or blowing out the center hole can create rust or corrosion between the center and taper...sounds crazy but old manuals I've read caution against it.

If you regularly hammer the drive center into your stock, the center will distort over time...and eventually gall the spindle. If you mount the drive center in the spindle, then pound the stock into the center, you may end up with a stuck center. (and prematurely failed bearings). Pounding a stuck center out may cause bearing damage....literally pushing them apart .

Regular maintenance...replace the spur center if any sign of damage occurs. None of this will get your center out, but may prevent it from happening again.

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#13

Re: None of the Above - Long

Ian

>marks method worked for me when I got my lathe and the spur was stuck in it for god knows how long.

only thing to add is I bought an extra nut and thread it on the spindle whenever I put in the spur drive. can't even remember where the knockout rod is haven't used it in so long.

IAN

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#14

Re: Alternative

E.T.

>Mark, where did you get the flat cap nut? What does it look like?

TIA. Ed.

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#15

Re: Alternative

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Ed,

I got mine from David Ellsworth when he was importing the Poolewood lathes. You can contact David to see if he has any left. You can easily make one however. All it takes is a plain steel 1-1/4"x8 nut and a 3/4" id flat washer, and either a MAPP gas, oxy acet, or Prestolite torch, and some fluxed bronze brazing rod.

1. Lightly sand one face of the nut and washer.

2. Place the nut, clean side up, on a fireproof surface like a brick or piece of Durock.

3. Carefully center the washer, clean side down, on the nut.

4. Heat them both to medium red hot and carefully apply the brazing around and to the washer/nut seam but without moving the washer. If the brazing doesn't flow out easily, you need the steel hotter.

5. Allow to air cool. No NOT quench in water. you do not want to harden the steel.

You now need to enlarge the hole a bit and make sure it's centered on the spindle. Easiest way is to spin the nut onto your spindle so it bottoms against the washer. Then, if you have a TS drillchuck and a 13/16 or 7/8 metal bit, you can drill the hole dead center. Careful here, you're only drilling through the washer's thickness. Go too far and you'll hit your taper. If no drill, a carefully supported HSS cutter bit like in a hollowing tool can be applied by hand to enlarge the hole the same way as doing a hollowform but with the lathe running SLOW. Check the hole size with your spur center's diameter. Most are 3/4" for #2 MT so just a bit larger will allow the washer to catch the head of the spur as you unscrew the nut but not prevent the spur from seating in the spindle taper properly.

Good luck!

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#16

Re: Alternative

Carole Valentine

>Mark, this makes my mechanically challenged eyes glaze over, but it sounds like something every turner should understand how to do. Do you suppose at some point you could do an article with pictures that could be posted in Articles and Reviews? I suspect I am not the only one who needs pictures on something like this, or maybe my brain is just too muddled right now. :(

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#17

PS 

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>


img

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#18

Re: Alternative

John Lucas

>Mark I'll try to build one of those, sounds like fun. This wouldn't work on my 3/8" drive center or my 1/2" sorby steb center. Thier isn't any metal larger than the morse taper. They also don't have a hole near the tip like my larger spur drives have. The larger spur drives that have this hole would work by just putting a pin through the hole and backing the nut off. You wouldn't need the washer.

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#19

Not A Problem

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I've made these for several of my friends when they couldn't find them elsewhere. I seem to remember that some outfit like McMaster carried something similar for a while, but I've lost the memory of where. They're pretty much identical to a plumbing compression nut. Se the pick below.

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#20

Good Point

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>These need a shoulder flange of the spur for the washer to catch. If the head of the drive is smaller than the MT diameter your only option is a hole and pin setup. TDon't think I'd recommend drilling holes in the spur though. |;-}

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#21

Penatrating oil

David Staeheli

>There are penatrating oils and there are penatrating oils. Something like WD-40 is pretty ho-hum. I used to swear by Liquid Wrench, but a couple of years ago I ran into Kro-oil (sp?). Used a lot in the aircraft repair industry. No way you are going to find it in a box store. I found mine in a bearing supply store. Comes in an orange can. Supposed to penatrate into a billionth of an inch crack.

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#22

Taper Maintenence *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>You raise good points that are too often ignored. People don't realize how precise the morse tapers are or how they work. They hold by friction of metal-to-metal, thus the more uniform the metal surface contact is in tapers, the better the tool will perform. Clean tapers are therefore essential because dust, dirt, or chips will prevent the 2 surfaces from properly meeting. I strongly recommend that everyone buy and use one of the urethane rubber Tapermate cleaners sold by Packard. A quick insert and twist before inserting a spur drive or center keeps the surface clean and clear without removing metal. A wipe of the spur and removal of scratches on its taper surface [which have high spots on their edges] ensures the best possible contact between the male and female surfaces.

For those whose tapers are already scored ["galled"], a hand reamer is the precise cure, although many use a bit of fine emory cloth or sandpaper on a stick. The problem with using abrasives is that they leave behind small grains of imbedded grit in the metal surface. In use, these just make more galls. A hand reamer can often be borrowed from a turning club or friendy machine shop, but can be purchased from ENCO for less than $35. Insert the reamer and GENTLY give a FEW twists using a hand wrench and the surface of the taper will be renewed with any high spots, scratches, and galls removed. ENCO currently has their hand reamers on sale at ridiculously low prices at the link. SPECIAL NOTE, these hand reamers are NOT to be used for cleaning because they will REMOVE METAL FROM THE TAPER each time they are used. It's all too easy to screw up your spindle or TS quill by using these too much. Cleaning should be done with the Tapermate rubber cleaner mentioned above.


ENCO Reamers

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#23

PS - Taper Mate @ Packard  *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>


Packard

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#24

Re: That is a deal- thank's Mark!!

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: Help my spur drive is stuck!

#25

Did you get it out!

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>