Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

foot size on vessels

Posts

foot size on vessels

#1

foot size on vessels

John Lucas

>I've photographed probaly 200 ceramic and glass vessels in the last month and I've noticed that the ceramic vessels almost always have a larger foot that we turners put on our pieces. The glass pieces probably more closely resemble the foot sizes that turners use. I thought it might be fun to discuss this again. I know it's been hashed around and thier isn't really a right or wrong. I think large feet look bad on some vessels and small feet don't work on funcional pieces. What do you all use as a criteria for the right foot size for your pieces.

Re: foot size on vessels

#2

Brad Vietje

Re: foot size on vessels

Brad Vietje

>John,

I tend toward too small, I think. I have also noted the larger ceramic and glass foot size, and I wonder if it is because everyone understands that glass is breakable ? Of course, wood is, too, so maybe we're fooling ourselves with tiny little feet. I've lost a few pieces because they were too small-footed, and a potential "customer" (shopper? browser? klutz?) knocked them over.

I'm starting to feel like I ought to make most feet a little larger, and occasionally make a piece just for me or for a display case that has a smaller foot.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: foot size on vessels

#3

George Balock

Re: foot size on vessels

George Balock

>John,

I wonder if it has to do with how these objects are made? Ceramic turned on a wheel needs a larger base to drive the piece, while the glass is held on a punt with a much smaller surface area. As woodturners, we can pick the size of the base we want. Sometimes it's too small. Most times it too big.

George

Re: foot size on vessels

#4

Re: foot size on vessels

Russ Babbitt

>A lot depends on whether the piece if for show or made to functional. The functional pieces need a bigger foot to be stable so their contents don't spill. The art pieces can be quite graceful to enhance their looks. Their are probably a set of "rules" for foot size. Off the top of my head I don't know them.

Re: foot size on vessels

#5

Re: foot size on vessels

TDRice

>I agree with Russ about large feet on functional items and small on decorative but you can overdo it in both directions. Much like size 16 feet on an attractive but hard working woman, or the chinese womens bound feet in the past.

Snowing sideways in Erie, Colorado

Re: foot size on vessels

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: foot size on vessels

Keith Tompkins

>John, you bring up a good point. I see many glass pieces with a distinct foot which narrows to a tiny diameter where it joins the vessel. If you turn something resembling that, you will be criticized to no end by other turners (from personal experience) while those in other crafts like it a great deal. This kind of foot has been done for centuries, yet it is taboo in wood turning. Seems one person's myopic views have great influence in the turning world.

Like the idea of tiny opening in vessels,and consistant and uniform wall thickness, the tiny footprint favored by turners has become another stumbling block to artistic expression, IMO.

Potters and glassblowers often celebrate differences in wall thickness....and foot styles. Should we?

Re: foot size on vessels

#7

Re: foot size on vessels

Russ Babbitt

>I think Keiths work proves we should explore all opportunities. A lot of inspiration comes from other media. Perhaps glass pieces usually use large feet for safety. Maybe woodturners are stretching technique beyond glass blowers.

Re: foot size on vessels

#8

Re: foot size on vessels

John Veerkamp

>I tend to like a minimal foot but I don't follow any rules. Each piece I turn has a unique profile, includiny the foot. The shape of the piece as well as the wood itself determine the foot size for me. For a beautiful piece of wood I don't want to detract with a big foot, but sometimes a plain piece can be greatly enhanced with a foot that lifts it up for the eye to see, Some thoughts.

John

Re: foot size on vessels

#9

Re: foot size on vessels

Andy Blackwell

>The best advice that I've seen was from a designer in Australia who said the a tall piece should not only look balanced it should be balanced.

Re: foot size on vessels

#10

Re: foot size on vessels

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>So John, what if I was to turn an amphora? ;-) I guess that would skew things a bit (so to speak).

Bill

Re: foot size on vessels

#11

Re: foot size on vessels

John Lucas

>Bill I had to look that one up. We don't use big words in the South. That's an interesting piece. My book says it has handles which is why most turners don't turn this. I think Bruce Hoover may have done one. It would probably be a funcional piece so you would think the foot would be bigger to keep it from being tippy. It also looks like it would be a little top heavy. For us rednecks it's a good two fisted beer mug and we won't set it down until it's empty so the foot size wouldn't matter.

Re: foot size on vessels

#12

Re: foot size on vessels

Russ Fairfield

>Bowls with large feet, small feet, and no feet all have their place. It depends on what we want from a bowl. Some people like bowls with a foot and others don�t. Trends and fads also change; the latest fad is the smooth bottomed bowl.

It makes a difference whether the bowl is "artistic" or "useable". Useable bowls usually have big feet, artistic bowls don't. It is difficult to make the bowl that is both artistic and useful at the same time. We have achieved "perfection" when we are successful. We end up with "awkward" when we aren't.

Re: foot size on vessels

#13

Re: foot size on vessels

Rick Davenport

>I agree with Jon Veerkamp.

My strategy is to let the wood and my eye make the decision.

Often I have a preconceived notion, but am open to changes as the project develops.

And then there is my contrary nature (which is why I am self employed).

Give me a rule and I'll break it.

Show me a trend and I'll buck it.

Irreverantly yours,

R

Re: foot size on vessels

#14

Re: foot size on vessels

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>John, sorry to send you to the dictionary! Well, not really... ;-) But I think you remember our time together in Louisville, with all those beers we consumed - unless you consumed too many! My neck is as red as they get, and I have a lot of southern blood in me. But I do like those big words. And now I am thinking about really turning an amphora. I guess I'll have to figure out how to do the handles.

Bill