We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I have just finished a butternut bowl, I have two coats of minwax tungoil on it, my wife would like it as a salad bowl, I have some lee valley salad bowl finish(a liquid) and claphmans wax finish, is one better than the other or will either work, or is there a better finish to use thanks for any help ron in Kingston
>All modern finishes, once cured are food safe. Any finish will "work" but there are some considerations. Varnish type finishes can chip and be a pain to repair, shellac can dissolve and also chip. I use Watco followed by buffing on nearly everything however with salad bowls and cutting boards I most often use sunflower oil. It can be easily used to restore the finish, simply pour it on and rub it in, it's inexpensive, it's the least likely of all food oils to go rancid, can be purchased at the local supermarket, all of these are useful to the end user.
>I prefer to use mineral oil myself. It's super cheap and can be purchased at a drugstore.
I believe Richard Raffan uses a mineral oil and bees wax combination. And if I remember correctly (and I have been know to be wrong), that is exactly what is in Tried and True's food safe finish.
>Ron, whenever I make an item that is to be used with food I don't put anything on it that I wouldn't eat! This really isn't a reflection on how "Safe" any particular finish is but more of how the people buying or using my bowls perceive risk.
I used to use mineral oil and paraffin but I've had people shy away from mineral oil because it's a petroleum product - never mind that you give it to babys as a mild laxative.
I now use food grade walnut oil (at the coop or market, check the label for no "extras" it's used for cooking) and paraffin or beeswax. Someone with a nut allergy might object so I make sure to point out that I use walnut oil.
Seeing how it's for you own use it's up to you. I don't know if there is any risk to have started with the minwax tung oil - make sure that it's good and dry!
Read Russ's corner in the menu on your left. I just reread this because of another discussion below. There is a wealth of information. The section on Tung oil also has a discussion of other oils and talks about "food safe" finishes.
>the difference is in the way you maintain the bowl, in my experience. I have half a dozen bowls turned 6-8 years ago that we regularly use around the house. Mike Mahoney and his lovely wife, at least a number of years ago, used only wooden plates, bowls and other utensils. He told me he felt a woodturner should only use wood. They didn't do a lot to maintain the pieces, I would guess primarily because they had almost a limitless supply. (Mike turns ~ 20 bowls a day in production mode, maybe more). They probably use his walnut oil and wax finish now, since he markets it, and it does a really good job according to many.
We are careful to wash out the bowls with a soapy cloth, and dry them with a dishtowel. I don't let them sit with water in them any longer, because they can develop cracks from that. DAMHIKT.
Almost all of them were finished with a Watco type finish, and not a lot of coats of that. Most of them still look like they have just come from the studio. Now, we don't use them for pasta, beans, or stews, but salad dressing (Olive Oil) seems to replenish the shine nicely, and the butter in microwave popcorn keep my favorite bowl looking beautiful. (Only one of my many vices, naturally...)
Never had anything go rancid, but then again I use close-grained woods for bowls. I don't think it matters much at all, in the final analysis. I've sold a ton of bowls, and have yet to have a client ask about food safe concerns. Ask yourself, what are the ten dollar wooden bowls at Target finished with? Would you think to ask if you wanted to buy one?