Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Beall Treen Mandrel?

Posts

Beall Treen Mandrel?

#1

Beall Treen Mandrel?

Joe Pack

>I am considering adding small boxes to my craft show lineup. I need to produce them quickly and accurately in order to make them worthwhile profit-wise...my typical craft show customer has a "price point," and doesn't care whether the item took 10 minutes or 1 hour to make, as long as it is attractive and the cost is "reasonable."

A couple of years ago, when I first got started turning for craft shows, I saw the Beall treen mandrel. At the time I was (1) not confident enough to tackle making such items in quantity for sale and (2) not pleased that the I.D. was limited to 1 1/4". Now, they offer an expansion kit that will allow for 1 1/2" and 2" I.D. holes which sound like they would be more marketable.

It would seem that, with this system, a lot of time spent hollowing and test-fitting could be saved by drilling the blank with a Fostner bit, then fitting the blank and top to the mandrel and guides for turning the outside. I am curious, though, if this mandrel system is actually workable/practical, or if it is a "miracle broom" type product.

I know I can learn to hollow boxes, but, if this system can save a great deal of time, I can produce more items for sale in the same amount of time. As they say, whoever "they" is, "time is money." Don't get me wrong - I don't sell junk. I may make quite a bit, but I don't sell it. :-) I'm just looking to crank up the "production" machine if I can.

If you have any experience with the Beall treen system, would you mind sharing?

Thanks. And merry Christmas to all.

Re: Beall Treen Mandrel?

#2

Re: Beall Treen Mandrel?

john lucas

>Joe I'm not familiar with the Beal Treen kit but you should look at how Chris Stott makes boxes. I think he has a book. His basic technique is to use a parting tool to make the cut that will be the start of parting off the lid. Make this cut wide enough for the lip and the thing parting tool cut. Now use the thin parting tool to cut the lid off but leave a very thin ring of the initail part. This makes it very quick to hollow and fit the lid. You just hollow until that thin ring just dissappears and it will be a snug fit for the tenon lip that you left on the bottom.

I must not be awake this morning, I part off the bottom and leave the lid in the chuck. Hollow the lid and then put the bottom in. This way you eliminate one step.

Chris can turn a box with a snap fit lid in 1 minute, just to show off of course. He says it takes a about 3 to 5 minutes per box depending on size and shape. That's sanding and finishing and everything. I'm a little slower because I don't make enough and every box is different so it takes me about 15 to 30 minutes for a relatively plain box, nothing as fancy as my finial boxes with feet.

Re: Beall Treen Mandrel?

#3

Re: Beall Treen Mandrel?

David Walser

>Joe,

I've never used the Beall Treen Mandrel, but I did spend some time reading up on it in response to your post. It looks like a will made piece of equipment (as you'd expect from Beall), but I have three concerns:

First, I don't think you'll be satisfied with the finish inside the box. After you use a forstner bit to drill out the box blank, you mount the blank on the mandrel. The mandrel's outside edge mates up with the outside ring cut by drill bit. This locks the blank on the mandrel well enough for you to turn the outside. It also means that the bottom of the box will still have the tell tale marks of a hole drilled by a forstner bit. That's just not what most of us want the inside of a box to look like.

Second, the lid is made up of two pieces -- the "top" and a "plug" glued or screwed on that makes a friction fit on the inside of the box (like a cork in a bottle). As the wood changes with the seasons, won't the join between top and the plug become more and more obvious? Wouldn't this distract from the piece? Even if it does not, having the plug stick down 1/2 inch inside the box is going to take up a lot of useful room. The boxes are going to be small to begin with, this type of lid is going to occupy a lot of the boxes' capacity.

Third, I'm sure that you could get up quite a production with this method. Turn twenty boxes, turn twenty tops, turn twenty tops, and then turn twenty plugs. And then assemble the tops and plugs and then match up the lids with the boxes. If you aren't matching the grain, you might save some time. If you are, it seems like you might be spending a lot of time changing your set up. Once you learn how, turning a box the "regular" way just doesn't take that much time. Honest.

Re: Beall Treen Mandrel?

#4

Re: Beall Treen Mandrel?

David Walser

>Wow! Please excuse all the typos in my post, above. I may have set a new WC record!

Re: Beall Treen Mandrel?

#5

Re: Beall Treen Mandrel?

Joe Pack

>Thanks David. I see what you mean about the room taken up and the interior finish. Those are things I need to think about. I only sell things I would be proud of. I will take a look at these possible problems.