We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Adding shot to a handle has been done for a long time with claims that the vibration from turning is reduced. Has any company done a real test to find out how much the vibration is reduced? Does the shot really counter act the forces or is it the extra weight from the shot that makes the tool feel better? I'm sure the shot does resonant in the handle but does 6 - 10oz's of shot really reduce vibration. Is this fact or hype?
I made my own aluminum handles, some filled with shot and some solid aluminum. Besides the weight difference there is no noticable vibration in either.
>I made a wooden handle for a detail gouge and put some shot in it. It perhaps does feel better balanced, it did give the handle+gouge more mass alright and perhaps damped the vibrations better. Probably would have to try some tests with and without shot. I have some doubt that it was really worth the bother.
However, and a big however it is, I have only done one and I would scarcely say I was any sort of an authority on the issue.
>Well, Doug, I have used Glaser tools for quite a few years now, and wonder if the vibration damping is really necessary. Properly oriented, there really shouldn't be a tremendous amount of vibration, in my experience. I do remember a lot more of it years ago when I struggled to get a bowl gouge to cut correctly. I only notice much bounce now when I'm roughing out a big blank. Otherwise, the gouge just sings. I credit that to experience and diligent application of what I've learned and discovered along the way. I've seen some of your work, if memory serves, and I'd imagine you have accomplished the same. Don't you turn hats?
I do, however, like the shot effect in the handle for other reasons. I like the way it seems to offset the turning forces a bit in positions other than just a level cut, and the way the weight adjusts to the level of the tool. It just makes it work better, IMHO. I notice a wide variance among the other gouges I have. The Glaser Scraper with the shot-filled handle, though it's not used much, works much better than a wooden handled one, as well. That may be because of the vibration damping, I guess.
All-in-all, I think there are benefits to the shot beyond vibration damping, but it seems to help most folks in one way or the other, or the Glaser type tools wouldn't be nearly as popular as they are.
Pricey, too!
The handles can be COLD, though, if I've not kept the fire going in the wood burner that heats the studio. Easily fixed, by standing them up on top of the stove, leaning them against the stovepipe while I sit on a log section and watch the fire get started, and drink my last cup of coffee. When I'm done, they're warm.
That's a really good part of any day spent in the studio.
I own a Glaser with shot in the handle. I also have a Sweazey that I turned the handle for out of bubinga. I like both tools a lot. I don't think I would add shot to the Sweazey or remove it from the Glaser. Bottom line, its not worth it to me to add the shot, but if I have a tool that comes with it, I'll leave it that way.
>Thanks for your input. It seems to me the theory that the shot resonants to stop vibration doesn't hold water but the extra weight adds to the feel of the tool. I like the balance of a heavy handle and after a few trials found out a 3lb. handle feels good to me. This works well on a large blank. Doug your memory is correct and a larger chain sawn blank will beat you up for the first 5 minutes until the corners are knocked off.
>My personal opinion is that adding shot to a tool to reduce vibration is "much ado about nothing".
Vibration at the cutting edge is usually caused by unsupported wood. That is controlled by giving support to the wood with a rest. A different and/or sharper cutting tool will help. I have never found that shot in the tool handle did anything to reduce this kind of vibration at the cutting edge of the tool.
Dull tools will also vibrate, but lead in the handle won't solve that problem. What we need to do is get the lead out of our ....., and go to the grinder more often.
For myself, I like a tool that is balanced in my hand as I grip it by the swell behind the ferrule. I should be able to open my hand, and it stays there. I have learned that I can use this tool for long periods of time without fatigue, and I can swirch rools without having to adjust for any differences in weight and balance. I add weight to a wood handle to achieve this "balance". I use shot because it is available, convenient, and the amount is easilly adjustable. It is also easy to take some of it out as the tool gets shorter and the handle gets heavier. It has nothing to do with any vibration qualities.
A tool will also vibrate when it is too far out over the tool rest and it starts to flex. In that case, vibration is from improper use of the wrong tool; and we can't overcome that with something we add to the tool handle.
A tool will also bounce around in uneven wood, but that has nothing to do with vibration.
To me, tool control is all about leverage and movement.
For bowl gouges and scrapers, that is easier to do with a longer handle that I can lock into my body. A longer handle means that I may not need to add any weight to reach the balance point. At the other end of the scale, I will sometimes remove all of the handle that is behind my hand on a spindle gouge because it is more maneuverable with the shorter handle.
I like the metal handles because I like the adjustable tool length and I like to remove the tool for sharpening because it is easier. I hate the metal handles because all of them are way too heavy for me. The best of all worlds is a removeable tool in a wood handle, and that is now available.
This is what works for me. Someone else will have different preferrences. Neither of us are wrong, just different.
>I can tell you, from a purely physics point of view, that adding weight, changing the shape, size , etc. of a tool handle will definitely change its spacial and frequency modes of vibration; and when that happens, depending on all sorts of variables, the turner may like the new feel of the tool or not. I 'm almost certain that one can't say this or that change will always be better for everyone.
Stereo nuts (like myself) are forever debating the pros and cons of such vibration concerns surrounding the design of stereo tables, little cone feet under their components and speakers, speaker cabinet vibration, etc. etc. It's really a difficult issue in mechanical engineering to deal with vibration. It's a HUGE issue for rotating machinery -- think high speed jet engine. It turns out (pardon the pun ) that the equations that govern the vibration of a rod ( a tool handle) and those for a rotating rod -- think spindle turning -- are remarkably similar.
>Metal like steel and to a lesser extent aluminum, like to vibrate, resonate and sing. That's because those metals have a very low damping factor. Lead shot helps to damp the vibrations because lead has a higher damping factor. (Ever hear a piece of lead sing?) Shot also helps because its motion will dampen the vibration just like the shot in a dead-blow hammer.
On the other hand, wood has a moderate damping factor so it will absorb the vibration without the need for shot. IMHO, the only reason to add shot to a wood handle is to change its weight and balance point. I've found that a solid plug of lead is just as effective and a lot easier than messing around with shot.
>As the initial poster... let me explain more... I'm interested in some vibration dampening, but I'm really mostly interested in changing the balance point and overall weight. I have several wood (unweighted) tools that are too light and a Glaser... I like the solid feel and balance of the Glaser and want to replicate that feel... thus the question about lead shot.
>David, thank you for original post because it brought up this question. IMO shot will improve the balance/feel to any tool handle and shot has the best weight/cost ratio. I've found sand works well to add a little weight. The lenght of the handle is important too.
Thank goodness we have a choice to use wood, steel or aluminum to make our handles and a choice of tool steel. We would have nothing to talk about if we didn't have a choice.
>Given what you just posted, it would seem that we're back to shot -- not fixed weights-- because one of the features of the Glaser handles is that the shot moves as you shift the tool around. You're not going to get this shifting weight property from fixed weights.
>Here's another thought. If you are considering various materials to use for a tool handle and are concerned about the purely vibrational issue, you should look up two quantities for each of the candidate materials: the bulk modulus of elasticity and the density. Then calculate the ratio of these quantities, i.e. divide the bulk modulus by the density. You should tend to favor the one with a smaller ratio. Lead, for example, actually has a high bulk modulus(which is not so good), but it is so dense that the ratio is small, which is good. But you wouldn't want the whole tool made of lead - obviously too heavy. I know this stuff is way too technical for this forum, but I bet guys like Glaser knew all about it.