Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

First Post

Posts

First Post

#1

First Post

James Fox

>Long-time lurker here. First posting. Fourth or fifth bowl that I've turned. Started with pens as many do and progressed (hopefully)from there. Cherry, undercut rim, 5 1/2 by 2 1/5, oiled, waxed & buffed. Critiques always welcome--shape, finish, technique, etc. Photography critiques/advice also welcome (Thank you Mr.'s Lucas & Donaldson, et al).

I would like to thank all who give advice, ask/answer questions, post photos of your work, and just generally hang out here. You have no idea how many folks you help and encourage each day by your participation in this site.

James


img

Re: First Post

#2

Brad Vietje

Looks great, James.

Brad Vietje

>I like it a lot -- if you are a beginner at making bowls I have 2 comments: 1- It doesn't show. 2- If you get any better, you're going to make some great looking stuff !

To be REALLY picky, I'd roll that upper curve in a little more gradually on the outside so there isn't as sharp a transition. If you make more of these, you can try subtle differences in the profile, and see what really seems to work best. Based on your apparent skills, all will look good, but a few will really pop, and rise to the next level.

Fine job -- nice bowl.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: First Post

#3

Welcome Jamie

Ron in Drums PA

>I like your bowl!

Re: First Post

#4

Re: First Post

George Van

>Nice job James, you must have spent some time on the curve to get it this good. I wish my first bowl looked this good, keep turning and posting!

Re: First Post

#5

Re: First Post

John Lucas

>Good job James. I like the shape. Lighting wise I would raise the left light. It's a little too side lit. Probably raise it and move it forward a little, at least for this piece. I'm not sure why you have a pink cast to the background, at least it looks like that on my computer.

Re: First Post

#6

Re: First Post

Steve Russell

>Hello James and Welcome!

Very nice bowl, the undercut rim really adds to this piece. If we can help you with anything, please do not hesitate to ask. Take care and best wishes to you and yours!

Better Woodturning and Finishing Through Chemistry...

Steve Russell

Eurowood Werks Studio

Re: First Post

#7

Re: First Post

James Fox

>Hi John--Recommendation to move the left light would lessen the hot-spot on left--correct??? Pink cast may be because I am color blind. Although "color blind" is a misnomer. Not blind to color, but I have great difficulty telling reds and greens (and all their variations--also some blues and pruples) apart.

Thanks for the suggestion about the light.

James

Re: First Post

#8

Wait until you are so old

Don Henthorn

>your buy a new tool because you forgot you already have one. (G)

Re: First Post

#9

Re: For a first post, very well.....

Jamie Donaldson

>....done, and the bowl looks quite good as well. As far as the photo, I would prefer a softer light that renders less obvious shadows- bounce it off a white panel rather than aiming straight at the turning. Moving the light as John suggested will have little effect on the highlight, and its fine as is- shows the surface is shiny.

Re: First Post

#10

Thanks to all for comments

James Fox

>