Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Poll: Hollowing Options

Posts

Poll: Hollowing Options

#1

Poll: Hollowing Options

Greg Haugen

>If you only could choose one option for hollowing. Would it be freehand or captured? And Why? What "brand" do you prefer?

Mine would be freehand. I don't own a captured system even though I have tried out the two most common systems and I just really like the "freedom" and feel of freehand hollowing. There are alot of days its almost therapy. I also like to concentrate on facegrain oriented forms. I like having some options with playing with the sapwood and the grain orientation to add a little extra to the piece. I do prefer John Jordan's hollowers and armbrace handle as most of you know. They are still running the 10% discount until Christmas, just mention "Wood Central" when ordering. Not associated in any way with the Jordan's. Just a happy customer. www.johnjordanwoodturning.com

Anybody use the "Mighty O" system??

Greg

Re: Poll: Hollowing Options

#2

Brad Vietje

Freehand

Brad Vietje

>I prefer freehand or hand-held. Why ? Well, that's hard to say -- feels more authentic somehow. I have and use a captured system (home built) but only for larger pieces where the laser measuring helps me down mear the bottom. If I had to make a lot of these, I might use the captured boring bar more, as there would be less stress on my elbow and shoulder, which have previous injuries that never seem to heal completely.

Brand ? I use home-made, Hosaluk, and John Jordan most of all.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Poll: Hollowing Options

#3

Freehand

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>I use a mixed bag for my hollowing. I mostly use the Scorpion armbrace with 1/2" Kelton hollowers for things 4-6" deep. For smaller turnings, I use the Kelton mini-hollowers in their handle. I also own and and use the Sorby multi-tip and two sizes of Sorby curved neck hollowing tools. I expect that if I were to do a piece deeper than 6", I would use the Scorpion, although I have not done anything deeper than 6".

keithz

Re: Poll: Hollowing Options

#4

50/50 captured vs hand

John Lucas

>When I use the captured bar system I'm so relaxed. Little or no chance of a catch I use a lazar pointer so I know where the tool is, it's just very secure and relaxing. I don't do enough hollowing of larger work to be really comfortable with the handheld cutter. I use a homemade version of the John Jordan bars and use these quite a bit to turn smaller stuff or weird shapes that are hard to get to with the captured bar system. My captured bar system is a homemade version of the lyle jamieson bar and I use the John Jordan style cutters in this tool.

Re: Poll: Hollowing Options

#5

Re: Freehand

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>I have a number of tools but my favorite is the Scorpion with the armbrace.

Norm

Re: Poll: Hollowing Options

#6

Re: Both

Allen Neighbors

>Greg, I always start all of my hollowforms freehand, using the Scorpion Armrest, and a couple of smaller homemade toolbars. Due to my familial tremor, since I made the captured rig, I always use it.

Now that I have refined the Laser mount, it is indispensable (sp).

With a little more practice, I should be able to get consistant thicknesses throughout the piece, and that is my goal.

The first pic is the Captured Rig on the lathe.

The second pic shows the "unrefined" laser mounting.


img

Re: Poll: Hollowing Options

#7

Re: I should have added...

Allen Neighbors

>that since I have the captured rig, I always use it to 'finish' up the hollowing.


img

Re: Poll: Hollowing Options

#8

Re: Poll: Hollowing Options

joaz

>When I first started hollowing, I used the Ellsworth hand held system. After a few nasty catches that resulted in hand, wrist and shoulder injuries I went to the Jamison system and now use the Kelton system with Jamison bar and cutters.

No more catches or injuries.

I hollow boxes and goblets with straight scraper and my own shear scraping tool by hand.

Re: Poll: Hollowing Options

#9

Brad Vietje

Re: I should have added...

Brad Vietje

>Nice looking machine, Allen -- looks like a pleasure to use.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Poll: Hollowing Options

#10

Captured

Russ Babbitt Jr.

>Never did like the look of the armbrace system. Just seems wrong to me. It's been the standard handheld system for years so it obviously works. I use the Jaimeson system with adapters made to fit other hollowing cutters like Keltons. I like to turn easy, the captured system gives me that.

Re: Poll: Hollowing Options

#11

Dick Hines

Re: Both

Dick Hines

>I do free hand on ornaments and small HFs up to 6" anything over that and I have my Keltom 3/4" set. I like the captive system on large things.

Re: Poll: Hollowing Options

#12

Re:Allen- that lathe is entirely too....

Jamie Donaldson

>...clean- don't you ever use it??!! I learned hollowing freehand a la Ellsworth,then added the Stewart handle, and for larger work a modified Jamieson D handle with Jordan cutters. But I always finish interiors freehand with the Stewart handle and small scraper on the hook tool shaft- gives me the most feel and control.

Re: Poll: Hollowing Options

#13

Re: Captured

Donna Banfield

>I have the Jamieson captured bar system; I've also used the Oneway hollowing system. I like the Oneway for the superior laser set-up, but am not as pleased with the 'D' section of the bar. It's a flat bar, as opposed to rolled and seems to 'drag' on the secondary tool rest. And yes, I've 'rounded' over the edges, which doesn't seem to help. Best world would be a colloboration of the two systems, which will take the help of a friend with a metal lathe. Working on that...

Here's something to consider for everyone thinking about a hollowing system. When I discovered woodturning, my first lathe was a Craftsman 15". I quickly outgrew that lathe and was lucky to find a used Oneway 2436 on the internet for sale. I drove nearly 4 hours in a Nor'easter (November snow/ice storm) with a covered UHaul to pick it up. In that shop were nearly two dozen home made 'spears' that the original owner used for hollowing, which he held in the Dennis Stewart arm brace system. When I asked him why he was selling the lathe, he replied that he got a very bad catch 1 1/2 years ago, which tore every ligament and tendon in his shoulder. It still wasn't healed, and he hadn't been able to turn since then, either.

I want to turn until "you can pry my cold, dead fingers off my tools" -- so that's why I use a captured boring bar.

Re: Poll: Hollowing Options

#14

Re:Jamie, my MIL always said,

Allen Neighbors

>"cleanliness is next to Godliness." :o)

I blow the chips off when I blow them out of a form. I clean the ways everytime my toolrest sticks on me. I clean the floor when I start stumbling around. :o)

Back when I was a photographer, people used to call me an artist, because my studio was always in a mess. One lady said, "You must be an artist, because you certainly are a slob." :o)

Now I catch it for cleanliness... what is one to do???........ :o)

Re: Poll: Hollowing Options

#15

Re: Captured

Greg Haugen

>I see a few issues. Stories like this are very easy to tell and to accuse the armbrace handle guilty. When in fact there are a few issues that need to be addresses. These "homemade spears" tools are "holding a smoking gun" if you will. Far too often I think "homemade" tools are an issue especially with hollowing. Far too often a hook tool becomes an "angled tool." If the cutting tip isn't in line with the shaft bad things can happen. Even if you come back saying they were you don't know the sharpness or metal used if it was able to do the job it was meant to. In my opinion if you have a Oneway and Stewart handle buying the right tools for it shouldn't be an issue. Now they are people that have the "know how" to make tools. Not everyone does though that makes their own tools. It is also hard to decide the skill level of the person and what he was actually doing at the time of catch.

The same story could be "someone doesn't turn bowls because someone told them that they broke a gouge and got hurt." Well its a story and its hard to justify it when the facts were they used a 3/4" roughing gouge (new people never use it on bowls) to turn a 13.5" bowl on a 14" lathe, and it's their first bowl.

You can argue this guy was a "turning god" and "tool making expert" but the facts are there are issues in any story that can be swung either way.

I think next to the skew the armbrace handle gets the worse reputation. Yes a spindle gouge can roll a bead and yes a captured system can make a vessel. Either option isn't bad. Both negative reputations are totally undeserved.

Just to clarify.

Greg