Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help

Posts

Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help

#1

Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help

Bill O

>Hi,

As I�m starting to turn, larger, heavier pieces, I am having difficulty in tool bounce & truing up pieces. Even when turning a solid bowl blank, and truing the outside, no matter how much wood I take off the blank, it does not get completely smooth & true and my gouge still bounces a bit. This is very puzzling to me. I�m working on a large solid lathe. My lathe is stable and not vibrating, and as an example of what I�m turning; a 15� diameter Bowl Blank, I am using a large 4�+ tenon, solidly mounted using Large #3 Oneway jaws on a Stronghold, and of course, I�m using the tail stock as support.

I�m starting to think that my tool is not completely cutting on the full rotation, and maybe scraping or just riding over some areas of the wood, leaving some high spots causing tool bouncing problems. Is this possible? Any other suggestions or common things to look for?

Thanks Much in advance, Merry Xmas & Happy Holidays

Bill

Re: Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help

#2

Re: Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help

Rick Allen

>Perhaps you are cutting while applying pressure to the bevel of the tool against the spinning wood.

If this is the case and you are spinning the wood at a moderate speed, say 300 RPM, then you may be moving the tool in and out 5 times a second (more likely 10 times a second). If this is the problem then practice moving the tool along the tool rest and not against the spinning wood.

At higher speeds, say 1000 rpm, you can't move the tool fast enough to achieve this effect.

A way to improve your tool control is to slow the lathe down to 100 rpm or less. At that speed you will detect movement of the tool in and out. You will also imporove your tool control to eliminate that modulation of the tool.

If that is not the cause of your problem then perhapse someone else will have some help for you.

Re: Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help

#3

Re: Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help

Dave Belser

>A 15" bowl blank is a rather large piece! I'm sure others will have advice here are my thoughts.

How hard are you pushing on the gouge? Once a piece gets out of round it can be very difficult to get it round. The other thing would be what speed are you turning at? Sometimes changing the speed a little can make a big difference.

If you are pushing to hard with the gouge you will just aggravate the lumpiness, particularly at low speeds. When you hit a high spot the gouge will be pushed away from the work and then you push it harder into the valley that follows. Think of a washboard road. Just the difference between the end grain and side grain on a bowl blank is can be enough to cause this.

Try using your hand as a stop on the gouge against the tool rest and take light or even intermitant cuts. once it's true take lighter cuts. Change the speed will change the frequency of the bumps this can help if you have hit or setup a harmonic (slight) vibration with your body/tool rest/ gouge.

Hope that helps.

- Dave

Re: Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help

#4

Re: Here are 2 potential reasons that...

Jamie Donaldson

>.....this bumping occurs. 1. The lathe speed could be either too fast or too slow, causing the gouge to act more like a cam follower than a cutting tool. 2. Once the bounce occurs, the method to eliminate is to undercut the surface with a new bevel rubbing cut, slicing off the uneven surface. Surface speeds for large blanks increase as diameter increases, and clean cutting operations must also change to accommodate.

Re: Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help

#5

Re: Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help

Bob Fawcett

>This goes without saying, but I'll say it anyway, make sure your tool is sharp.

I sometimes check the sharpness with my finger. I'll think the tool feels sharp. When I finally take it back to the grinder, it turns out it wasn't so sharp, I'm just fooling myself. Sharpen frequently.

Re: Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help

#6

Re: Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help

Robin Corell

>Another way to get a really problematic area round is by taking light cuts with a diamond point scraper.

Robin Corell

Re: Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help

#7

Re: Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help *LINK*

Derek Andrews

>I would agree with most of the other comments, especially regarding lathe speed. A faster lathe and lighter cuts makes the tool easier to control.

During the initial phase where I am knocking the corners off a blank that has been roughly chainsawn to shape, I don't worry too much about bevel rubbing and quality of cut. I typically use the bottom of the flute where the radius is tightest, and only engage as much of the side of the flute as I can easily control. The name of the game is to remove wood quickly and with minimum strain. Instead of trying to make long, flowing, bowl shaped cuts, I tend to use either short scooping cuts, or short cuts going straight into the wood. It takes some experimentation to find the optimum approach, and at this stage the toolrest needs moving quite often to mimimise tool overhang. I keep going until the 'ghost' has pretty much disappeared from around the spinning wood.

Once I am really close to having a round bowl, I then start to pay more attention to getting a better cut. The bevel now has something to rub against for nearly a whole revolution, so I tend to make longer cuts using the bevel to control direction. I watch the end of the tool. If I see it moving in and out as the bowl turns, I stop, go back and try to make a cut so that this doesn't happen. ***You have to have a steady surface to guide the bevel on, otherwise the problem just perpetuates itself.***

The other point to consider is that if you are turning the bowl in two stages, first green then dry, it really doesn't matter too much if the surface is bumpy after the green turning, because it won't stay that way as it dries.


The ToolRest - a blog for woodturners

Re: Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help

#8

Re: Here are 2 potential reasons that...

John Lucas

>I use the same thing Jamie just mentioned. I start a fresh cut that begins before the vibrating section and try to concentrate on holding the tool against the tool rest and not pushing on the bevel. This usually eliminates any vibration.

Re: Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help

#9

Paul Porter

You are pushing to hard...

Paul Porter

>...with the bevel on the wood. Push DOWN on the tool on the tool rest and take a lighter cut and I think you will see a big difference.

Re: Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help

#10

Re: Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help

Ed Karch

>Unless mounted endgrain, Rotating wood is end grain side grain end grain side grain. Try a speed change and a fresh sharpening on a finely controlled tool.

Re: Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help

#11

Re: Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help

John Lucas

>Ed the piece I just threw away was endgrain, side grain, endgrain, knot, endgrain, rock, side grain. You get the picture. Wasn't worth trying to keep going.

Re: Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Truing & tool bounce on Large pieces -help

Keith Tompkins

>HI Bill, a couple of thoughts....first, how sharp is your tool? In bowl grain orientation, you are cutting face grain, end grain, face grain, etc.. A less than sharp tool will cut differently on different grain; the resulting cuts seem to get worse and worse. Assuming your tools are sharpened correctly, the direction the bevel faces can sometimes cause the same problem....rolling the flute inward towards the cut will sometimes improve the cut.

A speed that is too high will agrivate any problems you are having...wood is going past the tool faster than it can be removed.

Like others said, don't force the cut, let the wood come to the tool. It may help to start a new cut where the bowl is still round,advancing the cut slowly, using less pressure against the wood...you should be able to watch the high spots being turned away.