Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Another hollowing tool option

Posts

Another hollowing tool option

#1

Another hollowing tool option

David Walser

>At last February's Desert Woodturning Roundup, one of the vendors demonstrated the Elbo Tool. I was very impressed. The tool uses an articulated arm clamped to the tailstock quill to control the cutting action. It seemed very slick.

Any of you had a chance to use this tool? If so, what are your thoughts? Here's a link to the maker's web site:

http://www.elbotool.com/index.html

Re: Another hollowing tool option

#2

Ric Taylor

Re: Another hollowing tool option

Ric Taylor

>David,

I bought one a few months ago after seeing his demo at SWAT, and I love it, especially with the carbide cutter attached. I'm getting rid of all of my other deep-hollowing equipment.

Ric

Re: Another hollowing tool option

#3

Re: Another hollowing tool option

Bart Rhoads

>I wouldnt get rid of your others just yet. I bought one also at SWAT. But I am keeping my other ones. Althought I do use it quite often and I think it is one of the best tool to come out in a couple of years it does have it limits. I think 8" deep is a little beyond its limits. Shallower than that it works great.

Re: Another hollowing tool option

#4

Re: Another hollowing tool option

David Walser

>Ric,

Sounds like thy system is working well for you. It looks very tempting: $294 for a "complete" hollowing system -- including laser.

Besides the complete system, have you found a need to add any additional components?

Re: Another hollowing tool option

#5

Re: Another hollowing tool option

eliot d

>I have several hollowing rigs, including the Elbo. I'm not about to give up my others, but,to be sure, I probably reach for this one most -- if the HF is not too deep. Its most obvious drawback is, indeed, built right into its design -- namely that it attaches to the tail stock quill. So, unless your lathe bed is very long, there is a built -in limitation on the depth of the form you can fit in there. The makers of the Elbo do sell some kind of plate or whatever that attaches to the lathe bed and , in effect, lengthens the bed. (In other words, you can attach the tail stock further away from the headstock.) I think it costs about $80. But, when you get so deep the whole thing begins to wobble up and down. It's just nowhere near as sturdy as my SpinDoctor(Keith Clark) outfit, which is built like a tank. But the Elbo is a pleasure to use on smaller sized forms.

Re: Another hollowing tool option

#6

Re: Another hollowing tool option

David Walser

>Thanks, Eliot. That's very good information. You like using the Elbo Tool the best. Can you give us an idea as to why? Is it less trouble to set up, easier to use, gives you more control, or what?

As to the tools limitation, I think that I understand what you are saying. The tool takes up a certain amount of room and must be mounted to your tailstock quill. If you have a short bed lathe you are out of luck. If you have a long bed lathe, the tool STILL takes up enough room that you limited in the size of hollow form you can turn. But isn't this the case with ALL captured tool systems? You need to mount the second "captured" tool rest behind your regular tool rest. Here, too, with most systems, you are out of luck with a short bed lathe. Is the Elbo just worse than the others in this regard or about the same?

Re: Another hollowing tool option

#7

Re: Another hollowing tool option

eliot d

>What I like most about it, for not too large vessels, is that there's is no metal rubbing on any metal. I find whenever there's metal rubbing on metal, there is a tendency for the tools to hang up a bit. I sent back a Kelton for this reason; and , although the Spin Doctor has some great features, it hangs up a lot, and that is very bothersome.( I'm working with Dr. Keith Clark to minimize this problem because I like its mass and other features.)

As for the space problem between the head stock and the tail stock quill, I see what you mean -- but only for certain rigs. If you know the Don Derry rig , for example, there is no tool rest behind the front tool rest. So the space is taken up by the head stock, the vessel, and the front tool rest. The tail stock isn't involved at all. And with the Spin Doctor, there is a front tool rest and the restraining part of the rig behind that, but they can be positioned fairly close together, With the Elbo, you simply have to attach the Elbo elbows and the (perhaps long) tool bar BETWEEN the tail stock quill and the vessel. So there really is more of a space question. As I said, though, the Elbo people do make some sort of extension to deal with this problem to some extent.

Incidently, the easiest one to set up, BY FAR, is the Don Derry. But I find that it hangs up often (again, metal rubbing on metal), and I use it only for fairly small stuff. (At a demo he said he is working on developing a larger model.) To be fair, there are very experienced turners in my club that swear by it. And without question, his laser set up is terrific. When you position it, unlike the others I've tried, it stays absolutely put. With the others, as soon as you tighten something, the laser dot moves. so there's constant fiddling to get it just where you want it. And getting it right is no small matter because, otherwise, you can find yourself cutting through the wall.