Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Belt Sander Sharpening -- REVIEW (long) *LINK*

Posts

Belt Sander Sharpening -- REVIEW (long) *LINK*

#1

Brad Vietje

Belt Sander Sharpening -- REVIEW (long) *LINK*

Brad Vietje

>Since writing this response below, I thought it might get lost, and maybe not noticed by some here, so I decided to re-post as a review piece. In the review below, I am specifically referring to Jon Siegel's sand & buff sharpening system, which can be seen at Jon's site, which also has some great illustrated articles:

FWIW, I've used Jon's sharpening system, as have a lot of turners in northern New England. I've done turning demos at local symposia with this sharpener, and often mention hom much it simplifies and de-stresses the sharpening process. I like it a LOT, so I'll add some review comments below:

What Jon's done is to offer a relatively affordable machine that does most of what Woodcraft's old (and long-ago discontinued) Mark II system did. He uses a 4" wide belt that travels UP, away from the cutting edge. Any rounding (from the belt riding on a thin cushion of air) happens at the heel of the tool, where it is very desirable, but not on the cutting edge, which would be terrible. This is, BTW, the biggest reason for inverting the belt travel. He uses a 60-grit belt for re-shaping, and a 150 grit belt for sharpening. After the tool is sharpened, there is also a thin buffing wheel for de-burring the edge with tripoli or emery, which also polishes the flute a bit, which can help with the edge on many less expensive tools that have slight ridges inside the flutes.

Jon Siegel's system is very quick, very accurate and entirely reproducible. He uses a "V"-block to capture the end of the tool handle, and there are many indexed positions for placing the V-block quickly so you get the same grind each time. For fingernail grinds and bowl gouges, he also offers a stand that replaces the V-block so there is enough room to swing the tool through the arc to acheive the fingernail grind without hitting the indexed baseboard.

The main feature of this system is that you can sharpen and buff a tool about 7 SECONDS, literally. Bowl gouges or fingernail grinds will take 20 seconds or so, because you have to attach the Ellsworth jig or equivalent. This system also produces perfect flat bevels, which Jon also prefers. That's a debate for another post...

BACKGROUND: Jon has taught turning for nearly 40 years, and is considered a top turning "guru" in greater New England. He is a big proponent of using "muscle memory". He has described this as the learned motion of hands, eyes, ears, tool, bevel angle, speed, etc, that are required to get just the right fluid cut on a particular piece. This is built up during roughing cuts, and he teaches that just before your final cut (ultimately the only one that really matters), you want a very keen edge on the tool in use to get the smoothest finishing cut and reduce sanding (which no one likes, and which can distort detail and isn't healthy, either...). If I turn away from my lathe to sharpen or hone my tool and have a frustrating time with a sharpening session, or the process takes too long (read: Tormek), you will lose any aquired muscle memory, and your final cut will be no more accurate that your roughing cuts. I have also seen my dad (when he was alive and turning) and many other turners get all frustrated at the grinder, and turn back to the lathe a few minutes later to ruin a number of pieces because 1- he was now frustrated; 2- he had been away from the workpiece too long to "remember" what smooth, fluid motion he needed to make; and 3- his tool and bevel were not the same shape they were a few moments ago. Turning after frustration could also be said to be dangerous as well. This appears to be a very common problem, especially with beginners, who are VERY likely to struggle with dull tools because sharpening is either not easy or too stressful.

How it works: Assuming I have my V-block set for the tool in my hands (the tool handles and V-block positions can be numbered or color-coded to make that quick, too), I turn away from the spinning lathe, sharpen and buff the tool in about 7 seconds, and I'm right back at my workpiece. The worn 150 grit belt produces a very fine edge which in my view almost never needs to be honed. You will never see a system that's easier and more reproducible for skews, and a slightly curved skew is a real pleasure to sharpen.

As for repeatability and accuracy, there will be a very slight change in the bevel angle as steel is removed from the bevel, since the tool gets a tiny bit shorter. However, unlike other sharpening systems, very little steel is removed. A very light touch is used, and the difference between a sharp tool and a dull one is maybe half of a thousandth of an inch (o.ooo5"), so with a light touch, you can sharpen a tool 2000 times before you lose an inch of HSS. The change in bevel angle is thus very slight and imperceptibly slow, so after a few hundred sharpenings, you can always change v-block positions, or attach something thin to either the V-block or the handle to hold an angle.

When I had very little money, I made a sort of similar system out of a 12" disk sander, with a V-block and indexed positions. I also established positions for my Ellsworth and other fingernail jigs. I'm now pinching pennies again, having just bought a house, but as soon as I can afford it, I plan to buy one of Jon's machines. It doesn't do everything, but everything it does do it does better and faster than any alternative I've yet seen.

That's just one fella's opinion,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT


Big Tree Turning Sharpening System

Re: Belt Sander Sharpening -- REVIEW (long) *LINK*

#2

Re: Belt Sander Sharpening -- REVIEW (long)

David Walser

>Brad,

Thanks for your review. I'm sure many will find it interesting and helpful.

Re: Belt Sander Sharpening -- REVIEW (long) *LINK*

#3

Re: Belt Sander Sharpening -- REVIEW (long)

Allen Neighbors

>Brad, thanks for posting this. That really looks like a way to go for a sharpening system. Too bad I already have the Oneway Wolverine and Varigrind, and today, I finished a homemade jig to sharpen skews.

I like the idea of a flat bevel on my tools, which I don't get on an 8" wheel.

Thanks again.

Re: Belt Sander Sharpening -- REVIEW (long) *LINK*

#4

Brad Vietje

Re: Belt Sander Sharpening -- REVIEW (long)

Brad Vietje

>Thanks Allen,

Truth is, not everyone likes flat bevels, even if they've never used one.

I like a flat grind as a very good compromise between hollow grinds, which seem to work better on spindle work, and convex bevels, which more closely match the inner curve of a bowl. A hollow grind on the inside of a bowl reduces the support at the edge, and often creates a sharp heel that can bruise or scrape the inner bowl surface. While I like flat bevels, many turners do not. In fact, some get pretty steamed at the very idea, since they have always used hollow ground tools off a grinder. I'm not old enough to know much about the history of turning tools, but I suspect we tend to sharpen with grinders because they are there -- many of us already have them -- and they're easy and fast. That alone does not make them the best tool for the job.

People who like to hone their tools have a point about hollow grinds making it easier to maintain the bevel by having two surfaces to support the hone or stone. True 'nuff, but honing creates a small flat bevel behind the cutting edge, so they are really using a very narrow flat bevel that could be better supported if the bevel were flat, too. Tools that come off a worn 150 belt and tripoli or emery wheel are pretty darned sharp, but you can hone them a few times before they begin to round over or loose their geometry -- usually you won't have to.

Lately I've been sharpening some tools with an 8" grinder and honing with diamond hones. Can create very sharp edges, but I find the flat bevels a little more forgiving.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Belt Sander Sharpening -- REVIEW (long) *LINK*

#5

Re: Belt Sander Sharpening -- REVIEW (long)

Colin Spencer

>Brad

Thanks for the review, sounds very interesting. Robert Sorby have just introduced their version of this in the UK, but with the current exchange rate and the voltage issue (240 vs 110) John's is probably the one to go for in the US and Sorby's for Europe.

Colin

Re: Belt Sander Sharpening -- REVIEW (long) *LINK*

#6

Re: Belt Sander Sharpening -- REVIEW (long)

David Walser

>Thanks, Colin. The Robert Sorby unit is interesting, but of little use to those of us on this side of the pond.

Here's a link to the description of the Sorby unit:

http://www.robert-sorby.co.uk/

Re: Belt Sander Sharpening -- REVIEW (long) *LINK*

#7

Re: Belt Sander Sharpening -- REVIEW (long) *LINK*

Darrell Feltmate

>I thought this sounded familiar, then I looked at the link. I saw this demoed about 10 years ago in New Hampshire. It certainly is a nice system. on the other hand I already own a grinder so...


Around the Woods

Re: Belt Sander Sharpening -- REVIEW (long) *LINK*

#8

Re: Belt Sander Sharpening -- REVIEW (long)

Allen Neighbors

>Brad, I had an old 6X48 Sears table sander, and today I converted it into one of these sharpening systems. It works just beautifully on my spindle gouges, skews, wood chisels, but I have to make some modifications if I want to use it for my bowl gouges.

Thanks for posting this. It has improved my sharpening habits. :o)

Re: Belt Sander Sharpening -- REVIEW (long) *LINK*

#9

Brad Vietje

Re: Belt Sander Sharpening -- REVIEW (long)

Brad Vietje

>Thanks for the Sorby post, David. I like their site, which seems much nicer than I remember from previous visits (?)

Maybe with a major tool manufacturer promoting systems like these, they'll gain more acceptance. I think turners need to actually TRY flat bevels before discounting them out of hand -- believe it or not, they work very well. The Sorby system would be just a tad better with a thin buffing wheel to remove the burr edge, and smooth the flute.

Safe spinnig,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT