Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Making a Bowl Gouge

Posts

Making a Bowl Gouge

#1

Making a Bowl Gouge

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>I have 2 roughing gouges. Any chance I could make a functional bowl gouge out of one of them

Cheers

Dan Clermont

Re: Making a Bowl Gouge

#2

Brad Vietje

NO

Brad Vietje

>Sorry Dan,

The main feature of a bowl gouge is a deep flute milled and ground out of a very stiff, round stock. The entire diameter of that round bar stock enters that handle to create a much stronger connection than the tang of a forged roughing gouge. Others will have other reasons, I'm sure, but the bowl gouge usually reaches further over the rest and gets into some pretty stressful situations, which would cause the tang to break on most roughing gouges.

The big and meaty P&N gouges might represent a different possiblity, but I'm not qualified to say.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Making a Bowl Gouge

#3

Re: Don't even consider it, for.....

Jamie Donaldson

>.. many practical and safety reasons. The roughing gouge is not configured for bowl turning, and why waste your time and resources when buying a real bowl gouge would be a much better alternative?

Re: Making a Bowl Gouge

#4

Thanks Everyone

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>I think I have heard enough ;)

I thought it might be as simple as changing the profile but obviously not

Cheers

Dan C

Re: Making a Bowl Gouge

#5

Talking about a roughing gouge!

Ron in Drums PA

>On the Woodworking channel last nite, The American Woodshop was on and there was Scott (I think that's his name) using a 1-1/4" roughing gouge on a 14" faceplate turning. I don't know what he was turning, I had to turn it off after seeing that, but it looked like a bowl to me.

Re: Making a Bowl Gouge

#6

Re: Talking about a roughing gouge!

David Walser

>I believe there is an AAW sponsored movement to rename the roughing gouge as the "spindle roughing gouge" to emphasize it is ONLY for spindle work. Unfortunately, there are lots of turners who use the roughing gouge for face work. Unfortunate because it steers new turners in the wrong direction. Also unfortunate because, even in the hands of an experienced turner, this practice is only one bad catch away from a real disaster. Yes, someone may get away with the use of a roughing gouge for bowl work -- for years -- but that does not mean it's safe. How many of us have touched up a tool on the grinder without wearing eye protection? How many would suggest the idea is safe? 'nuff said.

Re: Making a Bowl Gouge

#7

Steven Antonucci

Honestly, I mostly rough with a bowl gouge?

steve antonucci

>I own a roughing gouge, but I rarely use it. Even in spindle work, I typically rough with a bowl gouge (I don't do a lot of spindle work...)

You can rough with a bowl gouge, but I can't imagine bowl turning with a roughing gouge...

steve

Re: Making a Bowl Gouge

#8

Re: Making a Bowl Gouge

john lucas

>Dan When I first started turning I got a set of tools that included a rough out gouge but didn't have a bowl gouge. I had a heck of a time turning bowls at first. In fact I got so many catches with the rough out gouge I did all my bowls with scrapers. Then I figured out I could grind the upper U shape back and avoid some of these catches. Looking back now I realize I was just making a very big bowl gouge with swept back wings. Not as exagerated as todays Irish grinds but somewhat similar.

Now many years later I've played with the rough out gouge while turning bowls. Even using it upside down to turn the inside. It will work but is really only safe for experienced turners and in reality why risk it. A bowl gouge has the right geometry to work better. The shaft thickness is much better so even if you do get a catch you don't risk damaging the tool. At least not as readily.

I don't recommend using them for bowl turning. There are just too many tools that work better.

Re: Making a Bowl Gouge

#9

Re: Making a Bowl Gouge *LINK*

Darrell Feltmate

>I would use the roughing gouge as a roughing gouge and leave it at that. For bowls I like to use a home made Oland tool or inserted tip tool. I just like the cut and the cost.


Around the Woods