Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Using belt sander for sharpening

Posts

Using belt sander for sharpening

#1

Using belt sander for sharpening

David Walser

>I read recently an article by a turner who advocates using a stationary belt sander for sharpening turning tools. (He even sells a sander that he's wired to run "backwards" so the belt moves away from the edge of the tool.) I cannot find a link to that article.

Does this ring a bell with anyone? More importantly, does anyone have a link to this guy's web site?

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening

#2

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>I sharpened my tools for the first year on a 1" x 42" belt sander. Worked pretty good until I could afford a grinder.

Bill in WNC mountains

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening

#4

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening

David Walser

>Yes, that's it. Thanks.

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening

#5

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening

Colin Spencer

>David,

Record tools in the UK have just introduced one of these specifically for sharpening turning tools. It has the various jigs included for fingernail grind etc. I expect Jet or someone else will copy it fairly quickly and make it available in the US.

Colin

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening

#6

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening

john lucas

>I'm with Bill. I used a cheap 1" strip sander for a while. That was before the jigs for doing bowl gouges came out. I had trouble maintaining the shape of the tool but that was probably my fault. My belt didn't run uphill and with it running down into the edge it was too easy to round over the the edge. I also go tired of changing the belts which would go bad pretty quick.

If I were to do it again I'd by some of the blue zirconium belts and rig it to run backwards so the belt travels up. I like the new one Sorby is selling but it's awfully expensive. You can buy a decent grinder and 2 wheels for half what that thing costs.

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening

#7

For that price...

Clem Wixted, Jonesboro, AR

>...you could get a Tormek.

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening

#8

Or you could get...

Clem Wixted, Jonesboro, AR

>...a grinder and a Wolverine System.

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening

#9

Re: Or you could get...

David Walser

>Yes, for that amount of money, I could get a lot of things. I could even make my own if I had a similar sander (or I could buy one at Harbor Freight for less than $100).

My interest was primarily in rereading his arguments that such a system produces a better edge in less time than does a grinder with or without another type of jig.

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening

#10

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening

David Walser

>That's interesting. Anyone have a link to Record Tools? I couldn't find one in my brief search.

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening

#11

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening

Bill Neddow

>Try http://www.recordpower.co.uk/

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening

#12

Brad Vietje

And spend many HOURS away from the lathe.

Brad Vietje

>

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening

#13

Brad Vietje

I've used these & recommend them (REVIEW)

Brad Vietje

>FWIW, I've used Jon's sharpening system, as have a lot of turners in northern New England. I've done turning demos at local symposia with that sharpener, and often mention hom much it simplifies and de-stresses the sharpening process. I like it a LOT, so I'll add some review comments below:

What Jon's done is to offer a relatively affordable machine that does most of what Woodcraft's old (and long-ago discontinued) Mark II system did. He uses a 4" wide belt that travels UP, away from the cutting edge. Any rounding (from the belt riding on a thin cushion of air) happens at the heel of the tool, where it is very desirable, but not on the cutting edge, which would be terrible. This is, BTW, the biggest reason for inverting the belt travel. He uses a 60-grit belt for re-shaping, and a 150 grit belt for sharpening. After the tool is sharpened, there is also a thin buffing wheel for de-burring the edge with Tripoli (or the polishing compound of your choice), which also polishes the flute a bit, which can help with the edge on many less expensive tools that have slight ridges inside the flutes.

Jon Siegel's system is very quick, very accurate and entirely reproducible. He uses a "V"-block to capture the end of the tool handle, and there are many indexed positions for placing the V-block quickly so you get the same grind each time. For fingernail grinds and bowl gouges, he also offers a stand that replaces the V-block so there is enough room to swing the tool through the arc to acheive the fingernail grind without hitting the indexed baseboard.

The main feature of this system is that you can sharpen and buff a tool about 7 SECONDS, literally. Bowl gouges or fingernail grinds will take 20 seconds or so, because you have to attach the Ellsworth jig or equivalent. This system also produces perfect flat bevels, which Jon also prefers. That's a debate for another post...

BACKGROUND: Jon has taught turning for nearly 40 years, and is considered a top turning "guru" in greater New England. He is a big proponent of using "muscle memory". He has described this as the learned motion of hands, eyes, ears, tool, bevel angle, speed, etc, that are required to get just the right cut on a particular piece. This is built up during roughing cuts, and he teaches that just before your final cut (ultimately the only one that really matters), you want a very keen edge on the tool in use to get the smoothest finishing cut and reduce sanding (which no one likes, and which can distort detail and isn't healthy, either...). If I turn away from my lathe to sharpen or hone my tool and have a frustrating time with a sharpening session, or the process takes too long (read: Tormek), you will lose any aquired muscle memory, and your final cut will be no more accurate that your roughing cuts. I have also seen my dad (when he was alive and turning) and many other turners get all frustrated at the grinder, and turn back to the lathe a few minutes later to ruin a number of pieces because 1- he was now frustrated; 2- he had been away from the workpiece too long to "remember" what smooth, fluid motion he needed to make; and 3- his tool and bevel were not the same shape they were a few moments ago. Turning after frustration could also be said to be dangerous as well. This appears to be a very common problem, especially with beginners, who are VERY likely to struggle with dull tools because sharpening is either not easy or too stressful.

How it works: Assuming I have my V-block set for the tool in my hands (the tool handles and V-block positions can be numbered or color-coded to make that quick, too), I turn away from the spinning lathe, sharpen and buff the tool in about 7 seconds, and I'm right back at my workpiece. The worn 150 grit belt produces a very fine edge which in my view almost never needs to be honed. You will never see a system that's easier and more reproducible for skews, and a slightly curved skew is a real pleasure to sharpen.

When I had very little money, I made a similar system out of a 12" disk sander, with a V-block and indexed positions. I also established positions for my Ellsworth and other fingernail jigs. I'm now pinching pennies again, having just bought a house, but as soon as I can afford it, I plan to buy one of Jon's machines. It doesn't do everything, but everything it does do it does better and faster than any alternative I've yet seen

That's just one fella's opinion,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening

#14

Re: I've used these & recommend them (REVIEW)

David Walser

>Brad,

Thanks for your review. I'm sure many will find it interesting and helpful.

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening

#15

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening *LINK*

Mike Brazeau

>Herm DeVries swears by the Lee Valley 1" belt system that you supply a motor for. He uses the Zirconia belt and claims it lasts forever. You can see at his site in the Tools & Tips section. When I first started a few years back I clamped by belt sander in my workmate at about 45 degrees and it worked just fine. That was until I got educated and conformed and bought a grinder.

Mike


Herm's site

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening

#16

Re: Using belt sander for sharpening *LINK*

Darrell Feltmate

>I still like a grinder with a 60 grit wheel and a jig, preferably home made for the cost.


Around the Woods