Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Apologies to all - kinda long *LINK*

Posts

Apologies to all - kinda long *LINK*

#1

Apologies to all - kinda long *LINK*

Bruce

>I was looking at an earlier post about a bowl that I donated and it sold for $300.00 at a charity auction for the Nelson Center of Denton Texas. I probably did not adequately explain things very well. Some may have looked at the post and thought, "Sure you did. Who are you trying to kid?"

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/turning.pl?noframes;read=133306

First off, I have been turning for about a year, when I can. The bowl in question was turned after a brief conversation with Alan Tucker concerning form, technique, and etc.

To make a short story long... I, in no way, ever thought this bowl was worth more than 20-30 bucks, but I was proud, non-the-less. This bowl was purchased by a vice president of the company for which I work. I know this was a charity auction and my humble bowl was purchased by a very generous person. (I think ego may have played a part in the bidding as well)

I realize I have much to learn and have learned so very much from this board. I do not want anyone to think I was trying to represent my work as anything other than the product of an entry level turner.

In the end the money goes to a good cause and I can feel good about that.

So, I apologize if my omission of the detail was misleading.

Bruce


http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/turning.pl?nofr

Re: Apologies to all - kinda long *LINK*

#2

Re: Apologies to all - kinda long

Robert Henderson

>I just looked again at your pictures in the original post.

You don't have anything to apologize for.

Re: Apologies to all - kinda long *LINK*

#3

Steven Antonucci

Why do you apologize for donating work to charity?

steve antonucci

>Someone paid $300 for it. An object is worth what someone is willing to pay for it, regardless of the reason.

I donate things to charity auctions and they sell for what they sell for... I do not put a price on them. No apology required.

Steve

Re: Apologies to all - kinda long *LINK*

#4

Values

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Bruce,

Indeed it was misleading, It was worth MORE!!

Really, any act of donation for a cause in my mind is a gracious and giving act, paid values are seldom true in terms of it's paid price, the true realized value given back to the organization that benifits from this donation you have made is Much Greater....

:-)

You have the right Values..

take care,

Jim

Re: Apologies to all - kinda long *LINK*

#5

Re:At an auction, the buyers......

Jamie Donaldson

>... determine the value! After 40 yrs. in the horse business I know that ego is a large part of the bidding process, but who cares, unless you are one of the bidders!!!When the auction action benefits a worthy charity, just stand back and let the bidding begin!!!

Re: Apologies to all - kinda long *LINK*

#6

Re: Apologies to all - kinda long

George Van

>�Some may have looked at the post and thought, "Sure you did. Who are you trying to kid?"�

Bruce, the thought never crossed my mind! You should be proud that your hollow form brought the money it did for a good cause. You were generous in your donation.

Re: Apologies to all - kinda long *LINK*

#7

You were not misleading.

Ed Moore

>Bruce,

You presented the bald facts - and they speak for themselves. I sense that you don't want to be viewed as a "turtle on a fencepost" and representing yourself as a "big hat". A turtle on a fencepost is out of place and didn't get there by itself.

In a nutshell, we all applaud your generosity and the generosity of the purchaser, and no one has an unkind thought in your direction nor a concern about your hat size. We look forward to seeing more of your work.

Ed

Re: Apologies to all - kinda long *LINK*

#8

Re:At an auction, the buyers......

Stuart Johnson

>We used to go to a small town 4th of July picnic that had an auction to raise money for a charity. Each year a few of the rice farmers would start butting heads and bid several hundred dollars for a cherry or apple pie. Everyone won. The donator was praised for making the pie, the bidders made a substantial donation and the rest of us had a great time.

What was the pie worth? The same as your bowl, the amount of the winning bid. No apology needed so none accepted.

Re: Apologies to all - kinda long *LINK*

#9

Re: Apologies to all - kinda long

Arch

>Hi; Bruce,

The competition for inflated prices at AAW auctions is a good thing; supports AAW, makes both donor & buyer feel good and helps raise the public's perception of the value of custom turned wood.

The hundred and fifty buck mushy green peas and gooey chicken a la king was worth more than the price of our recent dinner for breast cancer.

I demand a retraction of your apology! :) & 'G'.

Best, Arch

Re: Apologies to all - kinda long *LINK*

#10

Withdrawn.

Bruce

>Well, apparently the majority saw the post as intended and I thank you. You other 2-3 can, well, uh, go find something better to do.

Apology withdrawn by popular demand.

Bruce

Re: Apologies to all - kinda long *LINK*

#11

Withdrawn

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Bruce, do you mean that someone actually wrote you something negative that prompted you to write the apology? That is just unbelievable. You are right; they need to get a life. You had nothing to apologize for.

Re: Apologies to all - kinda long *LINK*

#12

Re: Withdrawn

john lucas

>I agree with Barbara. I kind of read all of this off and on during the day and couldn't figure out why you had to apologize. Whatever we can get for a turning is well deserved. The price will vary a lot in different markets. If it's a piece donated to an auction then whatever it brings is a great gift the organization.

Re: Apologies to all - kinda long *LINK*

#13

Re: Apologies to all - kinda long

tm

>Well done. The first bowl I donated went for only $170.

Good on you! Its okay to be proud and remember, it should be tax deductable.

tm

Re: Apologies to all - kinda long *LINK*

#14

Re: Apologies to all - kinda long

tm

>It always cracks me up and amuses me the way posters here add the word "Gloat" to a header when they show some fine piece of work.

If its gloatworthy then gloat. ;)

tm

Re: Apologies to all - kinda long *LINK*

#15

Re: Withdrawn.

Ron in Drums PA

>A few months ago I've had a few nasty emails too.

Re: Apologies to all - kinda long *LINK*

#16

Re: Withdrawn.

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>You know sometimes I think when that happens the names and contents of the e-mails should be posted; it is called consequences. Did they even sign the e-mail?