Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Pen Help Please

Posts

Pen Help Please

#1

Pen Help Please

David Hammond, in Powder Springs GA

>I've got some more q's for my big 40 pen project.

I went ahead and sprung for the Beall Collet chuck to hold a pen mandrel in the headstock side, because I wanted as much accuracy as possible on these fancy fountian pens. And, I can use the chuck for other projects as well.

But I'm concerned about the tailstock end of this thing: normally the center of the rod just runs on the point of a revolving tail center. But the Craft Supplies rods that my buddy uses seem rather soft, and the center of that mandrel is going to get worn over time - right? Is there a better method for this? The mandrel from Pakcard and Lee Valley seems much nicer, but then again I'm just looking at pictures. And, if I bought pen kits from Craft Supplies, do I have to buy their mandrel?

Also, should I invest in a Oneway Tail Center, as I have a rather cheap tail center right now...

Thanks for the help guys,

And as a reminder to all of us - there's tons of info available in the Articles and Reviews Sections here! I just spent a good bit of time reading a bunch of them - what a great source of info!

David

Re: Pen Help Please

#2

Save Your Money *LINK*

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi David,

I use the LV adjustable mandrel. I also bought the 60 Degree Live Centre made by Axminster from CSUSA ($40), the One way is more expensive.

Take care,

Jim


img

Link

Re: Pen Help Please

#3

Re: Pen Help Please

Greg in Oshkosh

>the live center should rest on the end of the mandrel and turn with it and not slip. therefore you should not wear the end of the mandrel. It is more improtant that the centers of your lathe line up. Does the drive center point meet the live center point???

Re: Pen Help Please

#4

Re: Save Your Money

Bill Howatt

>I agree with Jim that you don't need the Oneway to turn pens - all you need is a reasonable live center such that the center turns with the pen mandrel and therefore there is no wear.

The live center should line up with the headstock. The thin mandrel and its length usually means that the tailstock end is not exactly true when mounted. Putting the point of the tailstock into the end of the mandrel aligns it as well as giving it support.

Having said that, I have a Oneway center and I like it. I find the accessories that come with it such as the cones and the threaded portion of the center to be handy.

Bill

Re: Pen Help Please

#5

Re: Save Your Money

David Hammond, in Powder Springs GA

>Thanks Jim: I just ordered the 60 degree cone and a mandrel from Packard, so I think I'll be ready to turn when they get here.

Thanks!

David

Re: Pen Help Please

#6

Re: Pen Help Please

David Hammond, in Powder Springs GA

>Good point Greg, and yes, my centers do line up, so I think I'll be turning pens as soon as my mandrel and live center gets here.

Thanks,

Greg

Re: Pen Help Please

#7

Re: Pen Help Please

J. Uteck

>I'd avoid the Oneway live center for pens, but it's still a great center for everything else! For pens, the dimple in the end of the mandrel is 60-degrees. The steel "pin" center on the Oneway is not a 60-deg. point, so you will get some runout --- I noticed wear on my point, not the mandrel. If you use the aluminum cone on the Oneway, it doesn't seem to sit quite right either -- although I don't know the angle on it -- I also had wear on the aluminum cone, not the mandrel. As you've already read, you're better off with a precision 60-deg live center.

Re: Pen Help Please

#8

Re: Pen Help Please

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi J.

I had the exact same experience with my One Way...I save it for other work. I have a great deal of run out like you mentioned.

The silence of running with a Live Centre made for the 60 degree fit is a pleasure.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Pen Help Please

#9

Re: Pen Help Please

David Hammond, in Powder Springs GA

>Sounds great guys, I can't wait to get starter! I think I'm going to make your pen sled Jim, and go ahead and prep my blanks, so I'll be 100 percent ready when the cone and mandrel gets here. I've got some stabilized Buckeye burl for a Havanna Rollerball and a Havana Fountain pen, which I've heard is really nice, so we'll see what I can do!

Thanks,

David

Re: Pen Help Please

#10

Re: Pen Help Please

Don Evans

>John:

One problem one can run into with pen mandrels and sharp pointed live centers is this:

The mandel may not be deep enough for the sharp point of the live center to allow it to set deep enough into the end of the pen mandrel. In other words, the pen mandrel is just not deep enough as they don't take the 60 degree all the way to a point inside the mandrel. Hope that is clear.

So what one should do is drill a hole deeper into the bottom of the 60 degree in the pen mandrel to allow the sharp point to go deeper. This will allow the SIDES of the mandrel and live center sides to mate with each other fully.

Not doing this will result in vibration, out of round conditions and also worn live center cones.

Also to answer another one of David's questions that I didn't see an answer too:

Should you purchase mandrells from same place as kits? My experience comes for 10 years ago and may be different now, but all mandrells are not exactly the same. I purchased them from several places and miking them found them to be 2 to 3 thousands different in size. The problem is with mandrells from one place and bushings from another can be a problem.

There was a time when some bushings from one place wouldn't even go on a mandrel from another or they may be a lot of slop in there fit.

I use nothing but a 1/4" collet at the end of my production days that came from MSC and you could buy just the rods from CS I think. I made my own draw bar which you would also need if using a machinist collet like I refer too. It was the most accurate way of doing it, none of the pen supplies stuff came close.

Good luck with your new venture, it's a lot of fun.

Don

Re: Pen Help Please

#11

Re: Pen Help Please

David Hammond, in Powder Springs GA

>Thanks for the reply Don, I'd waste a lot more time and money if it wasn't for you guys!

David