Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

scalpel...

Posts

scalpel...

#1

scalpel...

GaryG in MD

>I would like some ideas on how best to cut up this red cedar to maximize the yield of interesting pieces. I already have a few chunks of various shapes and sizes that I lopped off to get it into this fairly solid form. The apparent checks are only skin deep. I've sealed it for now with sprayed shellac.

It is 13" tall as it stands, but there are a couple of 1" diameter voids between branches on the other end which extend up a few inches. The maximum outer diameter is 12", but the minimum distance between inner lobes is as little as 5".

I feel like I would be wasting it by whacking out a couple regular side-grain bowls. There's got to be something artistic to do here. I'd like to get a couple "striking" pieces out of this, but I'm not sure exactly how to go about it. I would particularly like to hear from any of you who have had experience with a similar shape and situation.

Will an end-grain slab stabilize if it dries slowly, or if soaked in more shellac or diluted white glue, or will it eventually crack deeply like your typical cheap Florida plasticized cyprus clock form? What shapes will best show off the grain, color, texture, bark, shape, etc.? End grain NE platters? Trumpets? HFs? Trad bowls? NE bowls? ...??

All ideas are welcome, Gary


img

Re: scalpel...

#2

Re: scalpel...

Dave Belser

>Gary

If you don't have it I'd recommend the book "Turning Green Wood" by Michael O'Donnell. It has a really great section on how to orient NE bowls in a log. I had a cedar log like that and made some really interesting NE bowls from it. Unfortunately my skills and tools at the time were not up to the task.

I still have a half finished bowl and platter set turned from essentially the same section of log so that the NE wings on the bowl line up with the platter.

One of the biggest problems I had was cracking when the wood dried out while I was turning it. I think that this harder to control with cedar than other wood. As I said my skill at the time wasn't up to the task - if I had been able to turn thinner and quicker it may not have been as much of a problem.

Be extremely careful about dust exposure / collection. I wasn't and the cedar dust became irritating to the point of where I had cold like symptoms for a day or two. When I got back to the shop the smell of the cedar in my DC was enough to bug me. I emptied the bag and cleaned the canister and it still took weeks for the smell to dissipate. At this point I would only dry sand cedar outside on a windy day!

- Dave

Re: scalpel...

#3

Re: scalpel...

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>Here's what I did with a log I had.


img

Re: scalpel...

#4

Re: scalpel...

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>Here's another. It's about 5"X12". The platter was 18"X3".


img

Re: scalpel...

#5

Re: scalpel...

Rick Allen

>Phil Brown does a tall vase form with cedar that excludes any sapwood. As with most of Phil's stuff it looks spectacular.

I know we all like to get the most out of a piece of wood. Usually getting the best out of a hunk of wood and the most out of a hunk of wood are close to the same thing. Sometimes getting the best and the most are two entirely different things.

For me the value of cedar is the beautiful red color. Maintaining the sapwood and convoluted shape of cedar reminds me of the "tourist" items sold in gift shops at the foot of the Appalachian mountains. So for me I would rough turn some bowls or hollow forms... out of the heartwood. Wax them up and set them aside to dry for a year or so.

Good luck with your choice.

Re: scalpel...

#6

Steven Antonucci

This screams Natural Edge bowl/form to me

steve antonucci

>I'd try for one piece, end grain orientation, with the top of the form being at the top pictured and hollowed down.

I can see a "flower form" with an internal hollowform if you are up to the task... take a picture of the form before you "fully hollow it", since it's a risky play. IMHO, too nice of a piece of wood to not try something special with it. If you slab it square, I'll cry.

Steve

Re: scalpel...

#7

Brad Vietje

Re: scalpel...

Brad Vietje

>Gary,

This looks like a fun challange. My first question would be for whom are you turning ? Are you looking for craft sale items ? Christmas gifts ? A challange for your skills ? It's worth noting that the wood isn't in perfect shape -- the tearing around the edges looks like a little sapwood degrade, and deep in the heartwood it looks like some rotten/punky areas, similar to red rot in Cherry.

For craft fair pieces, I'd suggest many smaller pieces after slabbing off a slice for an end-grain platter like Gary did (that has to be turned pretty thin and dried slowly to avoid cracks). By making 10 - 14 small pieces that you can sell for more affordable prices, you can maybe expose more beauty and possibly make more money that 1 or 2 "primo" pieces that would be pretty expensive, or end up with many gift items.

If you want to make something for your own appreciation, I'd probably still take a 2-1/2" slice for a platter/plate/wall sculpture, but if it were mine, I'd go for a beautiful natural-edge "vase" with S-curved sides and a scalloped shape. If you have the ability to core it first, you could still make a nice hollow form from the center that you remove. Both of these will have all the issues that come with having the pith pass through the foot of the piece, so they'd be challenging projects.

Have fun !

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: scalpel...

#8

Re: scalpel...

GaryG in MD

>Dave,

Thanks for your thoughtful reply. I do, indeed, have the O'Donnell book (I've been recommending it to other people!) -- you're right, this would be a good time to review it. I agree that some kind of NE is in order here, at least in part. Were you thinking side grain or end grain NE?

Your warning about allergies is right on. I was aware that red cedar was on the list, but I never had a reaction to my mother's cedar chest smell while growing up. Funny thing -- last night, after chainsawing the original log into what I posted and stray bits in the afternoon, I didn't change my long-sleeved shirt until bed time. When I took it off, I found a rash starting on my right forearm. I'm obviously going to have to treat this as I do walnut and turn with rubber gloves and a mask. Luckily I do my turning outside, so cleanup will be easy -- no DC to clean out.

I like your idea aboaut a matching platter/bowl set. I hope you are able to get yours worked out.

Re cracking: The funny thing about this log is that it's a piece of road kill I dragged home about three years ago, stuck behind the shed, and forgot. It's been sitting out in the rain and snow since then, uncovered. I expected to have to recycle it. I started by cutting about 4" off the bottom and found nothing but sound wood after a couple inches of oxidation. I clamped it and salvaged a perfectly good 1"+ cross section from the cutoff. I'm going to have to review my end grain turning techniques and tools. The other end of the log was limited by opening up into a number of separate branches -- which I dutifully saved for a small bowl or HF and bottle stoppers. Cedar is amazing. My problem is I don't know the MC -- I don't have a meter. It's got to be at least partly dry, but I won't delude myself into thinking it's not ripe for cracking. I don't want to darken it any further with oil, and I don't want to get wax on a surface that I might want to present, so I sealed it good with spray-canned clear shellac. I suspect I'll continue to finish it that way -- or switch to Krylon.

Thanks again for your thoughts. ...Gary

Re: scalpel...

#9

Re: scalpel...

GaryG in MD

>Gary,

Your platter and vase are both very attractive. Thanks for showing them to me. I did cut a cross section off (per my answer to Dave above), so I'm going to give an end-grain platter a try at the very least. I've never done anything end grain that big so it will be a learning experience. What tool(s) did you use. I don't have a ring tool or hook tool at this point. Will bowl gouges and spindle gouges work reasonably well without a lot of tearout? [I've got to read my new Raffan book on that!]

I don't have the capability to hollow anything that deep, but I can certainly try a smaller one (with my Scorpion). I love the way it looks. It seems to be end grain -- did you have the pith in? Any cracking problems?

Thanks, Gary

Re: scalpel...

#10

Re: scalpel... (Long)

Allen Neighbors

>Gary, I had a small piece of hornbeam that had this sort of shape to it. I made a natural edged bowl from it. Turned out beautiful. As Steve says, it's screaming for a NE Bowl, and like Brad says, if you just want something for yourself, go for it. If it were mine, I'd rough it out first to about 3/4" thick, then soak it in the soap solution for about a month, and then finish turn it wet to about 3/8" thickness throughout, keeping the finished outside wet while I turned the inside.

By the time I'd turned it down to finished thickness, it wouldn't be dry but would have lost a tremendous amount of moisture, and I'd wet sand the outside with Danish Oil and dry sand the inside. Then I'd put a few heavy coats of Danish Oil on the outside only, and let it move the way it wanted to as it dried, before putting a finish on the inside. (I've turned dozens of bowls with this technique, and so far it works pretty well. They do move quite a bit, but they seldom crack.) Then I'd Jam Chuck it, and finish the bottom with a concave surface.

I might even try drilling a 1" hole about 1/8" into the bottom of the tenon, to help relieve some of the tenon stresses while it dried. (That's a good hint (I think) that I got tonight on this forum.)

This might not be the best way to do it, but it's just the way I would do it. :o)

Re: scalpel...

#11

Re: Should have said, "end grain". :o)

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: scalpel...

#12

Re: scalpel...

GaryG in MD

>Rick,

Thanks for the reply. I'll email Phil and ask him for a pic of his cedar vase. OT, his recent show with Doug at the Sandy Spring Museum was wonderful. I'm searching for the "right" piece of wood to use to try my hand at one of his classic trumpet shapes. I have some mesquite that is crying to be a trumpet, but it was unfortunately pith cracked before I got it, so that won't work.

I hear you loud and clear about the sapwood (hence my comment in my first post about the cyprus clocks). OTOH, I'd like to try to save some in at least one piece of this log. I agree with you completely about the tradeoff between best and most -- hence my post. It's a tough choice because I don't know when I'll ever run into a piece like this again. I'm going to feel like one of those movie diamond cutters when the chainsaw bites in. The choices we make are irreversible.

Thanks for your thoughts. ...Gary

Re: scalpel...

#13

Re: This screams Natural Edge bowl/form to me

GaryG in MD

>Steve,

I agree completely -- I can't bear to slab it; that's why I posted for ideas.

My skills and tools are unfortunately not adequate for a single, large, flower-form end-grain NE HF as you recommend, so I'm going to have to try to get some nice shapes out of several smaller pieces. Per Rick's and Dave's comments, I'm also concerned about the probability of cracks forming and growing in the sap wood. I want to try for something daring, but within my limitations.

Thanks for your comments. ...Gary

Re: scalpel...

#14

Re: scalpel...

GaryG in MD

>Brad,

I'm strictly a hobby turner and don't plan any sales, so it just comes down to maximizing my pleasure with the final result(s). I don't have the huge tools that would be needed to core it, nor for making one large HF, so it's going to have to be a compromise. You're right about the exterior being in less than excellent condition, and that's certainly a significant consideration. The interior, however, is pristine -- those color changes are not punky at all -- it's solid. I already have one platter blank from it, so I'm leaning toward the idea of cutting it in half across the end grain and then making one end grain piece and cutting the other half into several side-grain pieces, at least one of which will be NE.

Thanks for your thoughts. ...Gary

Re: scalpel...

#15

Thanks all...

GaryG in MD

>...for your thoughtful replies. As a result, I have a pretty good feeling for what I want to try, and how to go about it. Cheers, Gary

Re: scalpel...

#16

Re: scalpel... (Long)

GaryG in MD

>Allen,

You have given me some really good techniques for dealing with a situation like this. Regardless of my final cutting plan, I'll be using your approach. Thanks a lot for the excellent ideas. I've never seen it explained quite this way before, but it makes a lot of sense. It reminds me of Dave Smith's method of wrapping the outside (only) of bowls (after DNAing) in paper to keep the main stress compressive to minimize cracking. I will certainly try hard to prevent it from drying out on the lathe -- I expect you're correct about that being important. I plan to use clear shellac instead of oil to try to reduce the browning of the color -- for some time period, at least. Thanks for your great ideas. ...Gary

Re: scalpel...

#17

Re: This screams Natural Edge bowl/form to me

dinyar

>Gary:

If you are concerned about your skills, the advantage of turning this as a natural form is that you can always claim that any parts that you went through were intentional (so long as you dont make two pieces out of it.

I would recommend a natural edge hollow form, but turned in faceplate orientation. I was first shown this by Jon Schilling, who is so good at describing how to do things that he was able to explain it to me over the internet (I happen to be particularly challenged in the visualization area!).

Anyway, I have a photo-essay that is a step-by-step description of how to do this on my web-site, and you can find it at http://d.chavda.home.att.net/crotchform3.pdf

While it is not a project for a beginner, we all have to take the plunge sometime. You may want to try the process with a less "valuable" piece of wood to get the hang of it. I have found (with due apologies to Keith) that being willing to be flexible in terms of what you end up with, and being willing to change your design as you go along, is very important for success, at least until such time as you get better control over the tools.

Hope you find it useful.

Dinyar

Re: scalpel...

#18

Steven Antonucci

Nothing ventured, nothing gained

steve antonucci

>Philosophically, I think I'd rather try something great and fail than try something average and succeed. I've exploded more things pushing myself than I can count, which has made the things I actually do get off the lathe that much better.

When I see a piece of wood that special, it excites me. I can count on a single hand the number of pieces of wood that I've turned with as specific an idea as this, and I have only a couple of pieces to show for it.

More than likely, I'd lose this piece as well. In the case where the wood is "too special to lose", I will leave walls a little thicker than I'm comfortable (1/4" maybe?". Heavy isn't always bad. (Exploding vessels are always bad.)

Good luck with it whatever you decide to do.

Steve

Re: scalpel...

#19

Dinyar,

GaryG in MD

>Thanks for your thoughts. I'll check out your web site and the recommended project. That sounds very helpful.

I consider myself somewhere between advanced beginner and low intermediate. I take my time -- I rarely blow anything up but do, indeed, have some "redesigns". As I said, this is road kill, so it's not like I have a big investment in any respect, but I would like to try to do it some justice if I can. That means NOT just slabbing it, but trying something appropriate to the form.

Hopefully, I'll be able, and willing, to show the result later.

...Gary

Re: scalpel...

#20

Steve,

GaryG in MD

>I agree. My fear isn't the turning part, although I have to be careful to remain within my skill level and tools, but rather I'm afraid of doing something irreversible with the chain saw. Thanks for your encouragement -- hopefully I'll end up with something worth of posting. ...Gary