Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

Posts

Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#1

Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

Steven Russell

>Hello to the group,

It's that time of year again when I gather up all of my turnings that have been damaged, broken, or scratched at art shows and exhibitions over the last year and add them to those from previous years. The box is always overflowing it seems! The excuses given by those who damaged the items range from creative to spur of the moment, but nearly all result in the same thing - they walk away and I'm left with a damaged piece that I can no longer sell.

Here are a few examples of some things in my "Ooops" box:

A $3,000.00 flame Box Elder platter that an exhibitor in the booth next to us at an art show damaged when they were hanging up their lights. "Ooops, looks like that "wood thing" is scratched." Actually, is was a chip out of the rim. Exhibitor refused to pay stating that it should be written off as a cost of doing business.

A really beautiful $500.00 inlaid bottle stopper that a small boy picked up and immediately threw down on the floor, crying to his mom that it didn't bounce. Mother refused to pay and walked off to another booth where little Johnny promptly broke another artists item worth $1,000.00.

A splendid $1,500.00 Carob Burl bowl with a delicate and provocative carved rim, that was dropped at an outdoor art show on the concrete resulting in a cracked and broken rim. The man who dropped it said he wasn't responsible since it broke so easily, it must have been defective.

A handful of writing pens that range from $350.00 - $1,700.00 each. Dropped at various events with the same old excuses given by those who dropped them, and none would pay for the damage. Luckily, none of my really expensive pens have been damaged yet.

A $250.00 delicate egg with a hand chased threaded lid. A little boy picked it up and threw it on the ground wanting to see it crack. No, it was not the same little boy mentioned above. Little Tommies dad said that was too bad and walked off.

A magnificent $2,500.00 Mesquite burl bowl that a lady scratched with her platinum wedding ring when she was feeling the inside curve. She apologized, but refused to pay saying that it should not have scratched so easily.

My box has about $10,000.00 worth of turnings that have been damaged over the last few years. While I have considered trying to rescue a few of them by various means, I have yet to do so.

So do any of you have a similar experience? What do you do with damaged turnings? Are you better at getting the person to pay for the piece when they damaged it? I have not had much success at getting people to pay for something they damaged. Many will just walk off although a few over the years have been kind enough to pay for the items that they, or their children have damaged.

It can be hard as well to monitor every single person in your booth at a large show. Little kids are the worst, but some adults are not much better it seems. The large open air art shows seem the worst, but I've had items damaged at some really nice events as well. I've also had things damaged in transit to exhibitions, or by the staff putting up the show. It can make you a bit gun-shy when you send a piece off to a show, but luckily these kinds of stories are the exception and not the rule. Still stings a wee bit tho...

To everyone of the group, please accept my very best wishes for a safe, happy and healthy holiday season and a happy new year.

Better Woodturning and Finishing Through Chemistry...

Steve Russell

Eurowood Werks Studio

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#2

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitio

Russ Fairfield

>My most common damage is from men tapping the wood with their rings and women with their fingernails. It's as though they are giving the finish a "hardness test".

I once belonged to a club where the Show 'n Tell items were passed around the audience as they were discussed. There was one guy who always dropped a piece of scrap wood to get everyones attention.

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#3

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitio

John Lucas

>Russ I had that happen twice this morning while showing the piece I just posted. Both tapped on it with thier fingernails. I almost pulled out my nail cutters and went after them.

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#4

Steven Antonucci

If I had a booth at a show with that much $$$ ...

steve antonucci

>riding on it, I might try to get an inexpensive video camera setup to record the comings and goings. People may balk at walking away if you have a recording of "vandalism" by their kids. Doubt you'll get very far with the accidental scratches, though.

Just a thought.

steve

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#5

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitio

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>As your display items are of such high value I believe I would consult with your attorney and get his input. I know it will do no good for history but it may lead you to resolution on future shows.

I would also think these very high end items should be in galleries having insurance to provide you with protection.

Good luck

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#6

Is insurance a good idea?

Ron in Drums PA

>

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#7

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitio

Jake (SoMN)

>Why not cover up them up with plexiglass/lexan cubes. I know it will obscure some of the finer points of the finishes and such, but it would be much harder for anybody to just pick up and item and damage it. Might not be for all of the items, maybe just the higher priced pieces.

Also you could control who looked at them and how they were handled. It is easy to ignore a sign that says fragile, but much harder to ignore it when you hand them the object and explain the fragility and the proper way to handle it to avoid scratches and incidental damage.

My guess would be that insurance would be prohibitively expensive...

Jake

(Remove the 2 for email)

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#8

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitio

chris rolke

>i swear some people have no clue when it comes to our work

now the real question is are you going to have a scratch and dent sale ?

sorry i know that was wrong

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#9

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitio

bowlman

>On planet Bowlman, when this happens, the artist is required BY LAW to hunt down and end the miserable existence of such offenders and their offspring. Keeps the gene pool from further contamination. Same for parents whose little darlings throw tantrums in public and the parents refuse to "correct" their behavior with a paddling. Oh, and don't get me started on drivers with cell phones or cewll phones in public places like concerts, churches, theaters, etc.... on planet Bowlman things are getting better though ... especially with our new madatory catch and destroy (not release) laws!

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#10

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitio

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I was at a fine craft show in Chicago once and saw a guy with a booth that seemed like a good idea. He constructed walls with lighted cubby holes (niches) where his turnings were displayed. He had a sign that read "Please do not touch without assistance". The sign was good but something about the pieces being in protected spaces like that seemed to not only give them visual importance but also seemed to disuade touching. Perhaps you could re-work your display to help modify behavior? Just a thought.

Tom

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#11

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitio

Ron in Drums PA

>It's all in perspective I guess, I don't command the prices that Steve does.

But $1000 worth on insurance to recover $10,000 worth of lost goods sounds like a bargain to me.

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#12

You break it, you bought it....

Thad

>Curious...what happens if I wreck a car I am test-driving from a dealership?

I agree with the philosophy of Bowlman; "You break it, we break you." .....oh if we all lived on planet Bowlman...but alas.

What about posting notices such as "You break it, you bought it," or something more tactful that would be simultaneously inviting yet deterring. Some sort of notice informing peopleo f their responsibility in handling apeice and leave them without excuse

Maybe another idea, though a bit overboard, but ask for an ID as collateral while they hold a peice and they get it back when the item is returned undamaged, but you get an name and address if it is returned damaged. Not too feesable for high traffic booths, but still an idea.

~Thad

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#13

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitio

sean troy

>Good luck trying to collect from an Insurance company when this type of damage happens. They come up with every excuse not to pay. Unfortunatly, I've had experience with this and not nearly as high a ticket item as mentioned.

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#14

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitio

Chuck Engstrom

>Hi Steven -- Sorry to hear of your troubles in this. You're certainly entitled to be aggravated.

It occurs to me to suggest that you ask management of each show/exhibit if they have a general policy on damage by visitors that you might be able to cite when something gets damaged, or, if they don't have a general policy to help protect you, do they have any policy or suggestions on how you might go about helping yourself when this stuff happens. I would certainly hope that they'd let you post a small sign ("Parents are responsible for damage by their children") or such.

Best wishes for the season and thanks for all your contributions to the turning community.

Chuck Engstrom

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#15

You have a point

Ron in Drums PA

>

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#16

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitio

RK in Milwaukee

>I guess I have to ask what seems to me to be an obvious question; Why do you let people handle your work? The worst offenders for me are other woodturners who feel they have some kind of right to handle work I bring to club meetings. Aggravates the bejesus out of me. I asked the club to make it a policy not to handle another person's work without permission but people do it anyhow. Now I don't take work in for show and tell. Many of the pieces I might show have already been sold and I can't take the risk.

I remember a sign in a hobby shop once that said-

It's wonderful to look at

and delightful to hold.

but if you break it, it's just been sold -

TO YOU!

At the annual Lakefront Festival of the Arts show here in Milwaukee, artists that I have seen with delicate work such as hollow vessels don't let people into their booths.

My contract with galleries specifically states that they will pay for any work that is damaged. That means they have to buy the piece. I always suggest they put a "do not touch" sign with the work. It ahs worked so far.

Hope you find an answer to your dilemma.

Ron Nelson

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#17

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitio

Steven Russell

>Hello Russ,

I know what you mean about the tapping of fingernails. Scratches can sometimes be handled easier than other damage, but many times it requires a complete refinishing to get the finish right again. :-( A friend of mine would say that is why some of my pieces are now finished with a modified epoxy base... :-)

Better Woodturning and Finishing Through Chemistry...

Steve Russell

Eurowood Werks Studio

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#18

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitio

Steven Russell

>Hello John,

I feel your pain... It's especially hard after a piece you've worked on for two weeks gets damaged. Really takes the wind out of your sails - at least for an old salt like me anyway.

Better Woodturning and Finishing Through Chemistry...

Steve Russell

Eurowood Werks Studio

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#19

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitio

Steven Russell

>Hello Jake,

Thanks for your comments. Placing items under a case may work for some things (it works for jewelry), but not as well for woodturnings. Wood is very much a "touch me - feel me" kind of thing. One of the reasons people like wood so much is the touch and feel it offers. Over and over again you will see them running their hands over the piece commenting on the finish and the color of the wood. To remove this from the sales process may prove to be a very difficult task, fraught with missteps.

It's a tough nut to crack and one that is not easily solved. You want to invite someone to pick up your piece and make a connection that will lead to a purchase, but you don't want your work damaged in the process. So far, for me, this has been a delicate dance on a very sharp sword. It has been a very rewarding journey through the years, punctuated only by the occasionally painful incident that lingers in the mind like a bad Merlot on the tongue, long after it is consumed.

Better Woodturning and Finishing Through Chemistry...

Steve Russell

Eurowood Werks Studio

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#20

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitio

Steven Russell

>Hello Chris,

No worries... Your comments gave me a nice chuckle. I had thought about a scratch and dent sale a few times, but always rejected it. One of the most important things you can protect when you are a professional artist is your reputation. Your reputation and your skill are two of the most important things that define you as an artist.

For me, allowing damaged pieces to be sold, even at a greatly reduced price would not be acceptable. What would I do if someone picked up one of these pieces and saw my name on the bottom and then saw the damage? I cringe just typing it, much less trying to envision it actually happening. I will probably have a large bonfire one day, pitching each piece in turn into the fire with a fond farewell. :-(

Better Woodturning and Finishing Through Chemistry...

Steve Russell

Eurowood Werks Studio

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#21

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitio

Steven Russell

>Hello Bowlman,

ROTFL... I want to move to planet bowlman!!!

Better Woodturning and Finishing Through Chemistry...

Steve Russell

Eurowood Werks Studio

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#22

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitio

Steven Russell

>Hello Thomas,

Thanks for your comments. I have seen other artists try this before at art shows and most of them sold little if anything. It can work for some things, but not for wood IMHO. As you mentioned, having your items protected like that dissuades touching, which is critical for the person to make a connection that will lead to a sale. It also seems to project a "hands-off" kind of atmosphere for your booth that may well cause most folks to walk on by.

If you protect them too much, you may not make a sale. If you don't try to protect them some way, you may end up with a piece that is damaged and unsalable. There must be a happy medium somewhere, but every option offers its own set of challenges and consequences both positive and negative.

Better Woodturning and Finishing Through Chemistry...

Steve Russell

Eurowood Werks Studio

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#23

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitio

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>I don't know if you also have lower value work or not. If you do you might consider a two level display. Put lower value and sturdier work where it can be touched and a layer behind a table on the back wall in lighted display cases. Stand between and if someone wants to look at a piece you can explain the damage or break policy of you buy it.

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#24

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitio

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi Steven,

Could you post a link to a site where we can see some of your work, I'd love to see your expensive pens!

:-=)

Take care,

Jim

Re: Damages to turnings at art shows and exhibitions..

#25

Suggestion...

Peter Teubel

>I understand having your name on a damaged piece is bad for the reputation. But consider this: Brand the bottom with a big "DAMAGED" brand...something that totally obscures your signature and indicates (without question) the condition of the piece. Some folks may want to purchase something you've made but can't (or won't) pay top dollar. This gives them a chance to do so and would allow you to recoupe some of your losses.

Just a thought...