Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

oval skews

Posts

oval skews

#1

oval skews

Gary B. in Central NY

>I'm a new turner and CANNOT get a bead turned with my rectangular skew before it feels weird and catches.....An oval skew seems like it would work much better...any thoughts?

Re: oval skews

#2

Re: oval skews

Gordon Seto

>No, that catchless skew has not been marketed yet. It is mainly personal choice. Two of the skew masters have this argument in AAW Journal couple years ago. Nick Cook likes the oval; Alan Lacer prefers the heavy regular skew.

There is no substitute for learning & practicing how to use the tool.

Join a local AAW Chapter meeting and get some instruction.

Both Alan Batty & Alan Lacer have very good DVDs on using the skews.

BTW, a lot of local clubs has a good selection of books, videos for members to check out.

Gordon

Re: oval skews

#3

Re: oval skews

john lucas

>I've been an oval skew turner for a long time. Not because I think that's the tool to use, simple because that's the first one I got and I'm still using it. I think Nick Cook said it best. There are a certain number of catches built into each skew and you simply have to use them up.

I was teaching a skew class yesterday. The only way I know to help you is to tell you to turn large beads that resemble a ball shape at first. The square shouldered small bead is the hardest shape of them all.

Start out learning planing cuts. Just try your best to get a long clean cylinder. Then try to turn these into long curves. Once you've mastered that try exagerating the ends of each curve into a deeper curve. Then try making fairly large half ball shapes. Once your comfotable with these your ready to try beads.

One exercise I do when I haven't been turning a lot is to put a green limb section on the lathe and round it out. Then I do a series of V cuts. Then I'll turn the left side of all my bead forms. Once that's done I'll turn the right side. If I have time I'll do the same thing with my left hand. You need to be ambidextrous with all your tools.

Re: oval skews

#4

Re: oval skews..... just practice and

Ruth Niles

>Gary, try to relax when using the skew, when I first started, I'd get a death grip on the tool causing resistance when wood meets sharp point. Watch where the edge is cutting. You'll only get a catch when the heel or the toe dig into the wood which means you weren't watching the tool's edge. With the lathe off, lay the skew on the wood and turn it by hand to actually see where and how the tool is cutting and try different cuts and angles of tool approach. I did this a lot when I was learning how to not get a catch.

Re: oval skews

#5

Re: oval skews..... just practice and

john lucas

>Ruth is right. make light cuts with a sharp tool. When cutting beads the catches are caused by coming off the bevel. It's hard to learn to ride the bevel when turning a bead. Usually when you get a catch you have rotated the handle too far and your not rubbing the bevel so the heel grabs in the wood and runs uphill. Cutting too fast makes it easier to overotate the tool and get the catches. Like Ruth said, slow down and lighten up.

Re: oval skews

#6

Re: oval skews

Russ Babbitt

>Technique, techniqe, technique that's all it takes. Skew shape is mostly a matter of personal preference. The skew can be on of the more difficult tools to use. We all keep trying because when mastered can be very useful and makes some very smooth cuts. Besides finding a local club to get some good hands on I would suggest DVD's by Alan Lacer would be very useful.

Re: oval skews

#7

Re: oval skews

Scott Hurley in N. VA

>In Alan Lacer's video he suggests rounding the bottom edge of your skew to make it easier to roll it over. I tried it with mine, and while I am not in any way a master of the skew, I have had better success with the bottom rounded over.

Scott

Re: oval skews

#8

Re: oval skews

RK in Milwaukee

>The key to staying on the bevel with a skew is to arc the cut towards the center of the work. It's alot easier to show than to describe. In other words, you have to smoothly raise the handle of the tool as you progress into the cut. You should never push into the cut for v vuts or to roll a bead.

A skew with a radius edge is easier to use than a straight edge skew. Refer to the Lacer video.

It is a sweet tool once you get the hang of it. Keep trying.

Ron Nelson

Re: oval skews

#9

Brad Vietje

Not For Me...

Brad Vietje

>I agree with those who have suggested starting by mastering sharpening and smoothing cylinders, both heel up and toe up, and agree that there's a lot to be gained from Alan Lacer's videos and demonstrations. I also like a slight curve to the edge better than straight.

I started with old, rectangular skews with straight edges and short bevels, and tried cheating by letting the sharp corner dig into the softer cast iron rest to anchor the tool for rolling a bead -- all wrong, BTW, and a crutch for bad technique, but it seemed to work OK at least some of the time. It also put lots of tiny nicks in the rest, which is not such a great thing.

Now I use skews with rounded-over corners on the heel (shorter) side, but square corners on the toe (long point) side. This allows rolling beads with the heel, but helps to reference the tool for cutting across end grain with the long point down. Whenever I'm starting some spindle turning that involves beads, and I feel a little rusty, (I ususlly do), I hone the tools and practice a few beads on some junk wood. Admission here: When I need to turn a bead that is absolutely critical to a project (has to be just right the first time), I usually use a long-bevel detail gouge.

I have tried using an oval skew, and I must say, I didn't like it at all. There's more flex, and the tool feels way too light and flimsy in my hands -- there's also no flat side for some of the other things you'll want to do with that tool later as your skills develop -- again, check out the Lacer videos, and have fun making garden mulch with some nondescript green wood.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: oval skews

#10

Re: oval skews

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>Gary

Like you I started with the square rectangular section skew and had very bad luck using it. I ended up using it to scrape CA off the ways. Then I bought an oval skew and had better luck but now I am back to using a rectangular skew with a rounded edge simular to Alan Lacers skews. I used my belt sander to round over all my skews. I now do not like nor do I use the oval skew. Try rounding yours first before you buy an oval skew.

Terry

Re: oval skews

#11

Re: Not For Me...

john lucas

>Brad Not trying to argue or anything but I hear about oval skews flexing and I just can't feel it. Maybe I don't hang the skew over the rest far enough. I've turned with a bunch of skews and I just can't feel any flex or at least can't can't see any difference in the turning.I've turned things up to 6" in diameter with my oval skew.

I even have a skew I made from a thin file (properly annealed of course). It may be 3/16 if that thick. I only notice problems with that one when I get about 1" or more hanging over the rest.

I do notice a difference in my big skew which is almost 1/2" thick and 3" wide. On this one you have to stay below the usual cutting point of about 1/3 up. This one takes such a big bite it will catch if you get the cut higher on the blade. I can't tell the difference in vibration only the fact that the blade is so long there is more leverage on the cut so if you get to high on the blade it want's to cut really deep and you have to concentrate hareder to control the cut.

Re: oval skews

#12

Re: Not For Me...

Jorge Castaneda

>Gary

Like John, My first skew in recent history was an oval and so was my second, a present from some very frustrated person, but I was lucky to be assistant to a master turner way back in 1977, we were to rebuild a partially burned stairway and it fell on me to come up with some 120 spindles, when your bread depends on your production, you learn in a hurry. Joe Smith, my mentor, had me first making cylinders, cutting to the right, cutting to the left, everytime he had me analize how the grain of the wood was running and then decide how to attack it, to the righ or the left. The beads are really easy, but then you have to master the coves. Although Joe sold me a skew, a big gouge and a bedan and told me I really did not need any other tool, the spindles were made totally with the skew, this skew has rounded corners on the short side.

Even now, when I am lucky to sneak in some turning time, I warm up turning junk wood with the skew.

Practice practice practice, and what works for a person may not be true for the next, experiment and find what works for you.

As it was said by others, first you must master sharpening the skew, it must be very sharp.Go to it and had fun.

Jorge

Re: oval skews

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: oval skews

Keith Tompkins

>I think the reason the tool begins to feel "wierd" is you've lost and support the cutting edge had, then bango! If cutting beads with the short tip, the tip must maintain contact with the wood at all times...the second it lifts, a spiral catch. One solution is to start the cut higher up from the very tip, and keep the bevel rubbing.

I can deal with either flat or oval skews, but absolutely hate the curved cutting edge. The short point becomes nearly inaccessable, because the cutting edge above it contacts the wood first, before the tip can begin to cut. A good example is while forming a tenon on a cylinder with a 90 degree angle where they intersect. Same problem with the long point....try making a 90 degree end grain trueing cut with the long point down with the curved grind....can be done, but if the edge above the point touches as you arc the tool into the cut, the turning is ruined.

Try slowing your rpm's down to a crawl....a sharp tool will still cut, and this gives you time to analyze what's happening as it happens.