We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Has anyone had any experience with the Kryo Turning Tools sold by Craft Supplies or the P & N Tools. Is so, what were you likes & dislikes. I'm shopping for my Christmas present. Thanks in advance and Merry Christmas.
>The P&N detail gouges are superior to the other spindle gouges. They have very shallow flute; therefore a lot of steel mass remains supporting the cutting edge. You can reach out the tool further without chatter. That is a big advantage when you can't move the tool rest closer. They perform better than Sorby, Crown spindle gouges of the same diameter.
In my experiment, I chucked up a piece of square 4 x 4 SPF (spruce, pine, fir) off center. The P&N detail gouge was able to clean up the chatter that my other spindle gouges started and continued further. SPF is not turning friendly; the alternate soft / hard layers are prone to chatter, tear out. But it is a good material to tell us what works or not.
I also have K&N bowl gouges. I find the bowl gouges are over shadowed by their detail gouges. I would recommend the detail gouges without hesitation.
>Adding to what Gordon has said, the P&N Spindle Rouging Gouge is a great tool as well. Very beefy and solid. I think Woodcraft.com still has it on closeout sale for a great price, unhandled.
I have a 5/8" Crown Pro-PM bowl gouge and like it a lot. The edge does seem to hold for a long time. I bought the regular grind and reground it with an Ellsworth/swept back grind. That saved me about $65 over getting it already ground with an Ellsworth grind.
I also have one Henry Taylor Kryo tool. I like it and it works well, but it is a gouge that was designed for that tricky turn in bowls where the side becomes the bottom. It's almost like a very big (1/2") detail gouge with more of a bowl lip on the grind.
>I own a Kryo 1/2" rolled edge skew and love it. It holds a edge quite well and hones great. I hone it before each use and have zero complaints about it.
This tool works very well for me. I have used it for pens, bottlestoppers, and tops, so far.
>My opinion is that the cryogenic treatment is a gimmick and not worth the extra money they are asking for the tools. There are more important things that make a better turning tool - metallurgy, grain size, alloying metals, etc. Wearability is directly related to the Vanadium content of the tool steel.
If the cryo-tool is a better tool, it is because it is a better steel and not how cold it got during its manufacture. And, if it is a better steel, then it is worth the extra money.
The opposite is also true. If the steel is a common M-2 grade of HSS, there is no amount of freezing at any temperature that will make it into something other than an M-2 steel. In that case the money would be better spent on buying a tool with a better grade of steel, like an M-4 or 2030.
The problem is that, the way these tools are advertised, there is no way of knowing what specifications or metallurgy we are getting.
>I haven't owned a Kryo tool yet so I can't comment on how good they are. I do know that the process of krogenic treating of certain metals does make them tougher. It's been proven in several industries and the custom made knife industries use it a lot. Now is the tool that much better for turning purposes? I guess we won't know for few years until enough people have them to say authoritatively that they are better or worse. Turning tools undergo a lot of abuse and must be sharpened often, even the hardest ones. So there are actually 2 issues here. How long it holds and edge and how easy it is to sharpen that edge.
I'm going to keep my ear to the turning circles and my money my pocket until I learn more.
>Thnks for supplying this link. There is a lot of misinformation and outright advertising "fluff" (for want of a stronger word) out there to confuse people. I hope a lot of people read this. Getting straight answers from the steel and tool industries is impossible.
>The gouge I was talking about is a 9/16" Shallow Gouge (Steve LeGrue grind), which is available in M2 HSS or M4 HSS from, The Cutting Edge. The catalog I have describes it as, "superb for both spindle and faceplate work". The link to The Cutting Edge site with a picture of the grind is below.
>I've gotten several P & N tools from Rich Johnson in San Jose, CA. Their detail gouge and bowl gouge are very fine tools. I ground one of the bowl gouges with an Ellsworth jig. I've found that the flute is too narrow and deep to easily eject the curls of real wet wood (Madrone and Maple). The curls pack the flute tightly and is a pain to stop and remove often.
Rich has competitive prices and is a good guy to deal with.