Tear-outs in bowls: avoidable or not?
Aage Rendalen
>Are tear-outs in bowls a fact of life, like taxes and death? Have any of you emerged victorious in the battle against damaged fibres?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Tear-outs in bowls: avoidable or not?
Aage Rendalen
>Are tear-outs in bowls a fact of life, like taxes and death? Have any of you emerged victorious in the battle against damaged fibres?
Re: Tear-outs in bowls: avoidable or not?
john lucas
>Absolutely. It's mostly just technique and sharp tools. I find that many people force the cut. If the tool isn't really sharp you push on the tool to get it to cut. This not only gives you a bad cut but also reinforces the habit of pushing on the gouge. Both of these problems cause tear out. Use sharp tools and try to let the wood tell your hands how hard to push. You should see nice curls with light hand pressure.
The other problem is grain direction. It is important to always cut down hill or with the grain. On bowls,particularly curly grain bowls this can be challenging. When you are first roughing the bowl try cutting with the grain as much as you can. If you notice tearout on one area you might try cutting in the opposite direction at that point. This isn't always practical so always try a freshly sharpened tool and really light pressure first. Cutting is always better than scraping so try to get your technique down to the point that you don't need a scraper.
Tool geometry has a lot to do with it as well. Bowl gouges are sharpened with an angle of 40 to about 75 degrees depending on the type of gouge and the preference of the user. 40 degrees will usually tear out less than 50, and 50 less than 65 etc. However you might not be able to turn the bowl and keep the bevel in contact with the wood if you use a 40 degree angle.
Last but not least try altering the characteristics of the wood. Spray some water on it before making a final pass or try putting paste wax on it. I apply a coat of thinned lacquer. If it's really punky wood I apply multiple coats and let them dry. Some people recommend soaking the bowl in a mixture of white glue and water mixed 50/50. Minwax wood hardner also works.
That's kind of it in a nutshell. I'm sure you'll get some more good advice from this crowd.
Re: Why should I add to some already
Allen Neighbors
>good advice? John pretty well nailed it. In the nutshell. :o)
One Little (really) Addition
Brad Vietje
>I'll just throw into the discussion, that the type and state of the wood matter a lot, too. John alludes to this near the bottom when he mentions wetting or oiling the wood. Some wood is un-turnable without special efforts and techniques because it's beyond spalted, and starting to rot. Some woods are also easier than others. A real dense, fine grained wood will usually cut more cleanly than softer, more stringy woods.
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
Re: Tear-outs in bowls: avoidable or not?
Keith Tompkins
>Aage, there are several things I do to avoid tearout. The best thing to do is find a species of wood that tears out terribly...then practice on it, finding what techniques work, and which ones do not. I find Butternut, walnut, and silver maple are prone to tear-out.
On a particularly tough piece, I will sharpen and then hone my bowl gouges. Not all grinds will cut as cleanly as others. A skewing, shearing cut will often cut cleanly; just as in hand-planing a curly figured board. This is difficult to do with several popular grinds, I have developed my own grind for this.
When the bowl gouge still has trouble, I reach for my secret weapon....a finely honed spindle gouge, used with the flute facing away from the bowl. Rolling the flute towards the wood results in an even cleaner, but riskier cut. The old continental style gouges work the best, but be warned in advance....just like using a spindle roughing gouge on a bowl(which I DO NOT recommend) careless handling of the tool will result in a broken tang.
Why go to the trouble and risk then? A glass smooth cut instead of a torn surface.
Re: Tear-outs in bowls: avoidable or not?
Russ Fairfield
>This is the tool and orientation Kieth was talking about.
Re: Tear-outs in bowls: avoidable or not?
Keith Tompkins
>That's it! thanks, Russ
Re: Tear-outs in bowls can be avoided
Russ Fairfield
>As a first step, the problem may be in how the tool is presented to the wood. You should begin with taking lighter cuts with a sharper tool in problem wood. Don't be afraid to use a slip-stone on the edge of the tool. You can also support the end-grain fibers with wax, soap, water, finish products, or any number of other things. However, these address the symptoms and not the problem.
This is probably only a personal opinion, but I see the real problem as being that bowl gouge profiles are ground with a convex bevel. That works fine on the outside of the bowl where the curvature of the wood matches that of the bevel, and the wood is supported at the cutting edge. There is a mismatch of the curves when that same tool is used on the inside of the bowl. That means there is a 2-point suspension - the cutting edge and the heel of the bevel; and there is no support for the wood as it is being cut. This may not be imporant with a lot of wood, but there can be severe tear-out in many species where the fiber bond of the wood between the grain boundaries is weak.
The solution is to move the tool support closer to the cutting edge. That can be done by grinding a convex bevel on the gouge to better match the curvature of the inside of the bowl. You can get close enough in most cases by grinding away the sharp corner at the heel of the bevel, thereby having the effect of making a narrower bevel below the cutting edge and moving the support closer to the cutting edge.
The Continental style spindle gouge has the advantage of a longer radius at the tip to make a better shearing cut across the wood grain, and the thinner tool has a shorter bevel that reduces the effect of the concave bevel, and moves the support closer to the cutting edge.
You can probably tell that I am not a supporter of the "Do it all with ONE gouge" school of bowl turning. This photo is what I call my "inside grind". Yes, the bevel has all of those ugly multiple facets that woodturners don't like, but the only one the wood sees is the one at the cutting edge.
HERESY !!! But Absolutely Right.
Brad Vietje
>I've gotten tired of mentioning flat or convex bevels, so I an DELIGHTED to know that Russ is in my camp, too. Thanks, Russ !
It seems we have some in the turning world that have an overzealous appreciation for hollow grinds, and I've been beaten up on another turning forum for even suggesting that convex grinds would work better in some situations. I've found that concave (hollow) grinds work better on spindles and the outside of bowls, while convex bevels can work better on the inside. For quite some time I sharpened all my tools with flat bevels as a decent compromise that split the difference, and worked pretty darned well in almost every case.
These days I have some tools hollowed and honed, but some with flat bevels and yes, perish the thought, even a convex bevel or two. Having inherited an additional bowl gouge from my father's passing, I'm going to keep it and an old continental gouge with a convex bevel for just these situations -- so there! Russ says it's OK -- plenty good enough for me.
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
Re: Tear-outs in bowls can be avoided
john lucas
>Russ Don't look at this as an argument more of a question. When you have a concave grind that's been honed you have a sort of micro bevel similar to a carving tool. Won't this micro bevel support the fibers when cutting. This isn't exactly the same as a convex grind but I would think the wood will compress enough when being cut that it won't know the difference in a flat micro bevel and a convex grind. Maybe I'm thinking too much for my own good this morning. As always, I'll probably go out and grind a tool convex and try it on the next piece of tear out prone I attack.
Re: Tear-outs in bowls can be avoided
Russ Fairfield
>John, you are correct. Theoretically, honing to a micro-bevel should do the same thing, IF you hone the cutting edge. I don't. The problem with doing that is that some woods, Walnut and Cottonwood are two of them, that like to have a wider band of support below the cutting edge than what you get from honing.
In all cases, the hard edge at the heel of the bevel should be rounded so it doesn't have control of the tool.
If nothing else this gives me an excuse to have more bowl gouges.
Re: Tear-outs in bowls can be avoided
John Lucas
>Russ How do you sharpen a convex curve? Especially trying to resharpen it. I could push it into the unsupported portion of my belt sander but thier must be a better way. Any your right, that is a good excuse to by another bowl gouge or spindle gouge.