Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Fir for Turning?

Posts

Fir for Turning?

#1

Fir for Turning?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Everybody,

My best friend called me yeasterday from his daughter's home where he is visiting. His daughter had a 60 foot fir tree taken down, and Charlie claimed one of the trunk logs as his own, and says he has enough sections to nearly fill his station wagon. We plan to get together later next week and make bowl blanks. I never turned fir. Is it worth turning? What can I expect? Is it best turned green? We are both novices, so we'd appreciate your comments, and any photo you may have of turned fir. Thanks.

George

George

Re: Fir for Turning?

#2

Brad Vietje

Re: Fir for Turning?

Brad Vietje

>Hey George,

Fir is a challenge to turn because the early wood and late wood (lighter and darker bands of the growth rings) are very different in hardness. Can be done with very sharp tools and very fine, slow finish cuts, and especially very light pressure when sanding. This is fairly common for softwoods, and the gumminess from sap and pitch can be a drag, too. You can dip the tools in kerosene or mineral spirits to clean them up.

Another option is to experiment a bit and exploit the hardness difference for creative effect. You can scorch and sand the outer surface, sandblast them, or just use a very stiff wire brush to add texture to a band, or the whole thing. To make a standard wire brush stiffer, squeeze the bristles in a clamp, and hold this against the spinning bowl.

I'm sure others will have beter ideas, but its certainly worth turning at least a few bowls -- it isn't great firewood, after all.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Fir for Turning?

#3

Funny you should mention fir.

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Last Thursday at our turning club meeting a guy brought in two natural edged Douglas fir bowls. Really nice looking pieces. But Douglas fir is not fir nor is it pine or hemlock. Its scientific name Pseudotsuga means false hemlock. It is a separate species onto itself. So what kind of fir is it?

Dave Smith

Pseudo woodworker in Longview, WA.

Re: Fir for Turning?

#4

Re: Funny you should mention fir.

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Hello Dave,

You ain't no pseudo, my friend. I don't know any more info. I'll see the wood for the first time next week, but its more likely to increase rather than decrease my ignorance.

George

Re: Fir for Turning?

#5

Re: Funny you should mention fir.

Ed Karch

>Dave

If it is in PA it probably is not ugly dougly although my neighbor had a Christmas tree farm here in VA with lots of DF.

Ed

Former Oregon Forester

Re: Fir for Turning?

#6

Re: Fir for Turning?

Ron McKinley

>Brad is right on. I've turned a few pieces of Doug Fir and and it's a real challenge. Hemlock is similar but a little easier. But,I've seen some beautiful pieces done by Master Woodturners.......Ron

Re: Fir for Turning?

#7

Re: Fir for Turning?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>George, in my opinion life is too short to turn crappy wood. As a turning wood, fir fits into that catagory. However, if a challenge to your turning skills is what you want, have at it. It can be done, and with fairly good results. There are a couple of "musts" if you do....you MUST cut with the grain. If you don't, it'll take twice the effort to even make a cut, and the result will be very torn grain. You must have very sharp tools and you must make an effort to rub the bevel as you cut.

Good luck,

Wally

Re: Fir for Turning?

#8

Re: Fir for Turning?

Gordon Seto

>For the same reason, it is the best personal teacher. It gives immediate response.

It is a good material to try out a new concept. It tells what works, what doesn't. No second guessing needed.

Gordon