Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

Posts

Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

#1

Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

Bob Cook

>I am considering buying either the Powermatic 3520B or the Vega

2600-Inv. and am looking for comment and or advise.

I have been turning for about 4 years on a Nova3000 with AC motor. I

live in Arizona so don't have the ability to find, large pieces of

wood to turn. I almost always turn purchased blocks of wood that I cut round on my bandsaw, or segemented turnings. I love my Nova300 but the shortcomings for me are not having variable speed and having only 16in. swing over the bed.

The one feature that I hate to give up is the ability to swivel the

head. I always turn the headstock 22 1/2 degrees to turn the inside of my bowls. I rarely do spindle work and if I do it is short in length, rarely more than 12 to 13 in. long. I have never felt a need for more that the 1 hp. motor on my Nova.

I am considering the Powermatic 3520b because of the ability to move

the headstock to the end of the lathe and then stand in front of the

work while turning the inside of bowls. I am sure that I would rarely

move the headstock from this position. Of course the Vega 2600 also

would allow me to stand in front of the work.

The drawback with the Vega would be not being able to turn spindle work shorter than 6in. I sometimes turn handles for the decorative

rollingpins that I turn.

Any and all advise from Powermatic and Vega owners would be

appreciated.

Bob Cook

Re: Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

#2

Re: Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

Sean Troy

>There are plenty of very large trees in Arizona. Eucalyptus, Ash, mesquite to name a few. When I lived there, I was regularly turning over 18"-20". Eucalyptus is easy to come by and the trees can be well over 4' in Dia. If your not a member of one of the three turning clubs, I would strongly urge you to join one. Good way to network for wood and best of all improve your skills. If your going to turn more than bowls, go with the 3520b

Re: Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

#3

Re: Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv *LINK*

Sean Troy

>I meant to add in the address of the Az. Woodturners association


http://www.azwoodturners.org

Re: Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

#4

Re: Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

Ed Kelle

>I've got the 3250B and most of the time I have the headstock at least at mid lathe and mostly further for bowls. Love being able to stand in front or either side of it. Reverse is a dream as well, both for sanding and turning. I don't know much about the Vega, but I wouldn't trade mine for anything. The only potential downside is removing the tailstock for working at the end. I've done it so many times that the weight does not bother me, but you could build a swing away extension for the end of the lathe to avoid this. Don't forget it has the built in indexing as well. It's a great machine and I have qute a few friends who love theirs also.

Re: Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

#5

Re: Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>Bob,

I am no expert on the Powermatic, though I have turned on several and I like them.

I do own and turn on a Vega, and have worked with Vega over the last few years. In that time they have developed a bed extention (the tailstock will not attach to it, but it allows the tool rest to be placed farther from the headstock, or to use some of the captured hollowing rigs. They are in the midst of developing a simple spindle lock - but I have been happy using tommy bars. The VS motor system is a dream - smooth, powerful and quiet.

For me, the deciding factor was my small shop. The footprint on the Vega is half that of the Powermatic.

I started turning bowl on a Jet Mini, and I get very used to turning standing directly in front of the bowl, not leaning in over the bed.

A recent change to the lathe extended the Tailstock ram so that it comes very close to touching the spindle, so the between the spindle distance issue, should no longer be an issue.

Randy, at Vega, can answer any question you have.

Vega lathes, mobile bases, duplicators, TS Fences, etc, are all built here in the USA, and they manage to sell everything the make every year. I believe that fact is a testiment to their quality.

In short, I highly recommend the Vega, though the Powermatic is nice. If you turn mostly bowls, IMHO buy a bowl lathe.

Email me if you have specific quesitons.

Mark

Re: Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

#6

Re: Question for Mark- I haven't used ....

Jamie Donaldson

>... the newer Vegas- have they improved the tailstock alignment problems over the older machines? I remember that the whole tailstock was not as sturdy as the newer models seem to be, but without using I need the info from the horses mouth, and I know that you are a critical user.

Re: Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

#7

Re: Question for Mark- I haven't used ....

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>Jamie,

Not sure about your definition of older Vegas. I have had my over two years, and only speak to mine, and that time frame. My understanding is that each tailstock is custom aligned to each lathe. I found mine to be dead on. I recently did 40 chair spindles w/o any problem.

If someone is buying this for an all-round lathe, it is probably not what I would recommend. If I need a long spindle, I use my Mini with the bed extension. If when you are not doing bowls, you are doing pens, this would work, but is certainly not the best.

Is is by name and defination a bowl lathe, and as such a tailstock on this machine is more for safe roughing out of big bowls.

I know alot of people that have bad opinions of Vega based on the original Vega 2400 from years ago. Vega has worked, and continues to work to improve the current 2600. HOWEVER, they have no aspiration to be the next VB36 or whatever. They are producing the best pure bowl lathe for under $2800 (in my opinion).

BTW: If you go to their website (www.vegawoodworking.com) the front page photo is the current model, not the one in the 2600 page - even most of those stats on the 2600 page are not current.

BTW BTW: Come down to the real South, and try turning on my lathe. ;>0

Mark

Re: Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

#8

Dick Hines

Re: Question for Mark- I haven't used ....

Dick Hines

>I have a 3520A and love it. The 3520A does not have indexing but I have never had the ocation to use one so it was not a decideing factor when I bought my lathe.

I am about 50-50 bowls and hollow forms. I do very little spindle turning except for ornaments and bottle stopers this time of the year.As Mark said the foot print could be the selling point if you have a small shop.

I bet which ever lathe you get you will love it.

Re: Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

#9

Re: Hey Mark- that invite to 'bama....

Jamie Donaldson

>.....sounds good tonight- it's 10 degrees F here in central KY tonight, and I'm leaving for a show in Cleveland early tomorrow morning! And I was alluding to Vegas much older than yours.

Re: Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

#10

Re: Hey Mark- that invite to 'bama....

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>Yeah, well come down and warm up, suppose to be about 25 degrees tonight, but we are almost 60 during the day.

Maybe you can come down and demo for us sometime.

Yeah, I hear it all the time from folks that have only seen the old ones, and then see the new ones, that they are a great improvement.

Mark

Re: Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

#11

Re: Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

Rick Davenport

>I've got a 3520b and love it.

I can't speak for the Vega, but if you are looking for versatility the PM might be the way to go.

Have you checked out the Oliver in the succeeding thread?

The price is right!!

R

Re: Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

#12

Brad Vietje

Re: Hey Mark- that invite to 'bama....

Brad Vietje

>I could really use a trip to 'bama, too. I'd love to visit my son, who is flying whirlygigs down at Ft. Rucker, and it was 8 deg. F here this AM, with a wind chill well below zero...

'Bout the lathes: I went through a very similar decision process before buying my lathe (3520-B). Originally, I had big ambitions, and figured I'd get a Vega for bowls and hollow forms, and an older Powermatic 90, or possibly the 3520-B for all other work, which in my dreams also included a bed extension and a lot of architectural spindle turning up to 8' in length. Changes in life plans drove the decision to get one machine -- the P-M, as a great compromise that would accomplish everything except the extra 4" or so in diameter. I can still build or buy an extension if I decide I need it, I get the advantages of a bowl lathe by moving the headstock, and I can still use my hollowing rig for larger H-F's.

Conclusion: I like them both, but the P-M seemed the more versatile for my needs. Today, though, I might be swayed by a lathe with built-in heat !

Safe (warm...?) spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

#13

Re: Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Bob, I just now saw this thread here. I already responded to your same question over on rec.crafts.woodturning regarding my Vega and my opinion about it, so I won't repeat it here. Just thought I would let you know it is there though.

Bill

Re: Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

#14

Re: Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

Bob Fawcett

>Bob,

I have the 3520b and I love it. It has great variable speed, plenty of power, and runs very smooth and quiet. (I can turn while my wife takes her midday nap on the weekend).

I also have the 18" bed extension. This can be mounted on the bed or on the leg unit about 10" down from the bed. It comes with an extension for the tool rest and increases your swing to nearly double. You should be able to turn a bowl as large as you can on a Vega with this option.

Re: Powermatic 3520b compared to Vega 2600-Inv

#15

Re: Hey Mark- that invite to 'bama....

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>Come on down, Brad, I have a spare room. I am about 1.5 hrs North of Wirly-bird town.

Yeah, suppose to be down in the low 20s tonight - good gosh, this is the deep South.

Oh, just so no one gets me wrong - I thing the 3520 - especially the B model is a great lathe in that price range. It all came down to footprint for me. I had out club Jet1642 ('bout the same size) in the shop for two weeks and I knew it would not work for me. Now that I am expanding my shop by 60%, my decision may have been different. BUT since buying the Vega, I have NEVER said "Gee, I wish I had a.....". Randy at Vega is tops in customer service. I thought I needed a bed extention and built a prototype, and they made one and decided to offer it to customers. I decided that I wanted to try making a moveable tailstock for my bed extension (just for holding large segmented hollow forms together when I make them in two peices), they sold me the parts and the picture shows the results.

I don't think you can go wrong either way, but I do like the Vega.

Mark


img