Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

What bowl turning tools do I need? - Long

Posts

What bowl turning tools do I need? - Long

#1

What bowl turning tools do I need? - Long

Joe Pack

>Craft show season 2006 is over. After a thousand or so pens, keychains, bottle stoppers, etc, with retirement looming at the end of February, and with Mr. Grumbine's two DVD's having inspired me, I am looking forward to moving on to bowls, but need advice on tooling. I am trying to sort out the tooling I genuinely need for bowl turning. I spent an hour looking at the 25% off Sorby tools at Rockler last weekend, but didn't really know what I was doing, so I kept my money in my pocket. Plus, every catalog or web sales page sells the "best," and, of course, the new bowl turner should have one of everything! Somehow, I trust my WC friends more than the marketing folks.

I have two lathes - a Jet mini that I do all my craft stuff on - and a Jet 1442 that I bought a year or so ago, but have not used much except for buffing. (I bought it early for three reasons...I planned to get a full-size lathe eventually when I retired, I had the cash from a good craft show season and, the main reason, I got it for a "below market" price that I couldn't turn down.

I have a good assortment of spindle turning tools - gouges, skews, scrapers, parting tools, "specialty" tools, plus a Wolvering grinding jig (including skew and vari-grind attachments). My only specific bowl tool is a 16" long, 1/2" diameter shaft Crown bowl gouge that Bill G. put a side-grind on. (That one feels too short and too light, but what do I know?) I also have an "original" two-wrench Nova chuck.

I would appreciate input from folks I respect as to what tools I should be looking at. I don't want to throw money away, but I don't mind buying quality the first time. I also am not interested in "getting by," only to wish six months later that I would have bought the "right" tool the first time....You get the idea.

I am looking for input re: gouges (size, weight, etc.), drives (4 prong, 2 prong, Steb...), chucks (do I want a different one?), tool rests, and anything else I have not thought of.

Thanks to all. Enjoy helping me spend my money! :-)

Re: What bowl turning tools do I need? - Long

#2

Re: What bowl turning tools do I need? - Long

Carole Valentine

>When I do bowls, I usually only use two tools: a 3/8" bowl gouge (with a swept back grind) and a Sorby multi-tip with the tear-drop scraper. Of course there is the parting tool, which also comes in handy for doing recesses, but you already have one of those. If I want to do beads on the rim or elsewhere, I use my detail gouge.

Re: What bowl turning tools do I need? - Long

#3

Re: What bowl turning tools do I need? - Long

eliot d

>I think what you have is fine. I do just about all bowl turning with a 5/8 in Glasser that has the Ellsworth grind( or something very similar). It's good also to get a heavy round scraper to clean up the inside with. You really don't need many tools to turn bowls. Now, if you want to talk hollowing, that's another story.

Re: What bowl turning tools do I need? - Long

#4

Steven Antonucci

Need or nice to have?

steve antonucci

>I have more tools than I need. That being said, I use most of them.

For turning a bowl, you need a bowl gouge. Just one. Need.

On the other hand, Some people have different grind on their bowl gouges for different situations. I have a long swept back grind on a Oneway (1/2", I think) and a very blunt grind on a 5/8" Sorby that I like for the bottoms of bowls. If you learn to cut with both of them, you don't need any scrapers. I also have a bunch of scrapers since I haven't mastered the inside of a bowl yet.

All together, probably own 6-8 gouges with different grinds and such.

Steve

Re: What bowl turning tools do I need? - Long

#5

No expert, but when buying tools I try

Don Henthorn

>buy each tool as I need it. As has been said in a recent thread, turning is an individual thing and we all use different tools and techniques according to what works best for us. I would start out with what you have and then when you have a need for a tool to do a specific thing ask for help selecting that tool. You will still get various answers, but you then decide which one would work best for you. If not sure go to your local turning club and see if members will let you try the different tools you could use. Just my thoughts.

Re: What bowl turning tools do I need? - Long

#6

Re: What bowl turning tools do I need? - Long *LINK*

Vincent Welch

>Hi Joe,

I recommend that you try to get with other turners that you respect who share the same philosophy as you concerning tools and turning. Learning what tools you like is part of this great journey. I started with 5 Sorby tools and I beleive that less is moreconcerning tools. I do not want to become a tool junky. (Not that there is anything wrong with that!) Today let just say I have more then 5 tools but I prefer Oneway M4 double sided steel with Oneway handles and Henry Taylor(HT) for M2 tools because I love HT massive long handles. Their GREAT!

Good luck, Vince

P.S. Also remember once you have your prefered profile on your tool, when you sharpen you only need a light touch to raise a burr. So sharpen lightly but sharpen often.


http://vincesWoodNWonders.com

Re: What bowl turning tools do I need? - Long

#7

Re: What bowl turning tools do I need? - Long

Barry Irby

>I use a half inch gouge with an Ellsworth grind on it. A multi tip Sorby scraper, and a heavy scraper, and a parting tool. Many of us have many more tools and get very little use out of them. If we knew which four or five you would like in advance, you could save a lot of expense and frustration. I suggest you follow the advice to join a turning club and check out other members techniques and tools. Play with them a little and buy the ones you like.

I have the same chuck you do and found it would not hold well for me, so now it is almost totally dedicated to the Cole jaws. I also have two Supernova chucks, the kind that use that sort of weird (hateful) chuck key. I would rather have the ones that use the Tee handled Allen wrenches. At least I think I would, but I have not tried one.

I found that 100mm jaws work well for me, but check out the various sizes. I have some deep jaws and found they did not hold as well as shallow ones.

Check out the chucks carefully and get one that will accept the jaws of other manufacturers.

Re: What bowl turning tools do I need? - Long

#8

Re: What bowl turning tools do I need? - Long

Clay Foster

>Joe,

You already have everything you need. It's not the arrow, it's the archer.

Re: What bowl turning tools do I need? - Long

#9

You need LOTS (long) - Long

Rick Allen

>I am going to be a bit contrary here. First I think you NEED lots of tools to do bowl turning.

Two 1/2" (measured as 5/8" on the tool shaft) bowl gouges. These can be the tools sold by Penn State as I find they are as good as any. The primary reason for two identical bowl gouges is sharpening. One of the most important skills you will learn when turning bowls is when to sharpen your bowl gouge. If you have two bowl gouges that are both sharp then you can try the second gouge if you "think" the sharpness of the tool you are using might be an issue. Yes you could go to the grinder or diamond hone or whatever else you might want to sharpen a tool with. But that change of activity between turning and sharpening will get in the way of evaluating the sharpness of the tool you are using.

A good respirator. One of the power respirators like the Trend would be good. When sanding a bowl or platter you will generate a LOT more sanding dust than when turning small spindles. The quality and comfort of your dust protection becomes a LOT more important.

A chuck for each set of jaws so you don't have to swap out jaws. The Oneway Talon is a terrific chuck for the size lathes you have.

Dust collection. For the same reason as the respirator you need improved dust collection. A good DC and a good dust hood will help a LOT.

You need something to create all of that dust. Power Sanding is the way to go when sanding bowls. This means a Sioux close quarters drill, 2" and 3" sanding mandrills and an assortment of 2" and 3" sanding discs. Buying sanding discs in quantities of 50 for each grit and size is a good place to start. I like the blue film discs but there are a LOT of other discs available. Many woodturning clubs do group buys on sanding discs which can help a LOT with the cost.

Two moffit lights. These are the goose neck lights which stay cool to the hand and shine a LOT of light on the scratches you put in your bowls. If it difficult to get rid of the scratches if you can't see them.

Magnifying headband. I am guessing that your eyes are less perfect than they were. Extra magnification will help a LOT when looking for those scratches.

Calipers, outside, bowl and the veritas calipers will help you get the thickness you are looking for.

Chainsaw. One of the big differences between turning pens and bowls is the size of the wood you are turning. With size comes cost. To off-set that cost you can process green wood.

Bandsaw. A 14" with a riser and a 1 1/2 HP (or more) motor.

Air compressor.

A waste system and procedure. The waste you will be producing turning bowls can fill a 35 gallon trash can in an afternoon. So a good way to deal with the waste will give you more time to turn wood. Please note that the distance and directions that waste will travel from your bowl gouge will make your shop a mess. If you can contain the waste at the start you will be way ahead of the game. The best way to contain is to put everything in cabinets with doors or drawers that close. Throw a sheet over any horizontal surfaces before you start. Look for places like corners where waste might accumulate.

Finishing. The processes for finishing are different for bowls than they are for pens. Friction polish doesn't work on a bowl. A box of disposable gloves, paper towels for applying finish...

Storage. You will need a LOT more storage room for bowl blanks, roughed out bowls and the like.

Recap:

2 - 1/2" bowl gouges

Respirator

Chuck and jaws

Dust collection

Power sanding

Inspection lights, calipers and magnifying

Bowl blank prep, chainsaw, bandsaw

Air compressor

Waste control

Finishing

Storage

Re: What bowl turning tools do I need? - Long

#10

Brian McKearney

Re: What bowl turning tools do I need? - Long

Brian McKearney

>As some of the others have said, I think that you have everything that you need to get started. After you have turned a couple of bowls, you'll undoubtedly think of some items that would make things easier and/or more enjoyable and you can get those as you go along.

I have four bowl gouges - one Crown Pro PM 5/8" and three 3/8" (two Sorby and one Oneway). Of all of those, I ONLY use the 5/8" bowl gouge for roughing bowls. My two Sorby 3/8" bowl gouges have different grindes, but I can turn a complete bowl with only one of those - the second has a much more blunt grind and I only sometimes use it for the bottoms of bowls. My Oneway and one of my Sorby's have an Ellsworth style grind and between the two, I think I actually like the Sorby better.

As you get into bowl turning, one of the most frustrating parts will probably be "How do I clean up the foot of the bowl once the bowl is complete?" My solution was to eventually get a set of Cole jaws and I find that they work great, although it gets tedious at times swapping jaws and then repositioning the bumpers. It may be less tedious to use a vacuum chuck, but I haven't gotten there yet - that has been on my list for several years, but at this point I'm not sure that I want one.

Good luck and have fun - I never get tired of turning bowls!

Brian

Re: What bowl turning tools do I need? - Long

#11

Thanks to all.

Joe Pack

>Thanks for your input. Regardless of what my Sweetie Pie says, I do sometimes listen! :-)

Maybe I'll have products worth posting here sometime soon.

Joe

Re: What bowl turning tools do I need? - Long

#12

Re: What bowl turning tools do I need? - Long *LINK*

Darrell Feltmate

>Joe

I like to turn bowls. For me, if I were using gouges I would "need" a 3/8" bowl gouge with a long grind, and a 1/4" bowl gouge with a straight grind along with 1" heavy scraper. I would "like" 1/4", 3/8" and 5/8" bowl gouges each with a straight grind and a long grind.

On the other hand I do not use bowl gouges. I like inserted tip or Oland tools for bowls. I make my own because it is easy and cheap and I have them in sizes from 1/8" to 1/2" and various grinds. Check my web site on tool making for hints.


Around the Woods