Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

Posts

'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

#1

'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

Allen Neighbors

>In an earlier post, Carole said, "As I see it, grinds are a very personal thing. What someone else considers the "perfect grind" for a given application may NOT be perfect for you." Her statements are true. It may not work for me, even though it's perfect for you.

Why is that so? If it works for you, why won't it work for me?

Is it because of the particular way we position the toolrest?

Is it because we don't slant the cutting edge quite the same way, or that we don't roll the tool handle enough?

Just thought it would be interesting to hear what others think.

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

#2

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

Ron in Drums PA

>All things being equal, the simple answer would be "It's what we get used to"

At Totally Turning the year, Kieth T. and Cindy D. both had a similar tool made from 1/4" round HSS. Both of the said the the grind is just like the one they use on a bowl gouge. Yet both where totally different.

I made one, but couldn't get it to work right until I shaped it like my spindle gouge with a secondary bevel. Bottom line "It's what I was used too for the type of turning I needed it for"

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

#3

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

Russ Babbitt Jr.

>There are right ways of doing things and suggested ways of doing things. Wood magazine did an article on the Wolverine and grinding a while back that was a very good suggested starting point. The shapes and angles they gave were very good suggestions. We all have different ways of doing things. Angles that work for what we do, boxes or hollow forms, etc. We learn from experience and others we see. We try to take what we learn and and take the best ideas that work for us. I find that modern woodturning is still evolving. Tools change, tools are invented. Beginner turners should start with the suggested methods and build on experience.

Did that make sense?

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

#4

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

Carole Valentine

>Tough question, Allen. There are so many factors. The way I see it is that if all human bodies were the same and all lathes, lathe heights and tool rest adjustments were the same and we all moved the same way and used the same cuts and had the same tools and the same wood, we could all use exact same grind. That scenario does not exist. I agree with Russ B. that beginners should start with something close to a recommended grind. As they continue to turn, that grind will more than likely evolve into one that is slightly unique and comfortable for them.

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

#5

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

Bill Crommett

>And then sometimes you just don't hold your mouth right !

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

#6

Re: 'Nother Question from a newbie's POV

Carol from AZ

>It is helpful to learn what 'riding the bevel' and 'rolling into the cut" mean and how to do them. It is also helpful to have someone show a person what all those angles reference and how to measure them.

Now I know what I want to do, and have an idea of what it takes to get that to happen. Angles and bevels are related and subject to the stature of the turner and relationship to the lathe height. Comfort in making the cuts has lots to do with success and safety. Knowing the angle and being able to measure it is simply to have a frame of reference for repeatability of grinding them. Jigs help but stuff happens. I am not anal about numbers, as past math teachers will readily attest, but one has to start somewhere!

I have some experiementing to do and as is my style to analyse the why of things, I will be noting some observations.

Meanwhile, this is way too much fun! I am already trying to figure out a way to have a traveling turning shop on wheels to follow me around for the next couple of years as I continue the path I am on. I have this little cargo trailer, a mini lathe, a grinder, a Wolverine, a nice selection of Henry Taylors, a suitable DC, but the bandsaw is too big for this, a benchtop drill press I may finally have found a use for, and ..... much imagination!

Right now I have a friend with one arm who I am helping to get his lathe going for him. In return he will let me play with it as well. Now for some time to work on this.

Excuse me, I have to go wash my hair!

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

#7

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

Carole Valentine

>And that is the most important thing of all!!! LOL Obviously I have not been doing that for the past few days. Everything I have touched has turned (no pun intended) into crapola! I am going back out to the shop, super-glue the corners of my mouth into a permanent, optimistic smile and try again. Surely there is one piece of wood out there that I won't crush like an eggshell, blow the neck out of or turn into a spiral ham with the skew. ;))

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

#8

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

john lucas

>Allen that's kind of a tough question to answer. All of thegrinds work. As you learn more you will find that you prefer a different grind. Either it lets you hold the gouge the way you like or it cuts certain shapes the way you like. I have a bunch of bowl gouges. Only 2 are ground the same. That gives me a chance to try a lot of different grinds and some I like more than others but they all work.

My favorite doesn't resemble very many people's gouge. It has very long wings that are thin from the sharpening point of view and the tip is ground about 45 to 50 degrees. I've seen 2 other turners with this grin and we each arrived at it independantly.

Usually if a grind doesn't work for you it either means you just haven't spend enough time with it, or your work is shaped such that this grind won't work very well. A good example is when I'm turning with the Ellsworth grind I get used to it and will reach for that tool for the next few projects. Then I'll go back to hand mirrors and find it doesn't work as well as my old style gouge so I'll switch to it. Then when I pick up the Ellsworth gouge again I have to re-learn how to use it.

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

#9

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

Bob Fawcett

>Allen,

Good question. I think the answer is that it will "work" for you, it just doesn't fit your habits. As a beginner, most of my tools have grinds on them similar to what the manufacturer shipped them with. I try to copy what they did. When I first started, I built a few grinding jigs to allow me to duplicate the grinds I had. I still use several of them, even though I have a varigrind.

I do have one bowl gouge I created my version of the Ellsworth grind on. I still use it and like it. The grind looks similar to others I have seen, but probably isn't exactly the same.

I also have a Glaser and a Sweazey. I take great pains to set my jig to keep these as shipped, at least until I learn a little more.

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

#10

I think I have seen tis question posed several

Don Henthorn

>different ways with a great many very learned answers. But as many have commented in the responses turning is an individual thing based on our individual preferences. We don't all use the same tools and we don't all use the same tools in the same way. Turning is always in a flux because there are those who advance very rapidly in skill but may still be using the tools and techniques with which they are familiar, while others may progress at a slower rate but have more time to develop skills and techniques that are more numerous or more advanced than the first example. I was just commenting today to my wife about the differences in Del Web's video of maybe forty years ago and Bill Grumbine's videos of today. Tools and techniques are almost radically different and yet each is a great turner and teacher in his own right.

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

Keith Tompkins

>Allen, I think someone could write a book based on that one question. There are lots of variables here, but here are a few of my basic thoughts on the subject.

First, whatever grind you use, learn to duplicate it exactly each time you sharpen. Otherwise, the tool is unpredictable; never acting the same with each useage. Too many turners never get past this sticking point.

Many tools are ground at terrible angles from the factory....the bowl gouges that are ground with the edges of the flute protruding past the rest of the cutting edge are nearly useless as delivered. An Ellsworth grind with straight sides on the swept-back portion is grabby and catchy.

The grind of mine that Ron refers to has no flute, just a concave face with a steep grind angle and long, swept back wings....perfect for the way I turn. I almost never cut with the "flute" up on any of my tools, I ride the bevel with the tool on its side.

I would suggest studying some common grinds, and ensuring that your grind duplicates them before moving on to your own special grinds.

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

#12

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

George Van

>Hi Kieth, is your grind similiar to this of Ken's?


img

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

Keith Tompkins

>Hi George,Yes, very similar. My grind is swept back even further, and the long grind begins to curl inward, just like an Ellsworth grind. This makes it less grabby, since I use all of the edge. I can cut in the ususal way, and I can use it to refine the shapes of a cove. (the original purpose) I can shear scrape with the long edge without fear of catches.

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

#14

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

George Van

>Thanks Kieth, I bought some round HSS from Enco a while back. I am going to grind one and give it a try.

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

#15

Re: Thanks for the replies.

Allen Neighbors

>Everyone. Thanks for the replies. Interesting replies, they are.

I too, believe that it relates to the way we hold our mouths. :o)

It also has to do with toolrest height, edge tilt, handle roll... etc.

But I'm particularly interested in Keith's reply... about the Ellsworth Grind's straight sides being grabby. I straightened the sides on my Crown Pro PM 1/2" gouge, and I think it's a little bit grabby... seems like I get a lot more catches, but it sure does cut! Do the straight cutting edges cause the catches? If I just grind down the point a little more, curving the cutting edges on the sides, will that help?

I'm also interested in that little funny looking tool that is made from drill stock, with no flute. What's it called... a scraper?

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: Thanks for the replies.

Keith Tompkins

>Allen, look at the latest issue of the AAW magazine, there's an article on grinding with a jig....it shows a straight sided grind. That grind is grabby because even though the initial bevel angle may be correct, it will only cut right when using the very tip. Anywhere else has no support, and catches happen.

My tool will cut or scrape, and works well at hollowing boxes and goblets, since there is no flute, therefore, more mass. My top bevel does not extend as low as the tool in the photo above, my grind curves inward to meet it higher up on the tip. I'll try to get a photo....

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

#17

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

Ron in Drums PA

>While you are add it George make a 1/4" round skew with the same type of rod.

I've been using a 1/4" round skew for over a year and it compliments Keith's tool very well.

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

#18

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

George Van

>I will give it a try Ron, maybe that will be a skew I can handle!

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

#19

Re: Thanks for the replies.

Allen Neighbors

>Keith, thanks for the explanation of the straight grind. That's what's giving me problems, I think. I'll change that pattern, and see what happens.

On the little tool, a pic would be great! I don't understand how it is ground. On the pic above, all I see is a hollowground topside. Is the underside ground just like a bowl gouge?

Thanks for the information. I think this is going to help me a lot. :o)

Re: 'Nother Question... or six.... :o)

#20

Re: Thanks for the replies.

Allen Neighbors

>I changed my grind, and I must say it works like a dream!! Changed the straight into a curve, and that did it. I've changed grinds a couple of times, but kept the straight wings, and have always had trouble.

Thanks, Keith. :o)