Trying to simplify things
wilbur
>Although I haven't gotten my dust collection system set up yet, I've been spending too much time thinking about it lately. Bill Pentz' website, although very comprehensive, has an overwhelming amount of information for someone new to the subject. But here's what I've learned, summarized into (hopefully) easy to digest chunks:
1. You need to think of dust collection as a SYSTEM -- not just a bunch of components.
2. The specs on dust collection machines are optimistic, to put it mildly, at best. For a CFM measurement to be of any meaning, you also need to know what resistance that CFM is being pulled against. Most DC systems have a CFM spec and maybe a Static Pressure spec. Almost always, the CFM is against little to no pressure. The Static Pressure is the amount of pressure against which the DC can generate a minimal amount of airflow. So if a DC machine has specs of, say, 1100 CFM and 10" static pressure, that almost surely means that it will draw much less than 1100 CFM once hooked up to ducting, and that at 10" of static pressure, it's barely moving anything at all.
3. The goal of any duct collection system is to suck in and trap fine (1-5 micron) dust particles. These are the dust particles that will do damage to your health. In order to do this, you need to move a large amount of air.
4. There are basically two things that work against you when trying to move a large amount of air: resistance in front of the blower and resistance on the back side of the blower.
5. Resistance in front of the blower is primarily represented by narrow ducting, and ducting that is too long.
6. Resistance in back of the blower is primarily represented by the dust filter being clogged with dust as it does its job. the best way to prevent this from happening is to trap the dust before it gets there with a cyclone type device. Unfortunately, this will also add to the resistance in front of the filter.
7. Once you work though the math and engineering aspects, you pretty much wind up with a fixed dust collection system requiring 6" pipe, a large cyclone, and a big (>3 HP) blower to move the air. There doesn't seem to be any way around this without violating the laws of physics.
8. However, one way to get around this would be to look for ways to keep the resistance on the front side as minimal as possible. The only way I have thought of to do this is to get a mobile machine and a very short run (less than 6 feet) of flex hose, and move it from machine to machine as I use it.
9. Dust not picked up by your system at the tool escaping into the air is inevitable, due to imperfect dust hoods on machines. Even Bill Pentz has found this to be true. So consider also installing an air cleaner. I did some mathematical modeling and if you have air cleaner(s) that have a CFM rating of about half the volume of the air volume of your shop, then it will clear the air of over 99.9% of the dust in about 10 1/2 minutes, even taking some inefficiencies into account. I think that air cleaners are a bit underappreciated in the dust collection world.
10. Finally, the best thing you can do is find some way of exhausting the air outside. That is by far the quickest and easiest way of getting rid of dust. Unfortunately, I don't have that option.