Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Dust Collection

Posts

Dust Collection

#1

Dust Collection

DD

>Am looking at putting in a dust collector but am a bit overwhelmed by websites and their advice. I will almost exclusively use this collector for turning and associated sanding, but may use it occasionally for flat work. It will be used in the basement workshop. Most 1 HP dust collectors have a 4" inlet and up to 700 cfm airflow, but most seem to be in the 650 cfm range. A minority of these 1 HP systems come with 1 micron felt bags, the rest seem to be 5 micron or greater. The next size up is 1.5 HP, 1 micron filtering, and 1100 cfm +. They are slightly larger in size, have almost double the cfm, but will draw ~ 14 amps on a 110 v circuit, which means the DC will have to be on a separate circuit from the lathe (will set it up that way regardless of what size motor). Is 1100 cfm + overkill? Have read that one needs at least 700 to 750 cfm for an adequate dust collection system. Seems that a 1 HP DC is marginal. So that's where I am at - either overkill at 1.5 HP or marginal at 1 HP. Any advice out there? Would like to go to a canister system as opposed to felt, but the price grows substantially, so I'll stick with a felt bag. Any help appreciated.

Doug

Re: Dust Collection

#2

Re: Dust Collection

Russ Babbitt Jr.

>I did the same research you are doing and decided that the collection system would require a very large dust collector to be efficient. I scrapped my idea and just drag a hose where I need it.

Re: Dust Collection

#3

Re: Dust Collection

DD

>What do you use as your basic dc system? I too will likely end up simply moving a hose from device to device. thanks

Re: Dust Collection

#4

Re: Dust Collection

Mark Wollschlager

>I have chosen the Jet 650-CK ,a 1hp with canister filter, coupled with a trashcan cyclone and a 4" hose to get me to the machines.

The footprint isn't too bad and my machines are close enough that I don't need to move the unit.

The 'cyclone' ( a 30 gal metal trashcan with a veritas cyclone lid ) collects all of the big stuff and is easy to empty. The Jet canister and plastic bag collect the dust.

In my (non production) shop I empty the cyclone about every 2 weeks and the collector bag has yet to be changed after 2 years ( it has about 8 inches of stuff in the bottom).

I also use a Delta 2 stage air cleaner which also makes a lot of difference.

Re: Dust Collection

#5

Re: Dust Collection

Bill Crommett

>DD : There are a lot of variable involved; Do you have access to the out of doors ? Does the collector have to be in your working area ? have you got room to run multiple runs ?

My 2 cents worth :

I started off with a two bag grizzly that I put outside the shop in the paint locker. This would not give me the airflow I desired, so I modified the fan intake to accomodate a 6 inch PVC pipe with several branching runs up in the shop. Problem --- the air flow was so great that I could not keep the bag on the collar. My paint locker is a mess with all the dust and shavings . So, at the suggestion of one of our own, I ran the exaust directly to the outside where the shavings are used to mulch the bushes.

My next project is to find a rubber collar for the PVC to dampen the noise which telegraphs quite efficiently from the DC to the shop.

Questions ???

Re: Dust Collection

#6

Re: Dust Collection *LINK*

Bob Fawcett

>My 2 cents.

Buy the 1.5 hp model from Harbor freight.

Get a canister filter from these guys.

http://www.wynnenv.com/9e300bl_conversion.htm

Remove the Y adapter that comes on the unit and replace it with 5" hose. You can get the hose from the same website above.


Cartridge conversion

Re: Dust Collection

#7

Re: Dust Collection

john lucas

>I bought a Jet with 1100 cfm. I don't think that's overkill at all for a lathe. I would look at the new Steel City dust collector. It comes with a 1 micron bag. That could save you some money if you plan to upgrade to that anyway. They are having a sale right now but I didn't look to see if that is one of the items on sale. They advertise with WC so you shouldn't have any trouble finding them.

Re: Dust Collection

#8

Richard Allen

Re: Dust Collection

Richard Allen

>The CFM ratings are NOT real world. That rating is without the 4" hose and likely without bags. The 700 to 750 is also bogus when talking about a lathe. A good dust hood will make a huge difference in how well the DC keep dust out of your lungs. I had one of those 1 HP DCs with felt bags and a good dust hood on a 24" swing lathe. I eventually changed to a 3HP cyclone. The difference in doing the desired job is night and day. A good dust hood on a 15" swing lathe and 1 1/5 hp DC would be VERY effective (a 6" hose would be about twice as effective as a 4" hose.

If protecting your lungs is your primary concern then a good dust mask is much more effective and cheaper.

Re: Dust Collection

#9

Re: Dust Collection

David Breth

>My shop has very limited space, and very limited ceiling, and is located in the basement. Cyclones were out of the picture for me because of the height required. After a seemingly endless amount of research and talking myself in and out of collectors, I purchased the Grizzly G0548. At present, I have it hooked up to only one line, which runs under the floor joists and terminates at the lathe (a hood-shaped opening that is fastened to a vertical 2x4 that is attached to a small dolly, so I've got the ability to move it around to suit the work). All flex hose.

Some day, I'll run multiple lines, eliminate some of the flex hose, etc., etc., but for now, the set up is sufficient.

The G0548 has done very well in my book. It fit the space I had, and I think provides pretty good bang for the buck. I've been quite happy with it. The competing units of that cannister style were one by JDL and I think Jet and Delta. Reviews I saw pointed me off the delta and I think the Jet as well if I recall. Memory tells me that JDL didn't have quite as fine a bag as Grizzly claimed. I'm going by company claims of course with respect to the filtering, etc., but I have found it to be a very nice unit.

David B.

Re: Dust Collection

#10

Re: Dust Collection

DD

>Won't run it outside because I can't afford to let that much heated air to be drawn from the house, so it will have to exhaust inside. Everything I had read in the thread is pointing at the 1 1/2 HP unit. Have come across two quite suitable units with 1 Micron bags - the Steel City 65200 and the Delta 50-760. Thanks for the feedback.

Doug

Re: Dust Collection

#11

Re: Dust Collection

DD

>I wear a dust mask usually when turning and always when sanding. However, the amount of fine dust that makes its way through the basement and into the rest of the house demands some action to collect it at source. I'm hoping a DC is the answer to this. Thanks for the feedback.

Doug

Re: Dust Collection

#12

Re: Dust Collection

DD

>Saw the Steel City DC today at a wood show. Very nice machine. Was also surprised at how quiet it was. On your Jet, what size line are you running from your lathe to the DC - 4", 5", or 6"? If 5" or 6", do you have any trouble keeping the bags secured to the DC? Thanks.

Doug

Re: Dust Collection

#13

Re: Dust Collection

Barry Irby

>Bill, I went to a tire shop and they gave me a puntured inner tube. I cut about five inches out of it and used two pipe clamps to attach the pipe to the DC. Works great.

Re: Dust Collection

#14

Richard Allen

Re: Dust Collection

Richard Allen

>The air cleaners do great for that purpose. The air cleaner doesn't work well at keeping your lungs clean. But those air cleaners work GREAT at containing the fine dust to the shop.

Re: Dust Collection

#15

Re: Dust Collection

Barry Irby

>Doug, My shop is in the basement in what used to be a garage. I find that fine duct floats from the shop up into the house especially when the shop is heated. (A little portable heater, not part of the heat pump system for the house) I put my DC (a 1 1/2hp Delta unit) out side in an exterior Closet I built for it. I run it when a machine is running and when I am sanding. Yes, I lose some heat, but I find that it creates slight negative pressure on the shop space and negates the tendency for the dust to float up into the house. Very worth while. I have a small dog door in the door to the shop and the DC sucks it open, so most of the "makeup" air is coming in the the dog door. The heat you lose is in the air in the shop. most of the heat is stored in the solid stuff like tools, so it only takes a few minutes for the shop to warm back up after the DC goes off.

I find that the bag on my unit cake up quickly when sanding and the air flow (effectiveness) drops off quickly. I have the habit of watching the dog door and when it is not open as wide as usual, I go out to the closet and give the bag a good shake. I really like have the DC outside, because this shaking is a dusty job and the dust stays out there. Also changing the bag is messy too.

I really want a dust disposer, not collector. The dust is the part I don't want. Why am I collecting it? If I lived on a larger lot, I would just shoot it out into the woods.

I added a trash can separator to my system to avoid emptying the bag so often (A PITA for me due to a design flaw in the exterior closet) and its great with a lathe (huge amount of shavings), but its in the shop. My shop is small and the trash can takes up valuable space. In hind site, I should have made the closet bigger and put the separator out there. Maybe time for a redesign.

Re: Dust Collection

#16

Re: Dust Collection

DD

>Barry,

Thanks for the response. My house is fairly tightly sealed, so if I exhausted the DC outside, I would be drawing in cold air, either through the cold air source for the furnace or through leaks in the house. I was hoping with a decent dust collector hood and DC that most of the fine dust would be eliminated in the basement. I would like to get an air cleaner as well, but the budget can't support both. I don't think I can get away with only one of them, but if I can eliminate the majority of the dust with a DC, I'll prioritize on that. Thanks for the feedback.

Doug

Re: Dust Collection

#17

Trying to simplify things

wilbur

>Although I haven't gotten my dust collection system set up yet, I've been spending too much time thinking about it lately. Bill Pentz' website, although very comprehensive, has an overwhelming amount of information for someone new to the subject. But here's what I've learned, summarized into (hopefully) easy to digest chunks:

1. You need to think of dust collection as a SYSTEM -- not just a bunch of components.

2. The specs on dust collection machines are optimistic, to put it mildly, at best. For a CFM measurement to be of any meaning, you also need to know what resistance that CFM is being pulled against. Most DC systems have a CFM spec and maybe a Static Pressure spec. Almost always, the CFM is against little to no pressure. The Static Pressure is the amount of pressure against which the DC can generate a minimal amount of airflow. So if a DC machine has specs of, say, 1100 CFM and 10" static pressure, that almost surely means that it will draw much less than 1100 CFM once hooked up to ducting, and that at 10" of static pressure, it's barely moving anything at all.

3. The goal of any duct collection system is to suck in and trap fine (1-5 micron) dust particles. These are the dust particles that will do damage to your health. In order to do this, you need to move a large amount of air.

4. There are basically two things that work against you when trying to move a large amount of air: resistance in front of the blower and resistance on the back side of the blower.

5. Resistance in front of the blower is primarily represented by narrow ducting, and ducting that is too long.

6. Resistance in back of the blower is primarily represented by the dust filter being clogged with dust as it does its job. the best way to prevent this from happening is to trap the dust before it gets there with a cyclone type device. Unfortunately, this will also add to the resistance in front of the filter.

7. Once you work though the math and engineering aspects, you pretty much wind up with a fixed dust collection system requiring 6" pipe, a large cyclone, and a big (>3 HP) blower to move the air. There doesn't seem to be any way around this without violating the laws of physics.

8. However, one way to get around this would be to look for ways to keep the resistance on the front side as minimal as possible. The only way I have thought of to do this is to get a mobile machine and a very short run (less than 6 feet) of flex hose, and move it from machine to machine as I use it.

9. Dust not picked up by your system at the tool escaping into the air is inevitable, due to imperfect dust hoods on machines. Even Bill Pentz has found this to be true. So consider also installing an air cleaner. I did some mathematical modeling and if you have air cleaner(s) that have a CFM rating of about half the volume of the air volume of your shop, then it will clear the air of over 99.9% of the dust in about 10 1/2 minutes, even taking some inefficiencies into account. I think that air cleaners are a bit underappreciated in the dust collection world.

10. Finally, the best thing you can do is find some way of exhausting the air outside. That is by far the quickest and easiest way of getting rid of dust. Unfortunately, I don't have that option.

Re: Dust Collection

#18

Re: Trying to simplify things

Jeff

>I have the penn state 1.5 hp and it came with a 1 micron bag. It has a y for 2 4's that I took off and ran a main line 6 and then 4's to my machines. The branch to the lathe is great for sanding it get's most of the sanding dust which is great. The chips from sanding go all over some to the collector but most to the floor. I have don't know how you could get the chips to be picked up. I have plenty of suction but the are large and go all over the place.

Re: Dust Collection

#19

Re: Trying to simplify things

albertabob

>After a series of "Rube Goldberg" solutions and a plethora of well intended advice from arm chair turners I resorted to this tray that I clean out at the end of the process into a garbage can.

The ox forms a V under the ways and seems to collect about 97% of the chaff leaving a few crumbs for the broom.

As for the fine dust from sanding, I wear a Trend helmet and use the shop vac when I'm done.

The tray is made from Coroplast plastic and available in 4 x 8 sheets at most hardware/lumber Borgs.

Bob


img

Re: Dust Collection

#20

Re: Trying to simplify things

DD

>Wilber,

Thanks for the feedback. I am exactly of the same ilk as you. Lots of good information, but a bit difficult to sort through. I cannot exhaust outside, but will end up buying a 1100- 1200 cfm dust collector that I can move around if required. Will eventually end up with a canister filter in lieu of a felt bag to reduce the pressure losses, and an air cleaner as well. This will all take time and money (especially the latter), but I will start with the DC system. As stated elsewhere in this thread, will go for a Delta 50-760 or Steel City 65200. The latter has a good warranty (five years), but the former seems a little more versatile in its set-up. Price differences are negligle here in Ottawa, from what I have seen (only one dealer who sells both product lines).

Doug