Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

VB36 or Stubby Help!

Posts

VB36 or Stubby Help!

#1

VB36 or Stubby Help!

Brian McInturff in SC

>Boy I've got a delima. I put a deposit on a Stubby. They are in country and I was writing the check for the rest of the payment when I see where there is a VB36 with the long extension, free standing tool rest, and a bunch of other accessories including complete vacuum setup for less than what the Stubby would cost. The VB is only 4 years old and is about 3 hours away. What to do what to do. I turn mainly bowls and don't turn spindles. I like turning small stuff also but am keeping my Oneway 1018 for now anyway. But I really like the Stubby also. My shop is small and is in a 12x16 area.

Both would work in the small space. Any advice?

Re: VB36 or Stubby Help!

#2

Re: VB36 or Stubby Help!

Bob Fawcett

>I've never seen a Stubby.

The VB is a tank. It also has a very small footprint. It uses plain bearings which are capable of far more load than any ball bearings. I don't think you could wear it out in 104 years.

Re: VB36 or Stubby Help!

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: VB36 or Stubby Help!

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Brian, If you are serious about the VB, arrange to check it out immediately! I would not consider purchasing a used machine without examining it first...bring another experienced turner with you! You don't want to miss a good opportunity..... You also don't want to buy an abused piece of equipment.

Then, consider what your real needs are....that will help with the decision. Do you need a VB36? Will the stubby do what you want it to do?

Consider what accessories will adapt to either machine....that may be an important consideration.

Re: VB36 or Stubby Help!

#4

Back to the Future

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Brian,

Either machine will serve you very well if you stay with bowls. The VB is, primarily, a bowl lathe. While it will mount a tailstock for spindle work or SAFETY bowl work to PREVENT dismounts, adding on that pier and huge tubeset will pretty much wipe out your small shop area. You've also got to consider where you'll store the extra parts when not in use.

If, however, you decide to get into hollowforms (a/k/a Jars), I'm sure you'll find the Stubby clearly superior. Not that you can't do a tailstock mounting on the VB, you certainly can. But hollowing systems are going to be limited to you and your tool as there's no bed there for mounting and registration, and the change-over will be ponderous.

The Stubby 750, on the other hand, will turn your 29" bowl or platter just as well as the VB, but with a quick flip of the bed-lock, will also take a hollowform blank big enough for you to need some meaningful mechanical assistance to mount it.

I've had my Stubby 1000 for over 3 years now. I've also tried a VB which I view as more of a production lathe for bowls than anything else. It's a very smooth machine, but I wouldn't trade, even if there was money in the deal for me.

If bowls and only bowls are your thing, now and Forever, the VB's your Baby (provided you're not buying somebody's cripple). But if flexibility and multi-tasking is in your mind's eye, the Stubby's unmatched for its combination of features and space-saving configuration.

Good Luck, hope this helped.

Re: VB36 or Stubby Help!

#5

Re: Back to the Future

Brian McInturff in SC

>Thanks Mark,

I'm leaning more to the stubby the more I think about it. I already paid my deposit for it and will overnight the other check to Bill Monday, most likely. I think I got caught up in the "deal" on the VB. HF's will be a big part of what I turn. And I need to consider the fact that when I looked at the VB I didn't like the idea of having to stand on a platform. And like mentioned previously how easy is it to get tooling for it or does it require mainly items from VB. But it is a good deal on the VB. I guess if I already owned the Stubby and had room for the VB I would jump on it as an addition.

I think I'm talking myself out of the VB as I speak....

Re: VB36 or Stubby Help!

#6

Re: Being Tempted

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>There's no question it's a fine machine, and a great deal would be hard to pass up as you don't see them for sale very often. The few that I've heard about sold for near their original price. That little fact had me cautious when you mentioned a steep discount. Somebody "giving it away" means either they don't know what they have or you don't know what you're buying or who you're buying it from. Since there aren't that many VB's around, you could probably track down it's history with Hegner(sp?) in the UK once you get the number.

If you want a better idea, browse the UK site to get a sense of how it sets up.

Re: VB36 or Stubby Help!

#7

Re: Back to the Future

Russ Fairfield

>Good advice from all. You are trying to compare two different lathes that were designed for different purposes. The VB-36 is a "Bowl Lathe" that can be adapted to turning other things. The Stubby is a multi-purpose lathe that can be configured to turn almost anything from spindles to bowls.

Here are the differences you should be looking at to determine which is the better lathe. I am assuming that you are relatively new to woodturning, and don't have any idea which path (or paths) you will ultimately follow when given the freedom to explore them all. The Stubby will give you the freedom to explore every type of woodturning without any restrictions, and less expensively and more easily than with the VB.

There is a high price for being different. Should you chose the VB, be prepared to spend a lot of money on attachments, or doing without them, because none of those neat things in the catalogs will fit. They all depend on having a lathe bed under them to clamp to. You will never be able to use the Oneway coring system, or one of the captured boring bars, and good luck on making a full steady rest or a bowl steady.

Without measuring the floor and working space required, it seems to me that the Stubby will occupy less shop space than the VB with the tailstock attached, and they will both have the same capacity for turning large bowls. Don't plan on the VB tailstock being easily removed to save floor space. You will need a place to store it and a crane to handle it because it weighs almost 400 pounds.

It the same as buying a car. You makes your choice and never look back.

Re: VB36 or Stubby Help!

#8

Re: Back to the Future

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>The VB uses the McNaughton coring and laser hollowing systems.

Best, Ted

Re: VB36 or Stubby Help!

#9

Re: VB36 or Stubby Help!

Michael Sinclair in Orkney

>I have had the VB for almost 2 years and it was a toss up between the VB and the Stubby.The VB is a cool machine but I think it is mostly a bowl lathe. It will take a little bit of time to get used to but after that it is no problem.

Now the crunch I am saving up for a Stubby as my second lathe.

I have a small workshop 12 x 30 feet but I will fit both in given the chance.

Given my research you will not be disappointed with either machine.

As they say only my 2 cents but I lust after both.If your first hunch was for the Stubby go for it and get the VB later.

Good luck

Michael

Re: VB36 or Stubby Help!

#10

Re: VB36 or Stubby Help!

MikeB

>Brian

May be too late to be of help but I own a VB36 and may be near enough to you for you to come and play with it. Don't know where you are in SC. I am in Fayetteville NC and bought mine used two years ago. Admittedly, it is not my only lathe, I also have a general vs20. I don't have the tailstock and I have the two lathes close enough to use the bed of the general to support long hollowing efforts. Unless the current owner has not maintained the oil levels or not ever greased the machine I don't know how to abuse it without running into it with a fork lift.

Re: VB36 or Stubby Help!

#11

Re: VB36 or Stubby Help!

Brian McInturff

>Thanks Mike. Actually I'm going to look at it tomorrow. After talking with Greg and Terry and seeing some of the items turned and since this lathe is suppose to have all the attachments that VB sells plus several chuucks and adapters I decided I might change my mind and go with it. I'm really excited either way. I figure I will have my large lathe before Christmas no matter which one of the 2 I pic.

I may take you up on dropping by since we occasionally go to Fayettville. My wife lived there pretty much her whole life. I'll drop you an email later tomorrow when I get back from looking at it.

Re: VB36 or Stubby Help!

#12

Re: VB36 or Stubby Help!

Brian McInturff in SC

>So I decided to go look at it after all. Went this past Tuesday and here is what I found wrong:

The front oil reservoir was dry and had old dried oiland sawdust caked in it. There was what looked like a wick in it and when I pulled it out it was dry. The manual had a date of 1996 and I think this was one of the first ones because it didn't have the "bayonet" typeconnector on the mandrel where you attach the chucks and faceplates. Also the toolrest area is different, it's a piece bolted on and then the toolrest fits and locks into it. You use the same piece with the free standing tool rest. No height adjusting bar in either one. He only had one original faceplate(8") and 2 tool rest the small one and what probably was a 12". I'm really skeptical of the mandrel shaft and the bearing probably being ran dry and hot. They think that the heat may have been the reason the VFD went out. Said he tried turning when it was 115 degrees in the non climate controlled shop

I decided to pass on the deal. It very well may be a great deal with some of the other extras thrown in like a Seneco air compressor(small) and a vacuum pump, plus a bunch of mandrel adapters, small aluminum faceplates, and a couple of rather old Oneway chucks. I just didn't want to take the chance. The vfd had just been replaced and then finding it without oil made me feel as though it really hadn't been taken care of. Well, to my level of maintaining. If anyone else is interested I can put you in contact with the owner. Actually it belonged to his dad who passed away about 1 1/2 years ago. If nothing else is wrong with it then it's probably a great deal. I just didn't want to take the chance and I should be recieving my Stubby this week. The Stubby was my first decision by the way but mainly because I didn't have the money for a VB. I don't think I'll regret the Stubby and I don't think I would regret a VB as it's obvious they are both great lathes. Email me if interested in looking at the VB which is located close to Columbia, SC