Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

this doesn't look like silky oak to me... [bark]

Posts

this doesn't look like silky oak to me... [bark]

#1

this doesn't look like silky oak to me... [bark]

GaryG in MD

>...but what do I know. I suspect I may have been told incorrectly.

[Ed, make sure you get your 2c in -- I can bring it in Jan if nec.]

OK, I know, here we go again w/ tree ID.

I'm going to post two pix, and you tell me:

1) is this any of the many species called silky oak or she-oak?

2) if not, what is it? TIA, Gary


img

Re: this doesn't look like silky oak to me... [bark]

#2

[freshly cut end]

GaryG in MD

>Whatever it is, it's from Palm Springs, CA -- probably in a neighborhood.


img

Re: this doesn't look like silky oak to me... [bark]

#3

Re: [freshly cut end]

Sean Troy

>Looks like Acacia

Re: this doesn't look like silky oak to me... [bark]

#4

Paul Porter

What Sean said

Paul Porter

>It looks like the acaia we have here in Phoenix.

Re: this doesn't look like silky oak to me... [bark]

#5

Paul Porter

That would be Acacia not Acaia, duh!

Paul Porter

>

Re: this doesn't look like silky oak to me... [bark]

#6

Thanks Sean and Paul

GaryG in MD

>For now, I'll call it "acacia". I tried to Google it and found that there are literally hundreds of species, and they look very different from each other. Do you have any idea what the botannical name is of the "acacia" you are talking about in the US SW? Thanks for your ID. ...Gary

Re: this doesn't look like silky oak to me... [bark]

#7

Re: What Sean said

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>It may also be sumac. RHUS lancia

The two most common here are ACACIA saligna and ACACIA salicna.

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ. Just down the street from Phoenix

Re: this doesn't look like silky oak to me... [bark]

#8

thanks Bill

GaryG in MD

>

Re: this doesn't look like silky oak to me... [bark]

#9

Re: this doesn't look like silky oak to me... [bar

Ed Karch

>Bring a slice in Jan and I will scope it for you. If it is Grevillea a radial cut would show the tell tale ray pattern.

Re: this doesn't look like silky oak to me... [bark]

#10

Re: this doesn't look like silky oak to me... [bar

GaryG in MD

>I'll bring it in -- I'm guessing some form of acacia. ...Gary

Re: this doesn't look like silky oak to me... [bark]

#11

Brad Vietje

'Nuther clue ?

Brad Vietje

>I'm pretty darned far from both Phoenix and Palm Springs, so I know zip about your local woods, but there's a world of difference in the physical properties of Acacia and Sumac. Acacia species are MUCH harder and heavier. If you can stick a thumbnail or a toothpick into the endgrain, that's a lot more like Sumac than Acacia.

Whatever wood you have, there's another clue in the photo -- the end grain is cut very cleanly, but the inner bark is very fuzzy. If that was Sumac, the clean-cut end grain would suggest a very sharp chainsaw blade, since Sumacs don't cut real well, and that stringy bark would have to be a tell-tale character trait. If you have a very hard and dense wood, all the photo tells you is that the bark has a stringy inner layer that doesn't cut well, like some Elms, which could still be diagnostic.

Good luck,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT