We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Since you asked about turning a goblet from green wood I decided to see if I could do it successfully from a green limb. The goblet is 1 3/4" wide and 6" tall. Turned from a green vine maple limb. Rough turned on November 20th. Finished turned November 27th. You can get full details on the alcohol soaking blog.
>I posted the info about the goblet and yew box on 4 forums. However, the overwhelming number of visits to the Alcohol soaking blog are from Wood Central. Perhaps people here know me better. I suspect that more people visit Wood Central and those that visit other forums visit Wood Central first.
Dave Smith
Rain is above freezing this morning in Longview, WA.
>Dave Don't get me wrong on this I find the work your doing with the Alcohol most interesting and maybe someday I'll need it. It could be that others who have been turning for awhile feel the same way I do. For the most part I simply don't want to mess with the trouble of storing alchol or boiling bowls or any of the other "fast" methods. I simply rough turn them, put them on the shelf and someday (usually around christmas) I get back to them. If you do this on a regular basis you have a shelf full of stock to turn.
For goblets out of green wood if you choose the species you can easily turn them and just let them dry as long as the pith isn't in the stem. I find holly and dogwood great for this. They do warp but that's part of the fun.
For boxes I will rough turn them and microwave them (I can do that while making dinner) Then finish turn them. Mostly my boxes are dry wood so I simply don't have to worry about the wood movement that much.
I might give it a try for boxes because that doesn't take a huge amount of alcohol. It's only been about 4 days since the final turning. Does the lid still fit properly?
You have mentioned several things that could be substance for lengthy discussions on the relative merits of using alcohol for drying turned pieces. Keep in mind that I have boiled, microwaved, soap soaked, bagged and used several other ways to dry turning pieces. I have selected one that repeatedly yields the most predictable results with the least amount of effort. The process I have developed will not appeal to every turner. Nor will it be the best method for all situations or materials.
My experience has been that using the alcohol drying protocol reduces the degradation of pieces during the drying process. Quicker drying is not the only reason for using the process.
The box has not distorted and still fits well. The goblet is still straight but I would not be surprised if the stem did bend. I was asked if the method could be used on green goblets and boxes. I reported my results so people can see how I went about doing it. Using limbs is probably the worst case scenario since I have read a lot of posts that said to get rid of the pith because it will always crack.
There a many people who refer to alcohol soaking as alchemy. There are others who flatly say it doesn't work. One person says that air is the only thing that is replaced by alcohol. All this even though alcohol is routinely used to displace water in many applications from manufacturing to histology.
>Dave I certainly find it interesting just haven't tried it yet. I guess there just aren't enough people out there yet who have tried it to give it reputation so that the larger group of turners will start using it. We certainly appreciate your work on this subject.
The other thing is that people often think that all of these various methods are cure all's for difficult wood or improper technique. They try it and only have partial success so they rule it out.
I have some holly and a curly cherry limb that would be interesting to try it on. These may not be the best woods for that but I've got to go to the store tomorrow anyway. I'll pick up some DNA and give it a try.
I first saw the posts on WR. Didn't realize that there was a connection to the alchy blogs until I got here. I haven't tried alcohol curing yet bu I probably will eventually. When I do your postings will be some of the first I use. Thanks.
Just a note of support for your findings on alcohol. I have been using this method for a couple of years and find it to be useful and practical. It's not a big hassle--a cardboard box, garbage bag liners, some shavings, and a gallon or two of DNA. However, most of the time I just rough out and let 'em dry. It is just those times when I have an idea and want to see it to completion before next year...
>If I get things together so I can turn regularly you can bet I would use it. If I did the the traditional way I mught not be here by the time the blank is ready to turn.(G)
>back and forth between the alcohol and the soap, for over a year now. I have two large plastic tubs that I have the soap mixture in, simply because I usually have several bowls in it at once, and they take up a lot of room. I also have a large tupperware Cake plate with cover that I've inverted, and fill with alcohol (DNA). I use them both. I leave bowls in the soap a lot longer than in the DNA. The DNA has worked for me on quite a few bowls, that I think would have cracked without it.
My experiments with the soap mixture included recording time in and out only, (not caring about the weight or how fast they dry), since I am only interested in keeping them from cracking... and I have found that the soap solution works absolutely GREAT with Apricot wood. I've rough turned green, fresh cut, Apricot, and put it in the soap for 20-30 days, and turn it the day after taking it out of the solution... it's still wet... and finish size it. No cracking at all... on none of them. If I turn it wet without the soap soak, it cracks... invariably. (Soap works so well on Apricot, that I haven't tried the Alcohol with that wood.)
I believe the Alcohol does keep the wood from degrading during drying, but I'm not interested in how fast they dry... I just hate cracking.
I appreciate all the work, time and research that has resulted in a menu of alternative handling methods for green wood. David Smith, Steven D. Russell, Leif Thorvaldson and others have gone the extra mile and done the hard work for us -- to the benefit of turners all over the world. And while we're at it, lets not forget Del Stubbs, who did a lot of very thin green turning and inspired thousands of turners with a single finger flexing a thin Apple bowl on a video tape shot over 20 years ago !
I have used the Alcohol method (a.k.a. DNA) for green turnings that tend to warp a lot, and generally have a higher failure rate, such as Apple, Pear and Beech -- seemes to work very well. I'm not convinced that it reduces the shrinkage and warping dramatically, but it does help get a piece ready to finish in a much shorter timeframe. I'm sure Madrone, a.k.a. Arbutus is another species that belongs on the list of big movers and shakers, but I have only made 2 items from it.
I also experimented on a few dozen pieces with liquid dish detergent (a.k.a. LDD), which helped avoid cracking, aided in sanding, was good for my skin and nails (...sure -- you're soaking in it ...) and smelled great.
I have also used boiling (a.k.a. boiling -- he-he ) on some pieces that were really curly, such as curly tiger Maple, or a piece of cigar curl Eucalyptus I bought, and that has also worked well at eliminating cracks in difficult woods, though they still do warp.
I've also dried plenty of bowls in the microwave for saving time, intentional warping with texture, or getting the wood to dry w/out excessive checking. Worked like a charm just last night.
When I have a special challange, I usually roll out one or more of these special methods. Usually I'm working on things without a real specific timetable, so like John, I feed green-turned items into "the pipe", and a few months later, warped, air-dry turnings come out the other end for finish turning. When I have the time, I can rough-turn a lot of stock, so there are a LOT of part-turned items on hand all the time for the occasional need-it-tonight item. For items turned green to completion, I've also used DNA or the microwave to dry them faster.
My take on all these methods is about the same -- they each work well to help solve a particular problem, but none is good enough to offset millions of years of evolution and the demands of mother nature: wood WILL shrink when it dries. These methods are great at avoiding cracks, or at speeding up the process, or at making nearly impossible wood easier to work. I think some people have gotten the very much mistaken idea that there's a way to finish turn an object from a piece of green wood in time for tonight's birthday party with no cracking and no warping in a single turning -- if a technique or combination of techniques exists to do this, I want to know more.
My personal view is that as a woodturner I have to take the time to get to know the materials and methods of my craft -- including getting to know the properties of wood itself -- and when I respect the demands of the wood, good results can be achived consistantly. Beginners wanting instant results often learn this through frustration or failure, having impossible expectations at the outset. Once they get their expectations in line with the laws of nature, they're on their way to happy results and satisfaction.
My hat's off to all those who have helped us push the envelope and pioneered new ways to get the results we need.