Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

More than a swan neck

Posts

More than a swan neck

#1

More than a swan neck

eliot d

>Suppose I want a hollowing tool that will get WAY over ( to the left when turning in the normal manner). Am I going to have to make it? Are there any commercial tools that will reach way over there? I'm talking about hollowing through a 1 3/8 diameter hole into a more or less flat "river stone" -shaped 12 inch diameter vessel. Has anyone tried something like this?

Re: More than a swan neck

#2

Re: More than a swan neck

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I understand the Don Pencil Scorpion will do this.

Re: More than a swan neck

#3

Re: More than a swan neck

Carole Valentine

>You might be able to do it with an articulated hollower like the Rolly Monro but I am not sure. I don't think the Scorpion would make it, but I have not tried it.

Re: More than a swan neck

#4

Steven Antonucci

I have

steve antonucci

>It's an L-Shaped bar that I use to cut the underside of the top of the riverstone shape and the far outer profile. I use a vise grip to hold the shank and arrest the torque. I made it myself with a bench vise and a lot of hammering and pulling.

It's not fancy, but it works.

Steve

Re: More than a swan neck

#5

Re: More than a swan neck

OB O'Brien

>There is an adjustable, articulated, captured hollowing rig that Binh Pho uses. I think it's made by a gentleman named Hugh McKay. He only made a few of them and had them patented. Sometimes you can find one from an estate sale, but they are pricey, about $1500.00 or more. They are stuck into the opening hole as far as you want to hollow to the left, loosened, rotated 90 degrees, gravity allowed to turn the shaft and then retightened, or something like that. You might be able to find out more with a google search or by contacting Binh Pho. Good luck. OB

Re: More than a swan neck

#6

Re: More than a swan neck

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Eliot, some guys local to me do this on a regular basis. All you need is a longer tool bit in the holder you already have (assuming you have one). It is going to increase the torque substantially, but it can be done. You just have to be patient with your cuts.

Bill

Re: More than a swan neck

#7

Can you post a photo Steve?

John Lucas

>

Re: More than a swan neck

#8

Hugh McKay articulated hollower

John Lucas

>There was a very good photo and description of this hollower in American Woodturner, many years back. I may be able to find it. I've always thought I would build one some day using an old rifle barrel. Now that I have a metal lathe I may do it before very long.

It was designed to let you turn through a long neck but Binh Pho uses it to make the flat top vessels he's famous for.

Re: More than a swan neck

#9

Re: More than a swan neck

Pascal Oudet

>The Munro is my tool of choice for hollowing, but that's exactly the case where it can't go (it doesn't work for "flying saucer").

for a shape as you describe, the swan neck Woodcut Proforme would probably work (this is the one I take when I can't make it with the Munro).

otherwise I've also made a tool with a 14mm rod, bent (with heat)into a swan neck, and taped (M8) at the end to accept the Munro head.

Pascal

Re: More than a swan neck

#10

Re: More than a swan neck

Mac

>Its not a big job to make a special tool to reach any depth you need.You can heat and bend cold rolled to any shape you need. Insert a cutter into a hole and glue or set screw it at the tip of the tool.You can make the tool to fit any type handle you want such as a Sorby or Jamison type.The tool only needs to be shaped like a "P" with the top left 1/3 cut out.It can be made as deep as necessary,as the cutter will always be in line with the handle. Only thing you need to remember is to put it in the opening before you start the lathe as inserting it with lathe running can be something you would rather not remember.Likewise...let the lathe stop before removing it.Not as scary as it sounds,and it will do the job,in fact several sizes can be made for future jobs. A set of progressively deeper ones will make the job easier...

Re: More than a swan neck

#11

Hummmm.

Jorge Castaneda

>Me thinks I'll be making one or a few soon, when the winter storms are raging and the sensible thing is to stay home.

Thanks for the idea Mac!

Jorge

Re: More than a swan neck

#12

Re: Hummmm.

John Lucas

>I think one shaped like John Jordans shallow curve but with the bit mounted at about 30 degrees instead of straight out the point. I'm going to make a cardboard mock up of the bowl and try different shapes then I'll dig the forge out and go to work. I haven't fired it up since I moved so it's time to freak out the neighbors. I need to make whatever works in 3/4" as well as 1/2" shaft.

Re: More than a swan neck

#13

Re: Hummmm.

Jorge Castaneda

>More uhmmm,

that sounds good too and maybe easier to make as well.

Thanks for the idea John.

Jorge

By al means freak out the neighborhood...: )

Re: More than a swan neck

#14

Re: More than a swan neck

eliot d

>Mac, of the various suggestions I think your 'P' -shape idea seems best to me. I don't know how to weld , though. Maybe it's time for me to learn

.

Thanks to all who made suggestions.

Re: More than a swan neck

#15

Steven Antonucci

Sure thing

steve antonucci

>Here's the one I use for undercutting the top of the vessel. If you look closely, you'll see the teethmarks from the visegrip. It cuts from the right to left until you get "deep", then I pull it to avoid punching through the side while pushing.


img

Re: More than a swan neck

#16

Steven Antonucci

Clean up hollower

steve antonucci

>This is a swan neck version to attempt to help with torque. kind of works, but not perfect. I didn't have a torch when I bent this, so it was wailed on with a hammer into this shape. Quite a workout.

The cutter is a teardrop scraper that gets screwed in to the end to clean up the little ridges from the other cutter. The tool is laying upside down in the picture.

Steve


img

Re: More than a swan neck

#17

Re: More than a swan neck

Mac

>You can bend 1/2 or 5/8 cold rolled steel with just a Mapp torch,regular propane head,mapp gas tank. Bernz-o-matic will work.Clamp the rod in a heavy vise,heat it up and chase the bend with the gas torch. Wont take more than 10 minutes to make each shape...have fun....

Re: More than a swan neck

#18

Re: More than a swan neck

eliot d

>Oh, but I thought you said a 'P'-shape with the left upper third cut out. I took that to mean that you had to weld the vertical part of the 'P' (the lower two thirds) onto the curved part of the 'P' so that the vertical part would also sit on the rest to control the torque.

Re: More than a swan neck

#19

Re: More than a swan neck

Mac

>You could do that if you have the equipment, but I have had good success with just bending the rod with a gas torch.Look at it as sort of a compressed ? mark.The bend doesnt have to be a tight 90 degrees to work,but the tighter the better.Welding would be better and cleaner but heat bending will work also....good luck with it.