Collar Opinion
Sean Troy
>In your opinion, what would look better, a Holly HF with an Ebony collar or Cocobolo collar? For some reason on this piece, I can't seem to make up my mind.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Collar Opinion
Sean Troy
>In your opinion, what would look better, a Holly HF with an Ebony collar or Cocobolo collar? For some reason on this piece, I can't seem to make up my mind.
Re: Collar Opinion
Ron in Drums PA
>I think it is a mater of personal preference.
Do you have pictures you can share?
Re: Collar Opinion
bob davis
>EBONY
My 2 cents: ebony
Molly Winton
>
Re: Collar Opinion
Sean Troy
>No pics yet. I will when it's done. I have other turnings I need to take pics of also. I'll need to bleach the wood also. Good post above.
Re: Collar Opinion
John Lucas
>Wow I like both woods but they definitely have a different character. If the holly is pure white without the gray or blue streaks I would like either wood. If it has some of the color I think the Cocobolo would contrast with the other lines. You could always dye the cocobolo darker so it looked black but still had some lines.
I just added a finial to a piece. I used holly but dyed it black to look sort of like ebony. It was too stark when I sprayed it to a gloss finish so I knocked it back down with steel wool and then raised the gloss a little with wax. I'll photograph it today and hopefully post it tonight.
Re: Collar Opinion
Ron in Drums PA
>Why not try making a collar from both woods and see which you like best?
You could even post pictures of both on WC to get opinions if you like.
Ebony
Mike Cunningham (Cape May NJ)
>That stark contrast is great. I make forms of holly and use ebony and also padauk and redheart.
Ebony
Carole Valentine
>
Re: Collar Opinion
Barry Turner
>Without seeing the piece, I vote for ebony. I like the look, plus you probably won't get a rash from turning it like you may with Cocobolo.
Actually, Blackwood if you have it.
Carole Valentine
>The African Blackwood I have used with holly has been absolutely, perfectly black. A wonderful contrast to very white holly.
Re: Collar Opinion
Keith Tompkins
>HI Sean, something to consider....a piece of black veneer at the base of any color collar will create a break between the collar and the form....for example, the cocobolo collar with an layer of ebony veneer under it would be rich.
Re: Collar Opinion
Sean Troy
>I like that idea.