Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Collar Opinion

Posts

Collar Opinion

#1

Collar Opinion

Sean Troy

>In your opinion, what would look better, a Holly HF with an Ebony collar or Cocobolo collar? For some reason on this piece, I can't seem to make up my mind.

Re: Collar Opinion

#2

Re: Collar Opinion

Ron in Drums PA

>I think it is a mater of personal preference.

Do you have pictures you can share?

Re: Collar Opinion

#3

Re: Collar Opinion

bob davis

>EBONY

Re: Collar Opinion

#4

My 2 cents: ebony

Molly Winton

>

Re: Collar Opinion

#5

Re: Collar Opinion

Sean Troy

>No pics yet. I will when it's done. I have other turnings I need to take pics of also. I'll need to bleach the wood also. Good post above.

Re: Collar Opinion

#6

Re: Collar Opinion

John Lucas

>Wow I like both woods but they definitely have a different character. If the holly is pure white without the gray or blue streaks I would like either wood. If it has some of the color I think the Cocobolo would contrast with the other lines. You could always dye the cocobolo darker so it looked black but still had some lines.

I just added a finial to a piece. I used holly but dyed it black to look sort of like ebony. It was too stark when I sprayed it to a gloss finish so I knocked it back down with steel wool and then raised the gloss a little with wax. I'll photograph it today and hopefully post it tonight.

Re: Collar Opinion

#7

Re: Collar Opinion

Ron in Drums PA

>Why not try making a collar from both woods and see which you like best?

You could even post pictures of both on WC to get opinions if you like.

Re: Collar Opinion

#8

Ebony

Mike Cunningham (Cape May NJ)

>That stark contrast is great. I make forms of holly and use ebony and also padauk and redheart.

Re: Collar Opinion

#9

Ebony

Carole Valentine

>

Re: Collar Opinion

#10

Re: Collar Opinion

Barry Turner

>Without seeing the piece, I vote for ebony. I like the look, plus you probably won't get a rash from turning it like you may with Cocobolo.

Re: Collar Opinion

#11

Actually, Blackwood if you have it.

Carole Valentine

>The African Blackwood I have used with holly has been absolutely, perfectly black. A wonderful contrast to very white holly.

Re: Collar Opinion

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Collar Opinion

Keith Tompkins

>HI Sean, something to consider....a piece of black veneer at the base of any color collar will create a break between the collar and the form....for example, the cocobolo collar with an layer of ebony veneer under it would be rich.

Re: Collar Opinion

#13

Re: Collar Opinion

Sean Troy

>I like that idea.