Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

Posts

SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

#1

Ellis Walentine

SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

Ellis Walentine

>As you know, every two months we trot out a pithy question for your input. The results are pruned, tossed lightly and submitted to Woodworker West magazine, where they appear as our monthly "News & Views" column. (Click here to read some previous columns.)

This months survey topic was suggested by Barb Siddiqui, our resident editorial assistant and book reviewer. It has to do with the passing of the torch, as it were, of our collective woodworking knowledge and experience to a new generation.

Life today and into the future promises to be very different in many respects, and woodworking is bound to be different as well. This time around, I'd like to hear your thoughts on the place woodworking woodworking will occupy in the lives of our children's generation. What values, skills, sensibilities, etc. will be applicable in the near and mid-term future? As a bonus question, how do you think the activity itself will change to adapt to the new realities of the 21st Century?

Have fun with this one.

Regards,

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

#2

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>It may be wishful thinking but I don't things will change much other than woodworking my not be as important commercially as today. I think the same values will carry over. The one limiting factor in the far future will be the availability of material.

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

#3

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

David Breth

>Woodworking has already transformed from creating items of necessity (dressers, now mass-produced) to items of semi-art and novelty (wooden salad bowls bought at a craft show). In a world being overrun by plastic, I think we will see that substitutes for wood will be identified, and subsequently there will be a smaller demand for woodworking, save items of art. That's where technology will creep in. Ten years from now, it will be possible to create some pretty whacky items, probably with far less hands-on effort than is needed today. The term woodworker will be about as far removed from my great-grandfather the cabinet maker as anyone could possibly imagine.

David B.

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

#4

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

Wally Lloyd, Iquitos, Peru

>I personally think too many people want to work with computers and too few want to work with their hands. Several(Lots!!!!) of years ago I was in London working on a friends house because he could not find anyone to do the small jobs he needed. It was around a 200 mile drive to work!!

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

#5

Re: Response: THE IDES OF WHATEVER

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>You're about 2 week's late for the Ides, Boss; takes care of the "Quickdraw" thing.

Have two adult offspring who have grown up around their Old Man's studio/shop/etc. Along the way they've picked up rudamentary silversmithing skills, have turned bowls, made cutting boards, sweated copper, run drains, fished wire, and know the difference between a king stud a jack stud and a crip. Neither, however, had expressed any real interest in woodworking until resently when each happened to go out shopping for occasional pieces of furniture for their apartments. Both came back emptyhanded with all too familiar stories of chipboard and SWP at outrageous prices even in "furniture" stores. Both then ambled down to the shop to see how to make, not Bombe chests, but rather servicable furniture items that will last longer than the next move.

Mind you, I neither pushed nor cajoled these expressions of interest. Yet each appears to have come to it on his or her own out of a practical need coupled with a rejection of the quality of the increasingly hi-tech factory-made items available to them otherwise.

This weekend my son started a kitchen table in walnut with Emperador marble top. He worked out the design, picked out rough lumber, then jointed, cut, planed, and sanded his stock. My daughter finished the cut diagrams and materials list for a oak chest of drawers to fit a special place in her digs.

Has the torch been passed? Ahhh, no, not yet. But the "interest" and personal "value" of working in this unique material has definately taken hold. They both are still "tied" to their Blackberries, PDA's, etc., but all that stuff seems to be left in another room when they walk into the shop.

They left this afternoon to go "home" to get ready for work tomorrow, but each wanted to be notified when I plan to get the sawyer in for the walnut logs stacked by the driveway.

Prediction? Methods may change, tools will change, but the basic relationship of the person to the material and the outcome will remain the same.

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

#6

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>We gave our nearly fourteen, only grandchild back to his parents at church this morning. He had spent 2.5 days here turning Christmas presents. He has done this the previous four years. He started out with scroll saw and hand sanding. He is progressing to being a pretty good turner. He won one of the kid's lathes at Louisville. He takes great pleasure in revealing the beauty that God hid in tree trunks.

As my only daughter's only child, he will someday inherit all our stuff. He has been sucked into the vortex! He is learning skills that hopefully can provide an income, even if the electronic world doesn't. He is learning that his projects only have the quality that he puts into them. This is an IMPORTANT life lesson that everybody needs to learn.

It was heartwarming to hear that our daughter found him crying after his return from Louisville. He was upset because he thought that since he now has his own lathe he would not get to spend several weekends here making presents. Hopefully he will still want to come in ten years!

Bill in WNC mountains

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

#7

Be patient

T Daniel

>Hi Bill

My sons only want to know the basics for now. They say that when they get old like me they may want to do more. For now they just want to know how to make chips. Each time I win a show they get more motivated though. Hang in there, in due time rewards will come if we do not faint.

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

#8

Re: Be patient

David Galloway

>I want to tee off from Thomas Friedman's work about global economy. In his revision of The World is Flat, he dedicates a chapter to how to educate for the future. He uses Ga. Tech as an example as the school is now taking into consideration the issue of teamwork. They are specifically looking at applications as to two factors: playing a musical instrument within a band, and playing athletics. Both require teamwork. I am very interested in "collaborations" being done by numerous turners. Learning how to "play together" seems important. Thanks for an intriguing question.

DAG

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

#9

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

Allen Neighbors

>I'm writing my response before I read any of the previous respondents, because I have thought about this subject many times in the last couple of years.

I think we (people, as a whole) have evolved into such a micro-wave society, that there are many woodworking techniques and specialties that are falling by the wayside, just because very few seem to have the time to learn them.

It worries me, because I see such cheapness in wooden things that I see today, not only in stores, but in homes and offices. I.E., particle board furniture covered in a cheap plastic tape that is supposed to pass for veneer... and wooden trinkets that are manufactured in sweat shops in Taiwan and Manila, that have no class or quality.

I believe that the future artisans and artists that put out quality work are going to be few and far between. It's going to take concentration... as mentors and instructors... for any of us old timers members of the younger generation to give it a go.

I'm thrilled at the work I see being posted on this forum. Some of the highest quality work in the world is being put out by members of Wood Central, and the woodturners are the best. All of you who are striving for better quality... whether in art or utility... need to recognize the growing abilities of those of the younger generation, and encourage them all you can.

So many things have already passed into the great "back yonder", and we don't want these talents to go to waste.

If you get a chance at a good student... work them for all they're worth... the rewards will be worth working for. I've seen several people express interest in flat work, in the past, and now in woodturning, but it seems that none have the patience to pursue their own inquisitiveness... because it isn't instant gratification. We need to do all we can to further this "art" of fine woodworking... or it's going down the tubes.

Don't want to be a drag on this survey, but these are just my thoughts on this subject.

Now I'm going to read the other posts, and I'll probably wish I'd have just kept my mouth shut. :o)

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

#10

Re: Response: THE IDES OF WHATEVER

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi Mark,

Nice story! I have two little guys that I hope one day show some interest in what's going on in my shop. They both like to play with sticks, but mostly just pass through. The older one is starting to show some interest and I am trying to be casual with him and let him proceed at his own pace.

The time you got to spend with your two sounds like a lot of fun.

Thanks for your note,

Mike

Patience, patience, patience, in Apex, NC...

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

#11

Small Tip

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>They want to be like Dad, but are intimidated by the Great Stuff he does. Help them do only what they wish to do, and allow them to reinvent the wheel their way. That's the toughest part. |;-}}

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

#12

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

Ruth Niles

>We all decide the place of woodworking, cooking and everything else in the lives of all future generations. It's not like there's a mystical box that is opened at each "future point" that tells the generation at that moment how things will have developed. We do that.

Many here have said schools no longer offer vocational programs, that's because this generation (the parents) fussed about their kids need computer not woodworking education. Years ago the kids dressed, behaved and acquired skills by being parented (aka guided), they learned by just living with parents/grandparents and it became part of their instincts.

Every generation wants to "do something new", "get away from here", "make more money", that was our great-grandparents, our grandparents, our parents, us and our children. I think the future generation is going to appreciate working with their hands in direct proportion to what they saw and learned growning up. If, as youngsters, our kids/grandkids express an interest in learning woodworking, utilitarian or artistic, we should try to have schools offer these programs, take time to play with the kids in our shop and take them to shows (craft, art, museums) for inspiration.

Oh, I know "kids today don't want that, they want gameboys and playstation"; yes, my grandkids do, too. But when they come to visit me, I have no tv, they leave their computer games at home and we play in the shop or yard or play games in the house. My kids are in awe that I can keep their kids so interested that they want to come visit and leave the gameboys home. Hey, who stopped playing with them and bought them the computer games? Not me! We are the ones who determines the future, if we want fast, disposable, cheap, then the world will produce chipboard furniture, cardboad fast food and more electronic entertainment.

Guess you get the feeling I'm old fashioned, yep, you're right!

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

#13

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

David Breth

>I really enjoyed reading your post, Ruth. It made me think of some conscious decisions my wife and I have made.

The grandparent position affords you the opportunity to engage the kids more organically than the parents can if you will allow me the use of that term. I've got a couple of little ones at home, and as much as I dislike the soul-less plastic and electronic world, it is the world in which our kids must one day function (which is different than being absorbed into it). So, we have to walk a bit of a tightrope in our efforts to ground them and prepare them for the world in which they'll live.

Our daughter likes to play a Clifford word game on the computer. Many birds are killed with this stone that prepare her for her future. She likes me to take her into my shop after dinner to show her what daddy is making - this is one tool of many I'll use to show her that you get out of something what you put into it, and that hands are good things. We've made a conscious (and not always easy) effort to provide toys that require interraction and imagination, rather than flashy lights and funny sound toys that provide flashy lights and funny sounds. We read books to our children, rather than depend upon a book that reads itself to them (somebody gave us one, I call it the anti-book-reading book). Every year for Christmas, I make something for each child. I've got tools set aside for the kids to cut their teeth on when they are of age, and as my dad did for me, I will show them how to repair their toys.

Someday, my wife and I will get pressured for remote controlled cars and video games and Ipods and cell phones and everything else, but if we are able to get our kids to enjoy a sunny day outside, a canopy of trees, a trip to the park, hanging out with PEOPLE of character, and to appreciate something that was made specifically for them by somebody who loves them, then I'm not too worried about the impact of those other items as they enter our lives. I guess I'm asking a lot, but we seem to be on track so far.

David B.

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

#14

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

Mark Wollschlager

>As stated by others, exposure to Crafts in some way is the best way to spark interest in younger folks.

There will always be a portion of kids who are finding that the arts or working with their hands is what they want to do in the future.

Our (the sort of Royal Our ) current mind set about schools is that they turn out test takers with a knowlege tailored to take the series of standards tests required for graduation.

The schools around here do have vocational training, but primarily the high demand jobs like HVAC, plumbing, cosmetology and the like.

Its one thing to facinate a kid with woodturning/woodworking and another for them to choose it as a future for themselves.

I have met some younger ( than me) people who have chosen woodworking as a career. I really admire there choice and judging from their work, they have the potential to go far.

The problem with the woodworking/woodturning as a career will always be that the market is pretty dependent on disposable income and space in the marketplace for your wares.

The cost of materials and workspaces moves the craftsman away from the marketplace. You can be high end in an area with high disposable income and you can be high end in an area where the customers come to you. There is always room for treen production, but I think furniture and art pieces will be more attractive to career seekers.

The next 20 or 30 years may prove to be a goldmine for craftspeople,

if the economy holds up and disposable income needs a place to go.

There will be room for new blood, and they will take advantage of the opportunity.

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

#15

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

Allen Neighbors

>You're my kinda gal, Ruth Niles!! :o)

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

#16

You are so right...

Bob Fawcett

>We are the ones that determine what path our kids will take.

My grandaughter is 3. She developed a fascination for books early on. We encourage it at every turn. I would much rather buy her books than some electronic gadget, even though I make my living from such stuff. I recently started taking her down to the shop with me. She's still to young to do much with, but I can show her whats there, teach her names of tools, and show off whatever grandpa is making this week, and hopefully spark some interest later when she can understand the safety rules.

I spent the first part of my life working with my hands. Now that that means typing on a keyboard, I get the satisfaction of creating things after work in the shop.

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

#17

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>It is my feeling that the young people most likely to get into woodworking are those whose parents and grandparents are already working with wood. I don't think there will be all that many that will pursue wood, unless introduced to it.

Technology will continue to be a major draw to kids and the numbers that go into the arts and crafts will certainly diminish. It is unfortunate, but it is what I believe to be the wave of the future.

keithz

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

#18

Steven Antonucci

Apples don't fall very far from the tree

steve antonucci

>I think others have kind of made this point as well, but our influence as parents greatly affects the direction our children journey in life. Park your kids in front of the TV and feed them McDonald's, and they become mindless zombies with weight problems. Spend time with them in the shop, and they'll want to make things later in life.

My oldest son is 8. To date, he's worked with files and rasps, a ryoba, and handplanes. He doesn't really want to make things yet, but enjoys being in the shop and having his hands on tools. I only let him use things that are age-appropriate, but I can already see his desire for more.

The future will always have people who are interested in craft and craftsmanship. I think that much like the Arts and Crafts Movement was a rebellion against the Victorians, there will be a "rebellion" against technology (and I am a technology worker...). Automation can always make things better and cheaper, but most people will only pay for one or the other, not both. Today, people still buy Stickley furniture that has been largely made by human hands.

Plus ca change, pluse la meme chose... (the more things change, the more they stay the same)

Steve

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER

#19

Re: Apples don't fall very far from the tree

eliot d

>In my case it will be the grandchildren, who are still too young. but I'm looking forward to getting them down in the shop in a few years. I've already got one of them banging on the piano, though!