We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>After turning a couple of dozen bowls or so, I'm back to hollowforms. Most of what I'm trying to get done these days are "bottle" forms with small openings.
One problem I've encountered is that drilling out the depth hole, the spade bit tends to wander in the endgrain. My current form is about 14" deep and 5" wide, and hollowed to 1/4" or so- but only about 9" deep. Anyone have practical experience for "going deep"?
I hand hold my boring bars, and slow the lathe down, but cutting end grain with a 12" overhand is tough...
Specifically:
1.) If you predrill a depth hole, what kind of bit do you use and how do you keep it from wandering?
2.) If you hand hold your tools, do you have any secrets for controlling the tool? I have had enough of catches exploding the tops of my vessels!
>Steve I found a really long 1" twist drill with a #3 morse taper on it. My machinist friend turned a 1/2" shank on the end so I could put it in my jacobs chuck. I should have had him turn a #2 morse taper. It chatters and wanders off center, probably due to the 1/2" shank. I can't find a #2 morse taper drill that's over 9" but I haven't looked for #3 morse taper drills. Gun drills might come in longer sizes. Lamp boring drills only cut with one flute and that's why they stay closer to the center. I've thought about grinding one tooth down on my long drill to see if it stays centered better.
I don't hollow enough large things to feel comfortable hollowing buy hand. After using Frank Sudol's 1 1/2" captured boring bar you don't even want to try hollowing deep things by hand. That thing cuts so effortlessly up to 14" or so that it's a joy to use. Pain in the butt to pick up and put on the lathe because it weights about 40lbs.
Note: I'm adding this comment after proof reafing my reply -- you may know all this stuff already, and I don't mean to be patronizing if that's the case -- I'll just report what works for me, including some basic stuff, in hopes it may be helpful, especially if anyone reads this who is new to hollow form turning.
Deep hollowing with hand-held tools is a real challange -- even more so through a small opening -- we'll all agree on that ! I make a lot of hollow forms, but usually with 10" internal boring or less. I do have a stabilized boring bar setup for longer reaches or shapes that are difficult to measure wall thickness -- the laser method is just so slick, but it does feel a little like cheating sometimes.
However, I have made a few deep ones through small holes with hand-held tools, and I use a longer bar, especially a longer and heavier handle. You can even get a 2' - 3' length of iron pipe that can be mounted over your current handle (I'd add a few set screws) if you want more mass and length. I GREATLY prefer to use the angled-tip Ellsworth-style boring bars to the straight tips, and try to keep them cutting above center -- this way they can fling off into air if a catch or bad chatter happens (@&%# happens, after all). Straight tools are easier to learn, but in my hands at least, a LOT more prone to catches. The John Jordan curved "hook"[sic] tools in the Armbrace handle are also very nice, and I use these a lot -- keep your elbow in close to your body. For longer reaches with these tools I again prefer the curved tools to the straight ones.
I have had much better results using higher speeds, oddly enough, I suppose because the interval between digs and chatter marks is so much less, like the wood/air interval on natural edges. I used to go much slower, but Luke Mann suggested I try higher speeds when I was newer at this, and I do find that works better for me. When I use a curved, or swan neck tool, I keep it cutting above center, but add a healthy dose of CCW rotation for added shear angle. For longer reaches, I use smaller tips to cut down the forces involved.
Going to smaller cutters is a bit of a compromize, since they can bore into the wood (and through the wall) faster and with less resistance, but they do lessen the forces you have to overcome on the handle end. By smaller, I mean 1/8" tips instead of 3/16" or 1/4". Usually 3/16" is preferred as a good compromise between aggressive cutting (smaller) and aggressive behavior (larger). I have a longer bar with a 1/8" angled tip for longer reaches, but tend to use those with 3/16 for shorter forms. For larger tools like the Sorby or Stewart systems with either 3/8" bullet tips or larger teardrop scrapers, I would (and do) only use these to refine and smoothe the inner surface when that's desired (after removing most of the material with the smaller tips). For long-reach hollowing with these tools, I'd switch to the 1/4" or smaller tips if these are available.
One other strategy is to use tips with a shorter bevel so they are a little less aggressive. They still have to be sharp to cut well and avoid horrible periodic pulsing (sidegrain orientation), but I suspect they are a little less aggressive and a little easier to manage at the business end. If you do get chatter or pulsing in sidegrain vessels (well, any hollow form, actually) sharpening the tool is a good strategy.
As for drilling, I usually use a 1/2" bit in a Jacobs chuck. I may ask for one of those MT#2 drill bits from Santa. Drilling on the Powermatic is much more rewarding than on the Jet 1236, which was more akin to sport, on a good day. My spade bits all have 1/4" shanks, so I have not found them useful at all. I'm interested to learn more about John's comment about lamp auger bits that track straighter with a single cutting flute.
>Steve, I can never get a hole straightd if I hand-hold it. I use a 1/2" HSS drill bit in a tailstock mounted drill chuck. If I have to go deeper, I use a 1/2" brad-point wood boring bit to extend the hole, after I first go as deep as the HSS bit will go.
>Mike Darlow covers drilling deep on the lathe in, I think, his first book. I'm not sure if he is the source, but I think most who have to do such drilling recommend a single flute bit as having less chance of wandering.
To that end, I recently bought a set of 18" long single fluted auger bits from Garrett Wade for less than $40. There are 6 bits in the set from 1/4" to 1". I figure the larger 3 will be useful for hollowform pre-drilling and the others might come in handy as lamp augers (or similar applications). I'm planning on putting the larger bits (5/8", 3/4" and 1") in the drill press and grinding down the lead screw to a point before I use them so the lead screw won't draw the bit in. If it works as expected, I'll probably grind all the lead screws to points.
The link to the Garrett Wade bit set I bought is below. I think Lee Valley has a similar set, of 7 instead of 6, but it is twice the price.
>I read somewhere that you can drill accurately on center using a spindle gouge with the rest set so the gouge is cutting at dead center. The flute is held horizontal. Also look into spoon bits as they work the same way.
>Lamp augers look kind of like spoon augers but they only have one cutting edge. This is very much like using a boring bar in a metal lathe or similar to using a cutter angled to the left when you enlarge an already existing hole in a turning. The only lamp augers I've seen are 3/8" and 5/16".
It would be interesting to see if I could build one that is larger and fits directly onto the tailstock quill. The problem would be chip clearance. The lamp auger has about a 4" hollow that the chips collect in. You have to remove it often to clear the chips.
Gun drills are another option that I've looked into but haven't purchase one yet.
The best drill for drilling deeper straight holes is a drill (forgot the name if I ever knew) that has an end that looks like an auger bit, round with one cutting edge, than a 4 or 5 inch piece that looks like a spindle gouge and then the shaft that has a handle or can be chucked, the front end cuts and the spindle gouge like part holds the chips, works a lot like a gun drill, only better in wood, (it cuts rather than scrapes) and you don't have to clear as often for chip removal, just can't recall the name they use for it up here sorry, maybe someone does though.
>I always use a Forster-type bit in a extension rod that ,in turn, is held in a Jacobs chuck. I say, Froster -'TYPE,' because it's not actually a Forster bit, but it looks like one. It's the kind that you can use at very high speed ( don't do it on the lathe!) for cutting holes at odd angles in the studs of a wall. Electricians use them for running cable, I think. You can get the extension rod in one of the popular wood- tools catalogues. This kind of bit seems to have more 'air" around it ( less metal) so it doesn't tend to get stuck inside the vessel because of heat buildup. I often blow air into the hole as I bore to keep things cool, too.
You can do the same thing with a sharp -- and balanced -- spade bit. By 'balanced', I mean that you carefully regrind the wings of the spade bit, if necessary, so that each wing has exactly the same length.