Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

That stupid collar....

Posts

That stupid collar....

#1

That stupid collar....

Hooligan

>IMO, ruined the piece.

Japanese Maple, Walnut collar. 10"x 4".

Its a bit rough on the picture, as well looks fuzzy, because it's got one coat of wax, that I hadn't buffed out yet.....anyhow....


img

Re: That stupid collar....

#2

Re: That stupid collar....

gil jones

>J, put a golf ball sized wad of deoiled steelwool in some regular vinegar, and a tea bag in 3 ounces of boiling water to steep. Carefully remove the wax from the collar with mineral spirits then lacquer thinner to dry it off. With the piece inverted, brush on a coat or two of the strong black tea and let it dry. Remove the raised grain. Then carefully brush on a coat or two of the iron acetate liquid (from the steelwool/vinegar jar). The collar will turn black (you may need to repeat the tea/iron acetate step). cut off any raised grain, and lightly polish it. Finish as you see fit.

Gil

Re: That stupid collar....

#3

Steven Antonucci

Don't take this personal...

steve antonucci

>but you're right. That collar is a train-wreck.

Commission a ceramic piece and have him put an ugly collar on it. Maybe two of them.

That'll show 'em.

Steve

Re: That stupid collar....

#4

Re: Don't take this personal...

Hooligan

>I don't Steve. I do better work, as far as form is concerned. He wanted it, he's going to get it. I showed him the piece today, and he was happy with it. I am NOT signing it, and as far as I am concerned, learned a very valuable lesson.

I will do a commissioned piece in the future only if I have full capacity in decisions about the piece. No more of that sort of crap.....

Re: That stupid collar....

#5

Re: Don't take this personal...

Carole Valentine

>You should put HIS name on the bottom, or at least "Designed by (his name)". What WAS that guy thinking? What does his pottery look like?

Re: That stupid collar....

#6

Now That's Funny!!!

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Carole,

That is an excellent idea!!

Take care,

Jim

Re: That stupid collar....

#7

Brad Vietje

Re: That stupid collar....

Brad Vietje

>You're right, Hooligan, that just doesn't work. It would be nicer if it came inward toward the opening, as opposed to curving upward, so it could complete the inward curve started in the upper part of the piece.

I like the idea of putting his name on it, and if he has a web site, I'd like to see what sort of "high art" he creates !

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: That stupid collar....

#8

Re: That stupid collar....

Hooligan

>In all actuality, I don't feel that it is ethically correct for me to post his name, or his website. Though I would love to.

I guess it comes down to this. It is what it is, and I've ashed my hands of it. Some of you've agreed that it is not appealing, some may think it is.

Regardless of which, I'm NOT signing it.

So.

There.

Re: That stupid collar....

#9

There's no reason....

Ruth Niles

>why you couldn't post a link to his website. Remember beauty is in the eye of the beholder and some may like his work. You don't have to make any comment on the site or his creations, just post a link.