We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>This is a piece I took to Totally Turning as a prop for my demo "The art of the Finial". Swamp maple crotch with blackwood rim and finial, no finish yet. I will finish with Bush Oil. 8" tall without finial. I couln't resist a quick photo outside...what a great day!
When finished, off to the photographer, then part of an exhibition.
>Looks familiar, though I don't recall it being bigger than a tree
;)
Ever consider leaving it without finish? It makes a great contrast as is, and I've got a friend who has done lots of work left natural, and that is growing on me now.
>It's fantastic Keith. I just love the finial. Beautiful job all the way around. And you know what....I love the backdrop too! I dont' care what Jamie says ; )
Man, you know I love you, but I have to buck the trend here.
I love the hollow form, the wood selection is great, and the shape is as good as it gets. I love the shape of the lid and finial. The color contrast of the finial to the hollow form is great. The complexity of the finial compliments and highlight the simple elegance of the hollow form. The simple dark color of the finial complements the wonder splated grain of the hollow form. Very much a Yin-Yang thing going here.
HOWEVER, I think that the scale of the finial is twice as big as it should be (IMHO). It over powers the rest of the piece. It should be the wonderful desert to this visual feast.
>Keith I have to agree with Mark. I love all the shapes. Especially the way the form goes from the maple and flows up into the finial. I also really like the shape of the finial. The size of the finial overpowers the base. I'm thinking maybe 1/3 smaller. Cool piece.
>Thanks Guys! Mark and John, you know, the finial does look overpowering in the photo.....it may be the way I took the shot. In real life doesn't seem that big, but I'll experiment with smaller dimensions. Appreciate the input!
>Keith, I do agree with Mark. The form is so perfect but the finial is too much. It's expertly done, as usual for you. It seems the longer, thinner finial is one of those "woodturner's challenge" that is fun to turn but should be used sparingly.
>HI Ed, thanks! I guess over time the piece would acquire a nice patina from handling, etc., but I think the color would change to a unpleasant brown in the short term.
>Dadblast it Ruth, I hate it when you're right! Three things we turners are obsessive about: 1. hollowing through a tiny hole. 2. turning l-o-n-g stemmed goblets. 3. Turning long finials. I've overcome two out of three, but can't I have just ONE bad habbit? please? LOL
>Beautiful! The HF is outstanding and the finial just makes it. What I love is the curve from the start of the rim to the top of the finial, great work Keith.
>WOW, Keith, that's a SWEET piece! Spectacular form; superb finial. I think I agree with John that about 1/3 less finial would be an even better balance, though. You could just put this finial on the larger one you didn't show us ;~), and start working on a smaller finial for this one!
>A quick shot of the same piece, straight on...Yeah, I know crappy photo. One thing however, the shadow really shows the profile pretty well...hmmm. Thanks for looking...any better?
I'm not sure if the chorus will feel the finial still looks too tall for the piece, but I wanted to take a sec or two to point out why this is about the best finial I've seen in quite a long while, maybe THE best, including those of the aforementioned Cindy Drozda.
First, I'm finnicky about finials; really finnicky. I start from the general aesthetic sense that the finial should direct our gaze lovingly upward. Sorry for the squishy romantic language, but I can't think of a better way to phrase it without more sleep. What I'm attempting to get at is that each turned element should be in a proportional sequence that directs our attention up its length like a well-designed church spire. So, in my view, the general idea is to taper from larger elements at the base to progressively smaller similar elements at the top. This includes an apparent tapering of the central column, as well as every element hung on it.
Thus, the central column seems to get smaller and smaller, as do the wider elements at the base, the three "bulb" elements (larger ball, medium urn shape, and upper flame element at the tip), and even the flats, stops or raised rings, which progress from a little stop at the top of the base, to the filet below the spherical ball element, and the two raised rings below the other main elements.
I may not be writing my thoughts very clearly, but this all adds up to a near-perfect finial. This is something I just can't say about most of the Drozda finials I've seen. Don't get me wrong, she produces some of the most beautiful and exciting turned works of art today, (I really like her work), but her finial design sometimes falls short for me. She's known all over for long, thin, very delicate finials, which is technical mastery at its best, but she often puts larger elements atop smaller ones, or allows a thin central column to get thicker further up the finial. That may not break anyone else's design "rules", but yours is an example of one that doesn't break any of mine.
Whether this near-perfect finial fits perfectly on the Maple form it sits on is another question. I'll read what the wider jury has to say about that. I like it a lot just the way it is -- fantastic.
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
PS: the PERFECT finial is one just like that, but on my mantle !
>Thanks Brad. Thanks for the kind comments. I'm extremely critical of finials as well, including my own. I like your church spire analogy....have you noticed that the tall ones are dramatic, while the short ones don't generate much "pop"? Even though some finials seem too tall, it's hard to get the same effect with a short one.
We have similar views on finials...here's my take on this one...first, I design them from the bottom up, following the form's shape right up through the collar. Then a cove to visually separate the large bead from the collar. An assymetrical cove almost always looks more pleasing than a symetrical one. I separate the elements with filets, as you noticed; I try to make them progressive as well.
This finial is removable, the larger bead works well as a place to grasp the finial. I make the beads assymetrical as well. I debated making the next long shape leading upward smaller in diameter; in hindsight, probably would have been better. The shape of this section is critical; any interruption in the flow ruins the finial. At the smallest section, the diameter is 3/32". I could go smaller, which would add a more delicate look, but will have a greater chance of someone snapping them off. I like the size of the shape on the tip...too small, and it's anticlimatic.
Can't see in the photos, but there is a 1/32" cove beneath the tip...I made a set of micro tools just for finials..a 1/32" fluteless gouge, a 1/16" gouge, a 1/8" bedan, and a 1/8" detail tool. I'm excited to see what I can do with them.
that looks like a bedan on its side with a long, long bevel.
>Hi ED, yes, that's the basic design I chose for the piece. Then when I got time, I turned the finished finial. I debated adding a spalted maple section, but in the end decided against it.