Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Collars; revisited....

Posts

Collars; revisited....

#1

Collars; revisited....

Hooligan

>I've got a vase that the client wants a collar on. Effectively changing the intent of the piece. It was originally turned with a small lip, and lid. Somewhat typical high shoulder, and a very long curve. It is not bulbous a form at all, it is quite slender.

Here's the problem, I put a collar on it, and I am going to lose the relationship of the opening to the rest of the vessel. It is completely unlike me to want to change a piece, let alone to make someone else happy. They (the client) has a very good idea of what they wish to happen, with the overall look of the piece, even sketching what they wish to have as the collar.

Do I change it, and risk ruining the piece? Or do I say no, and leave it as is. What would YOU do in the situation?

I'll get a picture posted.

Re: Collars; revisited....

#2

Re: Collars; revisited....

Carole Valentine

>Sounds like a battle between principle and money. How bad do you need to sell it to this client? Would you be ashamed to have your name on it if you make the requested changes? Can you turn another similar piece but one designed for a collar rather than having the collar be an afterthought? No answers here...just questions. ;)

Re: Collars; revisited....

#3

Re: Collars; revisited....

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>I usually tell them there is a great risk of losing the whole thing, but I would be happy to make them another, taking into account price differences and such for a different amount of work. I always grind my teeth about people who have very definite ideas after something is already done...

Bill

Re: Collars; revisited....

#4

Re: Collars; revisited....

RK in Milwaukee

>Personally, I would give this person a list of competitors I don't like. As a commercial photographer I was faced with this type of situation in my early years and trying to accomodate this type of client never worked out and usually ended up with me taking the hit financially.

Now I just tell them that if they are going to hate me I would rather they hate me before spending any money. That way we don't end up in court.

If this client wants to design the piece they should take up wood turning. I know this sounds like a hard assed approach but I have learned the hard way.

Good luck whatever you decide.

Ron Nelson

Re: Collars; revisited....

#5

Re: Collars; revisited....

Hooligan

>Carol, that's just it. In a nutshell. I don't need to sell it to him, though I very much want to, because he is so well known in the ceramics world.

Part of me, as Bill stated, wants to grind my teeth, and just turn him away. The other part of me wants to do it, and be done.

Realistically, I can't do another one, as I have only the one piece of maple that he brought me to make it out of......so that leaves me at the original place, you know?

Re: Collars; revisited....

#6

Re: Collars; revisited....

john lucas

>Not being a professional woodturner but needing the money, I look at it like Carole said. If I'm not ashamed of the piece then I sell it. Most people aren't as picky as we are and even have thier own tastes. As long as they are happy and I'm not embarrassed I take the money and run.

Now my art pieces are different. I view them as a creation for a purpose and I won't change anything and I won't make them something like it. That's where I draw the line.

Re: Collars; revisited....

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Collars; revisited....

Keith Tompkins

>Hooligan, He brought the wood? That's what it sounds like....if that's so, there should have been a "meeting of the minds" before any work was done. He, as a known ceramicist, should know that as well as anyone. Asking you to change a piece after it's already completed isn't fair. There's no guarantee he'll like the new version any better than the first once completed. You end up holding the bag in any case.

I spent many years in the custom furniture business....Very frustrating unless things are clearly spelled out on paper.

Re: Collars; revisited....

#8

Brad Vietje

Re: Collars; revisited....

Brad Vietje

>What an interesting question... I sure will look forward to any pic's you can post. Is there any way to turn the collar separately and show the client the piece with and without the collar ? If this person has a developed sense of asthetics as a ceramicist, you might make your case that it would look better the way you want to make it. If the client prevails, how do you feel about NOT signing this one ?

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Collars; revisited....

#9

Re: If he's a ceramicist he should have......

Jamie Donaldson

>.... some knowledge of the form he wants. I would do the best I could to satisfy his wants and yours, providing he makes a 50% deposit for the total cost and agrees to be responsible for the balance when work is delivered.

Re: Collars; revisited....

#10

Re: Collars; revisited....

Hooligan

>Pretty much my thoughts on it, Keith. I suppose, if nothing else, I learned from the situation. I thought that we were in agreement as far as what he had wanted, I was wrong I guess.

I got so stinkin mad about it, earlier after talking to him for the third time today, I cut it, and put a collar on it, per his request. Just to have it over and done. He wasn't going to yield, and I have enough invested in it NOW that if he doesn't pay me, I will stick it in a gallery and hope that it sells. I sincerely regret that I didn't post a before, but I will post an after tomorrow, just so you guys+gals can see what I am talking about.

Re: Collars; revisited....

#11

Re: Collars; revisited....

Hooligan

>I"m not signing it. It isn't my design. I just turned it to his spec's. That's the way I feel about it now.

Re: Collars; revisited....

#12

Leo Van Der Loo

I'm probably in a different position than you,

Leo Van Der Loo

>But I have had people try to have me turn some work for them to their idea, and my standard answer has always been, "no sorry, I can't look into your mind to see what you like, but if you like what I turn than you can buy what I turn.".

Learned my lesson well in my previous life, Hooligan, too many times they like you to make them something to a memory they have of something, and you'll never be able to make that that come true, for grain, shape and/or color combinations, plus their mind altering the reality, it's a loosing battle.

But if they pay you before you start it's a different story altogether.

Like to see what you made of this struggle though.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Collars; revisited....

#13

Re Bill grinding his teeth

Dinyar Chavda

>Another mystery solved. That explains the anomalous readings on the richter scale at the local seismological center! :-)

Re: Collars; revisited....

#14

Not signed, but ?

Ruth Niles

>Keith had mentioned that it sounded like this guy brought the wood to you to turn this piece, is that right? If it is, end of debate, you turn what he wants no matter how ugly to your (or our) eye.

I stopped doing commission work (other than spindles) a long time ago. As Leo said, I tell everyone (EVERYONE), "I'll make turnings, if you like them, you buy them." Got burned too many times with "just make a set of salad bowls (example) I love your work and will love whatever you do." "Oh, not that deep." "Could you make a little rim on them instead?" etc.

If you like doing commission work, get a detailed drawing signed by the customer.

Re: Collars; revisited....

#15

Re: Collars; revisited....

Ron in Drums PA

>I've been in the same boat recently.

I have a friend who specializes in exotic woods. This person is an eccentric old codger, who in his younger days was a turner himself. He asked me to do some turnings for him. He had definite design ideas that were not at all to my taste. I agreed to turn some samples for him using the wood he supplied. The first one I loved and he hated. In matter of fact he hated the next 4. All the while I'm telling him, "this is the way I turn." BTW, some of you have seen the first piece at Bill's 5 Barns picnic and at Totally Turning.

Well after about 6 months, we finally settled on a form and I turned 3 of them out of some wonderful quilted bubinga. But I have to tell you, I was really dissatisfied with the shape, so much so that I didn't take any photos and only placed my web address on the bottom of each piece. I will say that the finish was my best yet.

Now if I was doing this for cash I would have acted differently. My compensation has been working and helping a good friend, who I believe won't be around much longer, and not to mention a boat load of some amazing wood. Included in this pile of wood I have 3 pieces of quilted bubinga that measures 14"x14"x2". If this was a client, I would have shown him the door early on no matter what the compensation.

BTW, the three pieces where shipped yesterday, the first went to the American Embassy in South Africa, the second I was only told is a South African government official, and the third to my friend's friend also in South Africa.

Re: Collars; revisited....

#16

Re: Collars; revisited....

Stuart Johnson

>Can you take a photo of it as is and then use one of those programs that allow you to change the photo to show it with the collar? He might see the change and say no leave it as is. On the other hand you might change your mind and like it.

Re: Collars; revisited....

#17

creative soulution

Robin Corell

>ofer to trade your altered turning for one of their pieces. Then find a nice bowl this person has made and ask them to drill a hole in the botom so you can use it as a planter.

Robin

Re: Collars; revisited....

#18

Re: creative soulution

Leslie S

>Robin,

That's BRILLIANT!!!!!!!!!

Leslie