Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Punky Maple Hollow Form

Posts

Punky Maple Hollow Form

#1

Punky Maple Hollow Form

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Here's something from the other end of the turning spectrum - other end from a nice clean cutting piece of figured walnut that is. :)


This is a piece of maple burl that got left out in the weather by accident. It is beautiful stuff, but boy was it a challenge to cut, and I am not sure I like the final product. I had to soak it real good with Minwax Wood Hardener to get it to cut well, and hollowing, while easy, left a very rough surface. I usually don't worry too much about that until I read about all of you concrete sequential people who actually sand the insides! What makes it worse? See below.


It is relatively easy to see inside, although not in this picture. It is rough rough rough, but there is not much I am going to do about it. Rough it is, and rough it is going to stay. This piece is fragile and I am not going to booger it all up with a sanding disk. I will just have to find a customer who doesn't know about the requirement to sand the insides. It is finished with Bush Oil, and I am trying to figure out what else might help it. There is some MWH from the soak that is making some of the points on the NE shiny, but I am not sure how to either buff them down or bring up the shine on the rest of the piece. Suggestions anyone?

Thanks.

Bill

Re: Punky Maple Hollow Form

#2

Re: Punky Maple Hollow Form

Hooligan

>Suggestions for what? It's fine as it is!

Re: Punky Maple Hollow Form

#3

Re:I have a can of Minwax....

Jamie Donaldson

>...Wood Hardener that I've refilled a zillion times with old Deft lacquer cut with acetone- use it for punky wood and as a sanding/cutting prep. On a piece that cries out to be rustic I brush with a stiff nylon or brass bristle brush to dull down any bright spots, and it also enhances spots that aren't rustic enough!

Re: Punky Maple Hollow Form

#4

Re: Punky Maple Hollow Form

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>Bill

Some of the pen turners are using pressure pots and infusing clear acrylic to fill punky/voids areas. Don't know if you can do it on this large of a scale.

Terry

Re: Punky Maple Hollow Form

#5

Ellis Walentine

To kill the gloss...

Ellis Walentine

>...you might want to spray some artist's matte spray on it.

Nice piece, Bill. That hardener really saturated the colors.

Ellis

Re: Punky Maple Hollow Form

#6

Dick Hines

Re: Punky Maple Hollow Form

Dick Hines

>I suggest you do more and post the pictures.

Re: Punky Maple Hollow Form

#7

Re: Punky Maple Hollow Form

eliot d

>It's funny that I gave up on two punky maple hollow forms today. One of them had a punky area ,not even as large as yours, that will result in a big hole, and I just didn't want that bit of a hole.( Although I must say that your piece looks good, so perhaps I'll reconsider. )

But here's my real question: do you find when turning punky maple that no matter what you do there is constant tool chatter against the wood? I was beginning to doubt my (expensive) Vicmarc chuck, my lathe, my sharpening technique. EVERYTHING! I thought I was loosing my grip! I would like to believe that the tool edge sees hard/soft,hard/soft etc,etc. at a high frequency and therefore chatters, which, if correct, means that I'm not loosing it. Can you help me out on this? I need conformation , or a refutation, in which case I had better start making runout measurements and the like.

Re: Punky Maple Hollow Form

#8

Re: Punky Maple Hollow Form

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Thanks everyone!

Terry, I started doing this because of pens back in the early 90s. I made a spalted pen and got orders for a bunch more. The failure rate was over 90%, so I had to do something, and this is what I came up with. It would be interesting to see how a pressure pot treated pen looks, although I would need a big pot and a lot of "juice" to treat a piece like this one.

Ellis, thanks for the matte spray idea, I will check it out.

Eliot, I am afraid you are the only one this ever happens to, and I have no idea why. Ha ha, not really, you have nailed it on the head. It is the difference between the harder areas and softer areas that cause the tool to vibrate. If you press real hard against the wood, you end up with an irregular shape when you think it should be rounder. The key is moving your whole body through the cut and cutting very lightly. I call this cutting to the invisible line. This allows you to cut through both the hard and the soft and maintain a sembalance of roundness. Sanding these things is tough too, since the softer wood abrades much more quickly than the harder, and before you know it, the wood is dished, and so are you (to use an old phrase).

Thanks again for all the comments and suggestions.

Bill

Re: Punky Maple Hollow Form

#9

Re: Punky Maple Hollow Form

eliot d

>Bill. I am so relieved!. But let me get something straight: does the piece actually become slightly out of round? Because that's what it looks and feels like to me. In other words, if I were to check runout at the spindle and the edge of the chuck, runout would be minimal; but runout at the edge of the turned piece would be significant. Of course, I'm going to check it right now. This explanation would be acceptable to me in the sense that it's just part of turning punky wood and that my equipment or technique is not the heart of the problem.

Re: Punky Maple Hollow Form

#10

Here's a thought about the inside...

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>How about black gesso on the inside? It would "hide" the roughness of the inside walls and it would not be so apparent. The black could also enhance the spalt lines on the exterior.

keithz

Re: Punky Maple Hollow Form

#11

Re: Punky Maple Hollow Form

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Eliot, wood moves all the time, and it can certainly move while it is on the lathe. I think it is going to vary from piece to piece though. And, you will also find that runout gets worse the further you get out from the headstock. What is only a few thousandths at the headstock can be huge by the time you get to the end of whatever it is you are turning, and when you reverse it, you introduce a whole new wobble, which is why pieces most often have to be retrued when they are flipped.

Bill

Re: Punky Maple Hollow Form

#12

Re: Here's a thought about the inside...

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Keith, a long time ago one of the guys in our club was describing how he had painted the inside of a hollow form black to minimize the roughness, but he wasn't entirely happy with the results. I asked him deadpan straight if he had used flat black paint. He answered no, just as seriously as I had asked, and it was only when a few people in the club started snickering did he realize I had gotten him. I was thinking about that very incident and wondering if I should try to paint this thing, but I wimped out. I do not have nearly the patience he has when it comes to this stuff.

Bill

Re: Punky Maple Hollow Form

#13

Re: If he had used ultra-suede black....

Jamie Donaldson

>... it would both look and feel smooth!!!