Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

Posts

Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#1

Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

Devon Palmer

>I'm sure replies will be riddled with "depends"... but..

I'm getting ready to tear into 12-15 18"x12" ambrosia maple cyliders I roughed out early this year and set aside to lose a little bit of moisture and maybe even spalt. I don't mind sanding any more as it feels like I've cut my sanding to 25% of what it used to be with a better end result. I have to say tho, the thought of sanding through a teeny 2-3 inch hole, a foot to foot and a half deep seems more painful that mounting a 3x3 square blank between centers, placing my forehead on it and turning on the lathe. <>

How many of y'all sand inside your hollowforms? What factors determine your decision to sand or not?

- Devo

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#2

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

Bill Howatt

>Factors seem to be:

Can you physically do it? It can be virtually impossible to do.

If you can touch it, sand it.

If you can see it, how good does it look without sanding?

Naturally, there are those who will go to great lengths to sand it just because it isn't sanded. They are usually identified by the band-aids around their fingers.

Bill

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#3

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

Ron in Drums PA

>If I can touch it, it gets sanded.

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#4

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

Mark Kauder

>I agree with the above. If you can reasonably touch it, it should be sanded. If you can reasonably see it, it should look good, if not sanded, and you should always apply a finish similar to the outside to the inside so that you have similar moisture/humidity absorbtion inside and out.

Mark

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#5

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

Mike Cunningham (Cape May NJ)

>Only as far as my finger can reach. If one can peer into it, I make sure that there are no visible tools marks....within reason. I always add finish to the inside, I pour in some watco and make sure all surfaces are covered, same finish that I use on the outer surface, probably 90% of the time.

I love to add collars with quite small openings, usually in ebony.


img

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#6

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>On the small HF's that have a small opening that won't acept a finger, I sand to 600 and apply 6 coats of finish.....:-)

First, I get it as smooth and even as I can with my hollowing tool. Then a long pair of forceps to grip folded sandpaper works very well. Steady it on a toolrest and don't put your fingers in the loops.

Wally

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#7

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

Carole Valentine

>I use the 12" locking forceps with sandpaper wrapped around a small piece of firm foam rubber. I don't apply finish on the inside of pieces with tiny openings (except the inside of the neck.) Maybe I should, but it seems to take forever for it to dry and for the odor to go away. Anything you can see into and work in (large openings) gets the same treatment as the outside.

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#8

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

RK in Milwaukee

>I heard once that Cindy Drozda sands the inside of her hollow vessels. If Cindy does it that's good enough for me. so I came up with an easy way to sand inside hollowforms and posted it some time ago. Search the archives for the Acme Sand-o-Matic and see if it might be of use to you.

BTW, if you want to get good at finials, Cindy's DVD called "Elegant Finials" is excellant.

Ron Nelson

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#9

Steven Antonucci

I barely sand the outsides...

steve antonucci

>Not that I'm that great, but there's something about the wood having a slight amount of texture that just makes me want to hold it a little bit longer.

And I hate sanding.

Steve

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#10

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

Hooligan

>Only to 400. I don't see reason for going beyond that. As well, I oil them.

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#11

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

OB O'Brien

>I only sand the inside as far as I can reach. Sometimes I put a collar on em with a small hole. Sometimes I spray flat black paint down inside after sanding them a little. The black paint eats up all the light and you can't see if its rough or not. Some turners I heard of just leave it textured. Terry Daniels and Allen Neighbors have made a tumbler and put granite rocks inside and tumble them for a day or two. They get a real nice smooth interior. Whatever you do it will still sell, cause most of the public don't know any difference. Just us turners. OB

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#12

No.

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>a. I refuse to cater to the OCD crowd who think every milimeter must be finished to 14,000 grit Micro-mesh (and look askance at contrary opinions); and

b. I think the rough interior, provided the walls are even, reflects the power of the process that made the object. In my view, the exterior and interior surfaces of a jar ("hollowform" if you must) have very different functions. The exterior is the "face" the world visually perceives, so smoothing it provides reinforcement of its function as a taught skin holding back the internal gesture of the wood. Leaving the interior rough with all the tool marks, etc., reinforces the fiberous nature of the material's inherent structure.

c. Could I sand it? Yes, of course. It's not hard to do in any number of ways. Will I? No.

Hey, you asked.

mm

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#13

Re: No. I learned to hollow from David.........

Jamie Donaldson

>.....Ellsworth, and he doesn't sand the insides, and that's good enough for me! But the top holes are as small as I can make them, and I take pains (sometimes literally!!) to make the surface as uniform as I feel necessary, and sometimes add finish, sometimes not.

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#14

Re: No. I learned to hollow from David.........

Hooligan

>Again, though, it depends on whether a piece is intended to be functional or not. Functional pieces, imwo, should be sanded, at the very least. Finished is better.

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#15

You & Me, Both

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Learned from him. Must say that I miss the physicality of hollowing "by hand," but the shoulder/arm just would not take the stress and vibration.

mm

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#16

Dick Hines

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

Dick Hines

>Make the openings small enough and you don't have to sand.

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

Keith Tompkins

>I think it's a matter of personal taste...sand or not. Up to you.

However, if I were purchasing a piece for my collection, I would ask the turner to leave the tool marks on the interior...even if they regularly sand. Why? A smooth, finished exterior may be impressive, but when I view the interior of a well-turned form, I can see and feel the marks left by a skilled turner. I almost feel the connection between the piece and its maker . As good a his signature on the bottom.

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#18

Re: Paint it flat black and forget about it.

Russ Fairfield

>Nobody but another woodturner will know the difference.

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#19

Re: No.

RK in Milwaukee

>Just curious. What is the "OCD Crowd"?

Ron

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#20

OCD Crowd

Barry Irby

>Obsessive Compulsive Disorder Crowd.

I start at 100 grit and send an e-mail to Mark Mandel, then sand at 120 grit and send an e-mail to Mark Mandel, then sand at 150 grit and send an e-mail to Mark Mandel, then sand at 180 grit and send an e-mail to Mark Mandel, then sand at 220 grit and send an e-mail to Mark Mandel, then sand at 320 grit and send an e-mail to Mark Mandel, then sand at 400 grit and send an e-mail to Mark Mandel, then sand at 600 grit and send an e-mail to Mark Mandel, then sand at 1000 grit and send an e-mail to Mark Mandel, then sand at 1500 grit and send an e-mail to Mark Mandel, then sand at 2000 grit and send an e-mail to Mark Mandel,.....

I would explain the rest of it to you, but its time to send an e-mail to Mark Mandel telling him to quit picking on the OCD Crowd.

I actually don't know much about OCD, but I know you don't want to tick one of them off, you will get an E-mail.

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#21

LOL

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>'Specially when all those e-mails bounce 'cause they were sent to the wrong guy! Oh, how sweet t'would be.

"But I copied his e-mail address so I know it's correct. I don't make such mistakes, ever! It just doesn't make sense. Maybe it will get through after I finish the next grit . . . ."

|;-}}}}}

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#22

Actually

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>OCD is no laughing matter and those who have the disorder do not think it's funny at all, and truly suffer from it. Those people are not who I referred to, but rather those who, having exalted process over originality, gauge the quality of a work (and often its maker) by the clarity of its finish rather than the clarity of the idea.

m

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#23

ROFL!

Carole Valentine

>

Re: Do you sand the inside of your hollowforms?

#24

Re: Actually

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I�m not politically correct so I call them anal. I do agree with your philosophy of what is important in turning though.