We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I always thought there were two ways to do it( other than sanding): shear scraping, and scraping with an exaggerated burr --either with a conventional scraper or with a hand held carpenter's scraper. At a recent demo by Trent Bosh, he claimed the best way is to cut --not scrap -- with a sharp bowl gauge that has a more or less vertical bevel angle. He demonstrated what he preached, too. What do you think?
>When I get to the point of should I shear scrape or shear cut, I'll coat the whole inside with some paste wax (I like Johnson's floor wax), then do one last cut with the bowl gouge. This usually does a fairly nice job of cleaning up tearout. Of course you have to take into consideration of coloring or tinting the wood plus your finish. IF that is a major concern, ask Russ Fairfield.
>Yes, with a long fingernail grind. Roll the gouge all the way over with the flute toward the work and with both bevels touching, rotate the upper bevel slightly away from the surface so that your cutting with the lower bevel. Pull this along the work, try it even with the tool rest or shearing with it angled upward, say 45 degrees to the rest. This is a non-bevel rubbing cut, don't open it too far or you'll get a catch when the lower edge digs in, also do not extend too far beyond your tool rest, particularly at an angle, the force of the wrok will want to pull the gouge over. A very effective cut for cleaning up tear out, many feel more so that a scraper.
>Me too and the lower the cutting angle on the tool the better it will shear the fibers. Most bowl gouges are ground around 60 degrees. I've started using a stewart Batty grind of 40 degrees when I can. A spindle gouge or Dave Hout Bowl skew are also good.
The recommedation to use wax, or wood hardner or anything else that both lubricates and hardens the wood will also help. Do this before the last cut and use a freshly sharpened gouge. This is the only time I hone the bowl gouge. It needs to be really sharp to cut punky wood.
If your going to scrape try tilting a round scraper at 45 degrees or even steeper and take very light cuts. You might try both directions, scraping toward the center and then out away from the center. Sometimes grain orientation will let you cut cleaner in one direction or the other.
Last, and maybe second only to using a really sharp tool, is don't force the cut. lighten up you grip and let the tool do the cutting. When your doing it right you should need very little effort to cut the wood.
>You'll get the best result if you cut WITH the grain, with a freshly sharpened gouge while rubbing the bevel all the way. Don't rub too hard or you'll burnish the wood, making it very difficult do a good sanding job.
When shear sraping with the gouge as others have described, you'll get the best results if you first apply finishing oil to the wood, lower the handle so the cut is at an angle, and use a very light touch.
>Here's a bowl gouge cut to cleanly cut the bottom, inside, of the bowl, that isn't widely known. This is an especially good one for a deep bowl where you can't rub the bevel on a normal cut.
Lower the tool rest a little so that the cut can be made with the handle well down. Start down the side in the normal fashion, rubbing the bevel, then at the transition point to cut across the bottom, roll the tool slightly so that the bevel is up a little more, then with the handle leading and pointing away from you, PUSH the tool in a rainbow arc to the center of the bowl. You'll be rubbing the bevel all the way in a very controlled cut. Just be careful that you don't roll the tool so that the bevel gets away from the wood. You'll get a dig-in if you do. The cutting is done near the nose. Practice this cut a bit. You'll use it a lot.
>I agree with Wally. I have used this cutting technique since the days of the square across ground superflutes and it is extremely efficient ... IF you don't get agressive or roll the tool too much. The rainbow arc is a good analogy. I always taught it as an "uphill till near the last 1 inch or so then downhill to the cebter." Try it ... you just might like it.
>Dick, a lot of today's turners don't know that in the early days of the bowl gouge we all used them ground square across...no side grind. You had to watch those corners!
I did the same thing. As soon as I got home from the meeting, I reground an old gouge the way Trent showed us and tried it on the bowl I was working on. It worked great - took out almost all of the tearout that I had left - even what was left after I had tried a high-angle shear scrape. It didn't take long to figure out how to use it. I'll be doing it that way from now on. MUCH less sanding than before.
>I use two grinds...the Ellsworth, and one very similar to the Oneway grind...almost straight across with the wings only slightly cut back. This grind cuts very very, clean. I use it very sharp, with the flute nearly straight up, cutting on tht side of the grind....on some woods, it cuts so cleanly , little sanding is needed.
>I tried it too, and it does work to remove tearout. What I can't understand is what's the advantage of grinding the tool that way -- a steep 90 degrees. I mean, why do the fibers care if the sharp steel is on a steep bevel or a swept back bevel so long as the edge is presented the same way. Mind you, I'm talking about the outside of a vessel, so it's not a question of following the inside of a bowl.
>Elliot, if you observe the angle that the tool approaches the wood, it's shearing the grain at a 45 degree angle or so. Similar to skewing a plane across a board to achieve the same thing.
>I understand; but why can't I get the same result with a swept back tool so long as I present the edge at more or less the same angle? This is to ask, why go through the trouble of grinding the 90 degree tool edge if you already have a sharp tool, with some other grind, that you can present the same way?