We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I am looking at bowl coring rigs and wonder which is best for my 16" Jet. Will do a search as I am sure this has been discussed before. But more importantly how do you mount those bowl blanks to finish turn them? MAybe a glue block?
Fishing is coming to a close so it back into the shop.
>I use a PVC coupler held in my chuck with a piece of scotch bright over it on the inside of the bowl and the tail stock on the outside to turn the tenon. Then reverse it in my chuck
>Since the bowl is rough turned only, I often just put it right over my bare Oneway chuck and bring up the tailstock and turn the tenon. If I want to be real careful, I'll put a piece of old router-mat or mousepad over the chuck first.
If you don't have a chuck then the glue block will work.
I drill a 2-1/8" hole with my forstner bit into side that I want the inside of the bowl to be.
I mount the wood on a chuck, bring up the tail stock and shape the outside. Sometimes I turn a tenon, sometimes I true up the bottom for a glue block.
I flip the bowl around and mount on a chuck and start coring.
When the first core is finished. I use the same 2-1/8" hole to chuck up the wood, clean up the outside, then either turn a tenon or true up for a glue block.
Repeat as many times as you can.
There are other ways that I've tried but this seems to work the best for me.
>I do exactly as Bill said - just mount your chuck and place the inside of the bowl over the chuck and then bring up the tailstock. Pressure from the tailstock holds the bowl in place and gives you enough of a grip to turn a tenon. Then you can reverse the bowl and mount in the chuck and from there I turn both the outside and inside from that same mounting (see Bill Grumbine's EXCELLENT DVD for more instruction).
>I do the same as Brian and Bill. The center will need finish turned so simply place the interior against the chuck with the jaws expanded to where the bowl sits on them in a stable manner and bring up the tail stock to exert enough pressure to hold the bowl in place. Turn the tenon, turn the bowl around, chuck and finish it. I often do the same to bring a tenon back to round after a bowl has dried following rough turning. Other methods work but this seems the simplest as well as quick.
>I do the same as Brian and Bill. The inside will need finish turned so simply place the interior against the chuck with the jaws expanded to where the bowl sits on them in a stable manner and bring up the tail stock to exert enough pressure to hold the bowl in place. Turn the tenon, turn the bowl around, chuck and finish it. I often do the same to bring a tenon back to round after a bowl has dried following rough turning. Other methods work but this seems the simplest as well as quick.
>For mounting and final turning, I use a recess (forstner bit) on the top of the blank to mount with expanding chuck, I turn the bottom, then I cut a recess in the base. I reverse it, and take the largest core first. I then final turn the biggest bowl. I then let the green bowl dry and warp before sanding and finishing so I only have to remount for sanding. Next, mount the core and turn the base as before. Throughout the whole coring of each blank, the chuck never comes off. I also don't use a tailstock.
As for the coring systems, I have all three. As simply as possible (I do a demo with the 3 systems):
Oneway: Most expensive. For your lathe you would need at least the 2 smaller knives (#2 removes a 12 inch diameter core), probably the 3rd knife, but not the biggest. I like it for the bigger cores say 14 to 16 inch diameter. The support finger for the knife makes it much steadier as you get farther off the tool rest. The cutters are a pain to sharpen, because it has to be removed from the knife, sharpened, then put back on the knife. The little point on the cutter serves a purpose, but makes it hard to sharpen. Oneway does have a jig now so you don't have to hold the bit in your fingers. I got it on Friday, and haven't had a chance to try it out yet. Having to stop the lathe and advance the support finger does consume some extra time, but not a whole lot.
Woodcut Bowlsaver: A nice little unit. Big radius blade is 5 inches, so a 10 inch diameter core is removed easily. You can go bigger, but you get a concave bottom on the core which can cause you to lose some depth on the core. To change blades, you have to move both blades. Not much of an inconvenience. Blades can be touched up with a diamond hone or easily on the grinder. It is made to work with the tailstock attaching to the rear of the set up, and as I never use the tailstock, this is a major drawback to me. There is some chatter when at the full reach of the blades, but not a lot. I have used it without the tailstock, and it works but with more chatter than if you use the tailstock. Okay with a piece of cherry, lots of chatter with locust. I don't recomend this (without the tailstock attached) as this is how this tool combats reaching out far off the tool rest. If you use a faceplate, it has to be removed to core.
McNaughton: If I had to choose only one of the systems, I would take this one. As it is now, I use this one at least 90% of the time. For me it is the fastest to set up and fastest to core with (I will continue to get faster with it, while I doube there will be much more improvement with the other systems), and it can core anything from plates to cone from deep bowls. Sharpening is easy, touchup with diamone hone and/or grind. The biggest drawback is that there is a learning curve. The other systems are on a fixed pivot point so will only go to one spot. With the McNaughton, you have to aim, and hope you hit where you aim. They do have a laser pointer available now, and after trying it out on 50 or so cores, I like it a lot. It hasn't improved my aim, but I can tell exactly how far my aim is off, and correct. I do wish the blades had a bit more curve to them. You also don't have to but the whole set of blades. 99% of the time I am using the small and medium curve blades on the standard and mini sets. Best way to learn how to use this tool is to find someone who knows how, and spend some time with them. I think that McNaughton needs to make a tool rest just for the mini system, and design it for the smaller lathes. The mini cutters work with no problems on a 1 hp lathe (I doubt that any of them will work on a mini lathe), while the other cutters on all 3 systems struggle a bit. Mike Mahoney has a DVD out, and I will have one out by the Portland Symposium. I still like to see things in person and be able to ask questions.
I have no affiliation with any of the companies, these are just my opinions.
>After you pop out a core, reverse/jam chuck it from where it was cut, it'll seat well, save you a step and have good support while you cut a small tenon on the bottom...
I also clean up the bottom as well and refine/fix the shape while I've got it reversed.
>If you have a recess cut or drilled in the top surface, then you don't need to jam chuck the core to turn the bottom, or the tailstock, and it will be already centered.
One other option is to use the McNaughton setup with the knives that curve the opposite way -- that is, they curve toward the left, and cut from headstock end toward the tailstock. That may not make sense, but they make knives that curve both ways. I only have the "normal" or more common knives that curve to the right, but a good friend and professional bowl turner uses "reverse coring" all the time.
I always start a bowl blank (for coring or otherwise) between centers whenever possible to make the best use of the wood. You can either turn a tenon or recess for your favorite chuck/jaws combo., or create a flat area for a faceplate on what will be the TOP (opening) of the bowl. Next turn a tenon at the foot, and the outside profile of the largest bowl, using the tailstock for larger sizes. Now core the largest bowl off the block, and set aside. Clean up the outside and shape the tenon of the next-smaller bowl -- core that one off the blank. Repeat until you have the smallest bowl mounted on your chuck/faceplate, shape the tenon, and reverse to hollow out the inside, removing the screw holes if a face plate was used. Each cored bowl can now be mounted by the tenon to clean up the inside surfaces.
In practice, many lathes won't work very well for "reverse coring", because the headstock can restrict access to the top surface of the bowl blank. The straight handles on the McNaughton knives can also be heated and bent so they won't cause as much interferance with the headstock. If your lathe has enough clearance, this is a very fast way to core large volumes of bowls.