Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Mystery Wood Hollow

Posts

Mystery Wood Hollow

#1

Mystery Wood Hollow

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Here's another little hollow form. About 3.5" tall. I'm not sure what kind of wood this is. I'm thinking cherry, but it didn't smell like cherry at all. It didn't smell familiar at all. I got it from those guys at the Indy Fest who were selling wood in the parking lot. It was a nice hunk of wood though. I have 3 more of these pieces. Textured around the collar with the dulled Dremel engraver tip. I think the neck is too big on this one?

Thanks for looking....

Jen


img

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

#2

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Jen, it looks like madrone burl. One of my favorites.

Nice job!

Wally

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

#3

Excellent Jennifer !!

Ray Carson, New Jersey

>I don't know what kind of wood you got there, but it sure is pretty. Nice work.

Ray

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

#4

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

robo hippy

>I have seen both Apple and Big Leaf Maple in that color range. Apple has a very distinct smell, maple can smell good or sour. Madrone has almost no smell, and can be that color, but I think of it more in the pink, red, purple spectrum. Plus it likes to split when you fire up the chain saw.

robo hippy

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

#5

Thoughts

GaryG in MD

>Jen,

Nice looking piece. Re shape: if they all look alike, classic or not, what's the point? You have expressed yourself and the blank. I don't think the collar overpowers the piece; it's just a little more prominant than "usual", so this is the first of your "larger neck" series. ;-)

It's certainly fine the way it is, but, FWIW, if I had done it, I would probably have made the textured band just a tad (say ~0.25") narrower from the outside edge -- allowing the smooth curvature of the form, moving up toward the neck, to have completed itself just a tiny bit more. Just a random thought. Nice wood; nice shape.

...Gary

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

#6

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

Hooligan

>I don't think that it is too big at all. Really, it works quite well in my eye. It doesn't detract from the form, but compliments it quite nicely.

I've been working on a series, based on late 14th century Japanese ceramic nuptual vessels. They are a little taller neck, sitting on the form almost, creating more of a transition than a gentle curve into the neck. The form remains appealing, because of the coincidence of the two, because of the transition. A clean line, remians a clean line, sometimes we force upon ourselves the idea that a nice form can't have anything to interrupt the curve.

Anyhow...

I like it, a lot.

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

#7

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

Carole Valentine

>I really like this little one, Jen. And I don't think the neck is too big at all. My eye wants to put the lower texture line either closer to the neck (narrower band) or a tad lower on the shoulder (wider band) but I can't decide which...maybe because it's best the way it is! Looks like some kind of burl but can't begin to hazard a guess as to what.

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

#8

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

bowlman

>You're right Jen. You ruined this one with that neck. Just send it to me and I'll fix it up ... and add it to my collection!

Just kidding. It really is loverly ...

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

#9

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

Jim Swank

>When you say "the neck is too big" which part are you talking about? I don't think the hole is too big, although it could be smaller. I do think that the integral collar could be a tad shorter, but the way the grain pattern continues through it buys you some leeway. Now that I've finished criticizng, I only wish I could do have as good!

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

#10

Mike Stafford

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

Mike Stafford

>I cannot be sure but I think it is cherry. I have turned some mineral stained cherry that looked very similar to this wood. Of course I could be wrong...I thought I was wrong once before...but I was mistaken.;-))))

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

#11

Mike Stafford

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

Mike Stafford

>Oops, forgot to mention how lovely the piece is regardless of what the wood is. The wood is almost inconsequential to the form as in time the wood will darken and all that will be left is the good form.

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

#12

Thanks Everybody :)

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Thank you for all the nice comments all. I guess when I say I think the neck is too big...I mean it looks like it's too tall to me....kinda sorta. I also agree with those of you who mention the position of the textured band. Perhaps a bit smaller....or maybe wider coming out over the shoulder.

Thanks for the input everyone :)

Each piece is a learning tool.

Jen

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

#13

Brad Vietje

Looks Great ! No mystery there...

Brad Vietje

>

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

#14

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi Jen,

I love these best with out the colouring, I like the texture and the natural beauty of the wood combined with that lovely form.

take care,

Jim

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

#15

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

Allen Neighbors

>Paint it black, and it'll still be a nice looking piece. However... I like it best like it is, neck and all. The lighter areas of the grain look like cherry to me, and the other looks like some madrone pieces my wife has in the Living Room. Regardless of the wood type, I think it's beautiful. :o)

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

#16

If you can post a pic,...

GaryG in MD

>...I think we would all enjoy seeing an example of the form you are describing verbally. One picture... ;-) ...Gary

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

#17

Re: Sure thing

Hooligan

>Sure. Not a good picture, but one to give an idea. There are five in the series, ranging from 4.5" to 7.5", with the collar dimension staying relative to the size of the vessel. The largest collar is a bit under 1.5".


img

Re: Mystery Wood Hollow

#18

Beautiful!

Chris K in MD

>