Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Honey Locust NE Bowl

Posts

Honey Locust NE Bowl

#1

Honey Locust NE Bowl

Allen Neighbors

>This is out of a chunk of that Honey Locust that Ed Karch identified for us. Had to be really careful to keep the bark on, and my arms out of the ragged spinning edge. It is hard to sand, because the softer parts of the grain sand away, leaving the harder parts a little proud.

It's 14.25" X 11.5" oval, X 5.5" deep. About 1/2" thick for a little heft.

Critiques or comments please.


img

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#2

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl Side view 

Allen Neighbors

>


img

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#3

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl bottom 

Allen Neighbors

>


img

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#4

Leo Van Der Loo

I'll eat my hat if that's honey locust Allen, but

Leo Van Der Loo

>you made a very nice bowl out of that wood, I like the profile too.

I'm here in Atikokan at my oldest son's place, but could you E-mail me at my address, I'll be here for a few more days, before heading home again, if we aren't snowed in over here, sure looks like winter here, all white for several days already and temps below freezing.

Hope to hear from you.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#5

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl Side view

Devon Palmer

>Sharp!

Love the contrast between the sap/heartwood. Locust is my favorite for NE, it holds onto the bark better than anything I've turned (which isn't much)

- Devo

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#6

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

Doug Trembath

>That doesn't look at all like any Honey Locust I've seen. Looks a lot more like Russian Olive, actually. Do the limbs have spines?

The Honey Locust I've seen has wonderful color variations, is heavy and extremely dense, and polishes up with almost no grain differential. Russian Olive is softer, and would lend itself to the soft grain leaving quicker than the Hard, or Summer growth rings, when sanding. The color and texture is what makes me think it's R. Olive.

'Course, I could be full of it, too. Who knows?

Nice bowl, by the way.

Doug Trembath

Studio in the Woods

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

Keith Tompkins

>HI Allen, this is a very nice ne. bowl! My critique, for what it's worth: Looking at the highlights on the inside of the bowl, I don't see any changes in line...a nice,smooth, continuous flow. I also like the flared rim, I think it adds a bit of "attitude".

If I had any suggestions, in the profile view, the form seems to become heavy towards the foot....it appears to flatten out instead of following the curve. On many NE. pieces, the grain itself gives you a guideline to aim towards...this one does as well. If you view the grain pattern, you can see the desired profile.(hope that makes sense) This is a well-executed piece...you should be proud!

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#8

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

Allen Neighbors

>Keith, I didn't notice the heaviness in the bottom until you mentioned it. It sorta sticks out like a sore thumb, doesn't it? :o) And I do see the grain pattern that suggests a better shape. You hit the nail on the head. Well, that good tidbit will have to wait now for the next bowl, because I have no way to remount it to change it now... anyway, the thing would be too thin in the lower portion if I took any off it now.

I really do appreciate the critique. Thanks. :o)

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#9

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

Allen Neighbors

>I know what you mean, Doug. I didn't know what it is, and I posted it a few days ago. I got responses like Red Elm, Red Oak, Honey Locust, Chinaberry, Osage Orange, and some more. Finally I sent a chip of it to Ed, and he put it under the microscope. Came up with Honey Locust.

It does react to sanding a lot like the black locust I've turned.

I've never seen, that I know of, Russian Olive.

Thanks for the comments. :o)

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#10

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl Side view

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks, Devon. The bark stayed on a lot better than I thought it would, but I did have to restick a piece of it. :o)

Take care. :o)

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#11

Re: I'll eat my hat if that's honey locust Allen,

Hooligan

>Agreed Leo. It DOES look like black locust in the picture, but not honey locust.

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#12

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

Molly Winton

>Beautiful bowl Allen, but I have to agree with others that this isn't honey locust. It sure looks like Russian Olive to me. Lovely piece of wood, and you've done it justice.

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#13

Re: I'll eat my hat if that's honey locust Allen,

Allen Neighbors

>Hooligan, I know that it isn't Black Locust. I've used a lot of that, and this is just too red and the grain is different.

JMHO, of course. :o)

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#14

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

Allen Neighbors

>Thank you for the compliment, Molly. I appreciate your opinion. :o)

I'd like to see some Russian Olive from some other turner sometime.

Haven't seen one of your pieces in a while, either...... :o)

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#15

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl Side view

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>Nice job Allen.

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#16

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl Side view

Allen Neighbors

>Thank you, Sir.

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#17

Re: I'll eat my hat if that's honey locust Allen,

Hooligan

>I believe ya, but(there's always a but) it does look a lot like the black locust up here. The same trend towards a deeper brown/red. I will see if I have another piece of it, if not a roughed bowl.

That said, the Honey Locust I generally get in this area is lighter, more a blond with red streaks through it. Not really anything close to what you've got in the picture.

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#18

One thing I didn't say, and I am sorry for NOT...

Hooligan

>Is that regardless of the species it is a well done piece. Gentle, easy flow rim to foot. I like it.

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#19

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

Carole Valentine

>Very nice work, Allen! I agree that it doesn't look like the Honey Locust I've seen but whether it is or isn't is neither here nor there. Since you have put Honey Locust on the bottom, it's going to be Honey Locust to whoever buys it, right? :)

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#20

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

Bob Fawcett

>Nice bowl Allen.

Between the new lathe and bowl gouge(s), you sure have become prolific. Keep up the good work.

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#21

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

Allen Neighbors

>Yep! Honey Locust it is! They'll not care one way or another... unless someone sees it, and says, "Baloney!.. that's not Honey Locust; that's (_____)!" Think of the nice conversation piece it is. :o)

Thanks, Carole.

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#22

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks, Bob. But I'm not nearly as prolific as I'd prefer. I think I'm too slow, and only turn out a couple a day, max. :o(

Maybe one day.....

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#23

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

Carole Valentine

>A couple a day? Heck, I'm lucky if I turn one in two days (not counting finishing)! LOL Now that's slow! Sometimes it's because I will let a piece sit on the lathe overnight before finish turning it just to let it do whatever sort of dance it's going to do, if any.

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#24

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

Bob Fawcett

>For me its a couple a week if I'm lucky. See the thread above about getting better.

I just don't find the time to do as much as many of you do.

Re: Honey Locust NE Bowl

#25

Re: I'll eat my hat if that's honey locust Allen,  *LINK*

Ed Karch

>For all you macro identifiers, the microphotos are on the web. Key it out yourself.

Ed


http://http://www.karch.com/micro.htm