Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

Posts

Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

#1

Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

Marym

>I am a newbie to turning, and I am trying to turn some legs that are 4 1/2" square stock, leaving the ends of the legs as square stock. My question is what is the best way to cut the transition from the square to round shoulder, minimizing the tearout?

I was able to take a parting tool to cut in fairly clean, but how to do I cut a rounded corner at the shoulder without tearing it out, to transition from the turned area to the square end?

I am not sure if I am describing this correctly, so I apologize if I am not. I was thinking that worse case I could make my shoulder cut with the parting tool, and then manually chisel away the square shoulder corners to give the transition to the turned area if I had to.

I appreciate any help or advice on this that anyone can provide!

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

#2

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

Hooligan

>Skew chisel.

Cut in with the toe dwon, and round the edge.

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

#3

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

Tony Reynolds somewhere near Newark, Ohio

>It's called a pommel (sp) cut and best done with a skew as Hooligan already pointed out. If you're not already handy with a skew, you may want to try it a few times on some scrap before trying it on your good stock, At least that's been my experience :)

Tony

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

Keith Tompkins

>HI Mary, If you are intimidated by the skew....and who isn't....try this. The cut is nearly as clean as the skew chisel, but far easier to do..my sketch shows cutting from a round surface, but the technique is the same.

With a bit of practice, it becomes easy to do. Start practicing the skew every time you turn, soon you will master that tool as well.


img

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

#5

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

john lucas

>I also prefer the skew, toe down like the others but there isn't any reason it can't be done with a spindle gouge. The best way to do it is to sneak up on it. Start about an inch away and try the cut. You need to be cutting from the square corner down so you are cutting down hill on the grain. Start the cut very carefully and then move the tool down while watching the backside of the wood to see the shape. then do this again. After 4 or 5 cuts you'll be getting the hang of it and you can get closer to the line.

In reality I turn most of the shape with a spindle roughing gouge. I start the leg with the roughing gouge always working from the non square end. I start about 3 inches from the end and move toward the small end. Then I back up another 3 inches and take off some of that and some more of the small end. Back up another 3 etc. Each time I'm getting the piece closer to the round and to the largest diameter. I stop when I get close to the bottom diameter of the pommel.

Then I take the toe of the skew and by making V cuts I'll go down to the depth I need. Then I take the skew with the the heel down and start rounding the pommel. If the wood is soft I'll finish the pommel curve this way. If it's really hard wood I will usually turn the skew over and finish the cut with the toe.

Some days I'm just nervous and will take the spindle gouge out instead. Usually this is when I haven't been turning a lot and the customer only gave me enough wood to do the job. I know I can do it without screwing up with the spindle gouge. I'm pretty good with the skew but you do need to stay in practice.

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

#6

Re: This cut could also be easily....

Jamie Donaldson

>...made with a side ground bowl gouge. Might be the best tool for a beginning turner.

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

#7

And at the risk of

Don Henthorn

>thunderous opposition I would suggest if you do little turning you might try a 1/2" round nose scraping tool. Go gingerly and when you get close to the size you want and there is too much tear out sand down to the final size and then sand for finish. (Don - Ducking and running.)

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

#8

Another Way

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi Marym,

I remember the first time I tried to make this cut, I was in a Shaker Table class with Christian Becksvoort. I was getting ready to make the cut with a skew, practiced the motion to make the pomell cut and then Chris walks up, says lets's get on with this, he takes the skew from my hand, lays it flat on it's side on the tool rest then pushed the point of the skew into the leg at a 45 degree angle through the spot I wanted the transition.

Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

I was suprised and amazed it ws so clean and left me the shape I wanted.

Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

Hope that helped,

take care,

Jim

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

#9

I agree with Jamie..........

Ruth Niles

>A bowl gouge is just a bit easier to use than the spindle gouge because of the deeper flute, it gives you more bevel allowance before the cutting edge slices the wood.

I've done spindle turning a LOT (actually supported myself with it for years) and I do personally prefer the skew, point down just as everyone suggested. If you want to learn to be more comfortable with the skew, use it. If you're hesitant, use the bowl gouge.

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

#10

A 3/8' Bowl Gouge is.....

Nick Stagg

>the easiest of all methods. With a skew it takes so many cuts before you get there!! The secret with the bowl gouge is to make a clearance cut ahead of the line and then float the gouge in WITHOUT tool rest contact of your hands, i.e. both of your hands are on the gouge and not touching the tool reat. At the end of the cut pivot the gouge tip in to the work. Any sideways pressure will cause the gouge to bounce; start with the handle low and pivot it into the cut Try it on a some scrap wood and you'll find it to be a very efficient cut.

Nick

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

#11

Re: Another Way

john lucas

>I agree. A skew works better than most scrapers when it's used as a scraper. That's why I want to play with the negative rake scraper that's been discussed here. Still it's very easy to chip out the top corner any time you use a scraper. I find the best method is to rough out the shape and then go back and fine tune with the scraper if necessary. There's less chance of tearout when you only remove a little material with a scraper.

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

#12

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

Marym

>Thanks for all the replies....when I tried a gouge initially, it just tore the corners out too quick on me. I think I will try the skew chisel.

With the skew chisel, should I lay the tool on its flat against the rest, or turn it on its edge against the rest? Everyone here who prefers the skew agrees on the point in first, which makes sense to me, but which way the tool should be set on the rest is still a question in my mind.

Also, when I first start the cut, should I make a narrow cut like I tried the first time, then turn away the round section, and go back to knock of the corners of the square ends. Or do I first work the corners off the square ends while there is material there before turning the adjacent material into a cylinder?

Thanks again all, I really appreciate it!

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

#13

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi Marym,

Send me an email, I can foward you a file I will make that will help.

Thanks,

Take care,

Jim

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

#14

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

RussFairfield

>A couple wraps of glass reinforced tape around the square at the transition will help prevent tear-out.

Masking tape also works, but the glass fibers support the wood while being clear enough that you can see what you are doing.

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

#15

Welcome back Russ

Rick Allen

>Welcome back Russ. It has been a while since I last noticed you on the forum. I have missed you. I hope to see a lot more of you.

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

#16

Re: Welcome back Russ

RussFairfield

>I am only here for today. We are still travelling, and in St. Louis. Next stop is Bakersfield, CA next weekend.

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

#17

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

Bob Fawcett

>There is a lot of good info above. I'll just add here is a link to a video showing the cut done with a skew.

http://www.hiltonhandcraft.com/images/Video/Pommel%20with%20a%20Skew.avi

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

#18

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Mary

If I might add to the info that you already have - I teach this on a regular basis. You want the skew laid on its edge, long point down. Angle the tool so that the edge on the side of the wood which you want to remain square is angled so that it is perpendicular to the long axis of the wood. Pivot the tool to make a slight cut, and then remove the waste on the side which will become round. Repeat until you get to the depth you want. You need to keep removing the waste on the round side, or it will push the tool into the square part and splinter those nice crisp edges. I posted a pictorial tutorial on this a while ago, but never got it onto my website. I will have to see if I can find it and repost it for you.

Bill

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

#19

Re: Cutting square to round shoulder cut?

Marym

>Thanks again everyone, and thanks for the video clip Bob, it is nice to see it done right in front of you!