Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Don't know if it's cheating, but....

Posts

Don't know if it's cheating, but....

#1

Don't know if it's cheating, but....

KurtK in Indy

>I just got my new monster tool hollowing system unpacked and started using it a little tonight with the laser arm.....man is that fun and really cool. I don't know what y'all think...is it the easy way out or (in my opinion) a time saving way to do a great job of hollowing? I haven't completed my first HF with it, but all indications are that I'm going to really enjoy using it and won't lose nearly as many pieces to the dreaded "bust through" I've encountered in the past.

I'm working a nice piece of cedar now and will post a pic when I get it done. Just thought I'd bring up the question. Thanks for any replies.

Kurt

Re: Don't know if it's cheating, but....

#2

Re: Don't know if it's cheating, but....

Arch

>Kurt, I hope it not too late. Next you'll slip into using a motorized lathe with a revolving tail center and a scroll chuck. then there's no turning back. That sort of cheating can lead to turning non-functional forms and in your final degradation as a turner you, heaven forbid, might even turn to 'gasp'...Art! As you can see, I keep a fair and open mind, but this sort of thing has happened.

Anyway, My name is Arch and I am a cheater so I'll give you the address, off WC, where you should send that awful device for proper disposal.

Re: Don't know if it's cheating, but....

#3

I agree, Arch

Ruth Niles

>Now I am going to confess that once I did think all these devices were cheating. Cheating yourself of fine tuning a technique or learning to master a tool. I had felt it might be cheating yourself of the feeling that you created it with your own hands.

Then I got a slow cooker, bought the packages of complete meals in a bag and enjoyed some good "home cooking". I used to cook really good, even made cakes from scratch. Am I now "cheating"? Food tastes wonderful, I'm getting nurished and not burning pot bottoms.

So, you're getting a great turning, you're not going through the bottom (hopefully!) and you're having fun. Besides a home-cooked meal, what more could a man ask for? : )

Re: Don't know if it's cheating, but....

#4

It's not

Mike Cunningham (Cape May NJ

>I agree, learn how to do it the "hard way", then use the tools that allow you to complete your work as quickly and easily as possible. I learned how to handcut dovetails but when faced with a very large project some years ago, I purchased and used a dovetail machine. If they'd had electricity and powertools in 1700 Williamsburg Va., they'd have been put to use.

Re: Don't know if it's cheating, but....

#5

I Know

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi Ruth,

I�m right there with you too. First time I saw that type of rig I thought well there was little skill required and that it was not really a turning skill. Well I believe I am wrong now too. Flat workers sort of get into it when discussing hand cut dove tails verses machine cut dove tails, the results are different but ultimately the wood doesn�t care how it was transformed, it�s how it looks in the end.

I think with many things in wood the result is the answer, anything that adds or allows the esthetics of hand work to prevail in the final form is where I place my values.

Now Ruth, are you a Frozen Box and Microwave type of gal or stove top?

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: Don't know if it's cheating, but....

#6

Re: It's not

Don in Central Illinis

>I agree with Mike. While I do not have any laser guided tools (yet) I may go that way sometime. I believe that one needs a basic understanding of what is happening and why. Then use whatever you cana to either speed the process or get it more precise. Same way with automatic everything cameras. You need a basic understanding of f stops and aperture settings first. Make sure you post a picture.

Re: Don't know if it's cheating, but....

#7

Neither, Jim

Ruth Niles

>Since moving, I don't have a stove, microwave, toaster oven or even a toaster yet. I've been eating cold since Sept. 2, except for when I'm at shows. The kitchen needed complete painting, inside cabinets, everything and I'm not putting one thing in it until it's done.

Re: Don't know if it's cheating, but....

#8

Re: Don't know if it's cheating, but....

john lucas

>When I first built my hollowing rig the first thing I did was to turn a vessel with my old arm brace. Then I used the boring bar. What a difference. No white knuckles ( I don't do a lot of hollowing on larger work so I'm not very proficient or comfortable). The boring bare limits what you can do so it's a good idea to learn to use the hand hollowing methods. I do both now but when I'm working with an expensive piece of wood and the shape will allow it, I use the hollowing rig. it's just too darn easy.

cheating, I use a scope on my rifle (can't see without it), I use a oneway sharpening jig most of the time even though I'm pretty good at hand sharpening, I can't cook even with the book so I like Ruth's idea of the slow cooker. I though slow cook was what someone called me.

Re: Don't know if it's cheating, but....

#9

Re: Don't know if it's cheating, but....

Don in Central Illinis

>Was that slow cook or slow kook? Just kidding.

Re: Don't know if it's cheating, but....

#10

Re: Don't know if it's cheating, but....

Randy Privett

>Glad your having fun with it Kurt.

Re: Don't know if it's cheating, but....

#11

WOW Ruth

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>I guess the hunger to complete that kitchen will be the feast in it self at the end of that Rainbow.

Wish I could help.

take care,

Jim

Re: Don't know if it's cheating, but....

#12

Yes of course it's cheating!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>You don't want that on your conscious...so in order to alleviate that burden...you can send me the Monster. At least I'll know not to blab that I'm cheating!

;)

Signed,

Jealous

Re: Don't know if it's cheating, but....

#13

Steven Antonucci

OT:Funny how slow cookers work, huh?

steve antonucci

>Throw everything you got into a pot, and cook it forever, and it comes out tasting good. Go figure.

Steve

Re: Don't know if it's cheating, but....

#14

Is it cheating to have fun?

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>

Re: Don't know if it's cheating, but....

#15

Dick Hines

Re: Don't know if it's cheating, but....

Dick Hines

>Richard Petty once said" if you ain't cheating you ain't raceing." I don't call a hollowing rig cheating I call it a better tool. Your pieces will get better and you will not be as tired at the end of a turning session.

People can call it cheating if they want but I will just keep using mine.

Re: Don't know if it's cheating, but....

#16

Thanks all...my conscious is now clear!

KurtK in Indy

>And I'm having a great time turning!! You know, Jen asked me a few weeks ago if I was doing any turning and I told her I was spending so much more time tracking down wood and trying to get rid of all that I come up with that I hadn't really had much time to actually do the thing I enjoy the most. With this new rig, like anything else that's new...I feel re-inspired to go into the basement and "just do it".

Thanks Jen for the kick in the pants! And you can use it anytime you want....