Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

Posts

Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

#1

Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

wilbur

>I've taken my second try at woodturning and now I'm on a mission to get a lathe for myself. I'm looking at mini lathes to start off with. In looking through the various models out there, it seems that most mini lathes have a 10" swing. The new Rikon mini lathe has a 12" swing, and General makes a mini lathe that also has a 12" swing and has a pivoting headstock for outboard turning. I emailed Nova about their Mercury mini lathe, which also has outboard capacity, and it appears that it's being reintroduced to the US market.

In looking at the pictures of these larger capacity mini lathes, even though they can handle a bigger piece of wood, the overall size of the lathe is still pretty much the same. It doesn't look like much was added to the lathe for stability.

My question is, for these mini lathes that have a greater capacity than the usual 10" swing, how practical is it to turn a larger chunk of wood, considering that the base is still going to be relatively small?

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

#2

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

Allen Neighbors

>Wilbur, just thinking about your question, and how I would answer it, I thought about my first lathe, a Craftsman 12" swing, tubular bed lathe. Though it had a 12" swing, the spindle of the headstock wasn't as strong as it needed to be. I put a large chunk of Mesquite on it, and ended up bending the spindle. So my answer to your question is that the Lathe is only as strong as the Headstock Spindle. The base can be strengthened by bolting it down to a well-built stand, but the spindle determines the weight of the wood that can be turned. And the tailstock shaft (quill) ranks second to that.

Hope this helps you in your quest.

Allen

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

#3

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

Bob Fawcett

>I agree with Allen.

You might also consider what you want to turn. You can get a bed extension for most of the minis and be able to turn good size spindles. I have turned bedposts on my mini with a bed extension. They are about 3 1/4" max diameter and 36" long sections. That seemed to be close to the limit to me.

There was a thread recently about what lathes people own. Almost everyone who bought a Jet mini as a starter, still had it. They are great within their limits and even after upgrading, most people find them usefull. They also travel well. Great place to start and learn.

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

#4

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

georgetroy

>In my opinion, a Mini lathe is just that. Limited capacity, low speed does not go low enough and rests are small from the factory. They send a 6" cast iron tool rest in some cases. I think a mini lathe is only one to throw in the back of a truck for small demos. Yes I do have one,a Vicmarc mini lathe, but use it very little. You might consider a Nova DVR XP with a 16" swing and the ability to bench mount or stand mount. Oh yes, once you get a small lathe you are always looking for one of larger capacity. You still get what you pay for. GT

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

#5

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

Bill Howatt

>The real answer lies in an analysis of the spindle size, heat treatment if any, bearings, castings,.... you get the idea.

The spindle size as far as threads and Morse taper go are on par with larger lathes (1x8). However, the castings tend to be smaller and the lathe weight and footprint tends to be small in comparison.

If I had one and was working with a maximum size blank, I would take care in getting it rounded and somewhat balanced before mounting it on the lathe. The force on the spindle created by a spinning out of balance blank are much, much more than spinning a balanced blank of the same weight. Keeping the speed down is imperative as well. Are these electronically variable speed machines?

I think a nice advantage of the 12" swing would be allowing the banjo or an accessory to move under a 10" blank if necessary.

Remember there is more to a big lathe than just a big swing size.

Bill

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

#6

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I own a Jet mini and have thought about exactly what you are asking. I have successfully turned a 9 3/4" diameter bowl on my mini, but I started it between centers. That is the only way the spindle can handle that kind of weight. There is just too much downward force on it otherwise.

keithz

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

#7

Re: The 2 features you mention ...

Jamie Donaldson

>.....that promote the swing and head swivel of some lathes are often not accurate and even dangerous. The stated swing capacity never includes the height of the banjo, and every turner has encountered the problem of trying to position the tool rest under the wood blank.The swivel head eliminates the safe use of both tailstock and secure tool rest support, encouraging the often inexperienced turner to take extra needless risks.

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

#8

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe? *LINK*

Vincent Welch

>Wilbur,

I beleive that if you are going to try to turn a peice that has some size and weight to it with a mini lathe you are going to struggle. The motor is not going to have the torque to keep the peice spinning, hard on bearings, etc. It is that simple! I have found that mini lathes are great for small turning with less heavy wood. I own a Jet mini and I think most will aggree these lathes are workhorses and last for years. But if you know from the start what you really want to turn is something more and you will not be satisfied with the a mini I suggest to wait and get the right lathe rather then trying to get more out a mini then it is safe too. Safety is a big factor and when we push our luck sometimes bads things can happen as a result. Just a thought. Vince


http://www.Vinceswoodnwonders.com

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

#9

JL

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

JL

>I was impressed with the new General Mini Lathe. That being said, I also like the Jet Mini lathes (with or without variable speed. It all depends on what your final use is going to be. If you want a small lathe for throwing in the back of the car and going places - minis are nice. They'll do small bowls and small spindles. They'll take a small chuck - but not a Stronghold.

I think the new General is impressive and will take some more weight than the others. But any larger lathe like the Nova will have more capacity.

Is there any way for you to "test-drive" a few? Do you have the time to take a class? I turned on a few lathes which helped me make my final decision.

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

#10

George is right. Mini is a mini.

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

#11

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

Ed Karch

>I have two Jet Minis and a PM3520a. The capacity of a 10" mini is about 9 1/2" which is a decent sized bowl. I have extensions on both minis and often use all three lathes setup for different steps in a production process and move a piece from lathe to lathe..

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

#12

Re: The 2 features you mention ...

john lucas

>Also when you swing the headstock the tool rest no longer reaches everything easily so you end up buying or making a tool rest that's longer. Then you get vibration problems. The motors that come with mini lathes won't handle pieces larger than 10" unless you take extremely small cuts. I don't usually turn bowls over 8" on the minis because it's just to slow and the lathe bounces too much when the wood is out of balance.

I own 4 mini lathes right now and have turned lots of stuff on them. I love the minis but you need to keep within thier bounds to really enjoy them. Larger work just isn't fun.

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

#13

Thanks -- going to save my pennies

wilbur

>Thanks for all the replies! Just from my two experiences so far, I think I'm most interested in doing larger bowl turning. The platter I turned this weekend I measured at 8 1/2" in diameter, and I turned that on a Jet mini lathe. While I was working on it, I kept wishing that it was bigger. From your collective advice, this means I'll have to get a bigger lathe -- something that can at least handle 14".

So now it's time to save some pennies.

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

#14

Re: Thanks -- going to save my pennies

Allen Neighbors

>Save for a Oneway 1640, and add the 17" bed extension and 2436 Banjo to your order; mount it on the outboard end, and your can turn up to 16" inboard, and 24" outboard. You'll never need another Lathe. (I'm grinning all the time, since I got mine)

Just my suggestion.

Allen

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

#15

Going to save a LOT of pennies

wilbur

>Whew! By my calculations, your Oneway setup goes for $4135-4355, depending on which motor you get.

Just for grins, I tried to see how much a Nova DVR-XP with a bed extension, stand, and outrigger unit went for. That comes in at $2812. That's $1300-1500 less.

Can I ask why you went with a Oneway?

Re: Practical maximum capacity of a mini lathe?

#16

Re: Bill Crommet told me to. :o)

Allen Neighbors

>Actually, after checking everything about many lathes, including, but surely not limited to prices, I was bouncing back and forth between the Oneway 1640 and Powermatic 3520. And Bill Crommet told me to sell my firstborn, and get the Oneway... that I could use it to make enough bowls to buy my firstborn back. :o) So I did. I've already bought him back. LOL

Truly, though, I liked the fit and finish, and Service after the sale, better on the Oneway. So I bought it. I've never regretted it. :o)

Best to you,

Allen