Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

Posts

Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#1

Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

TDaniel

>Recently we discussed designs and whether or not classical forms can win at art shows against the highly adorned pieces. All we see in the AAW mag is the ultra adorned pieces and we are led to think that that is what is hot and collectible. For those who need inspiration for continuing to turn the pure turnings, relying on turning skills rather than enhancements I am very pleased to announce that my pure turning, natural edge hollow form, has just won "Best of Show" at the Bascom-Louise Art Gallery in Highlands, NC. This show included all art forms and I am humbled to learn that my piece was chosen as best of show. My piece was made from big leaf maple burl and I relied totally on the art that was in the wood rather than what I could add. Folks, turn what you think is pretty and ignore what the mags try to say is what is "in". There are pieces of wood out there that have much more art in them than we could ever create.

TD

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#2

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

Tony Reynolds somewhere near Newark, Ohio

>Way to go Terry!! Would love to see a photo of the piece.

Tony

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#3

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

Hooligan

>Wicked good!

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#4

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

John Leonard

>Terry, thats great. I believed that to be true but this helps to reinforce it. John L.

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#5

Congratulations and point well said.

Bill Stehman

>

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#6

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

gary s clarke

>congratulations, I would like to see a picture. I heard on public radio a talk about art and it was said that just because something is in an art museum doesn't mean it is art. The example he gave was because a shoe is in the museum it might be on his foot and not art.

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#7

Leo Van Der Loo

Congratulations Terry, Yes what's "IN", buy a

Leo Van Der Loo

>Pet rock lately, or a coppertone stove, big finned car ??

The shape and dimensions we give the wood, can use some help sometimes, but in my way of looking at it, good form and balance has to be there first.

I was wondering who was doing the judging ??

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#8

Re: Congratulations Terry, Yes what's "IN", buy a

Ed Karch

>Way to go TD

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#9

pic, and thanks all 

TDaniel

>


img

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#10

whups, too big, pic 2 

TDaniel

>


img

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#11

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

gil jones

>Bravo for you, Terry!!

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#12

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

Lan Brady

>Great job TD.

They recognize quality in any form!

Lan

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#13

Barb Siddiqui

Congratulations, Terry!

Barb Siddiqui

>

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#14

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

George Van

>I can see why this is "Best of Show". Congratulations Terry

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#15

Ed, Gil, Lan........

TDaniel

>this is the vessel that you saw at the Gathering in April. It needs a name I am told. Any suggestions? I call it "Found Art" since the art was in the wood. The show opens today with the artists' reception this evening. Meet me in Highlands and I'll buy everyone a burger; my checkbook has a good balance in it now. :)

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#16

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

Ron in Drums PA

>Congratulations TD

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#17

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

OB O'Brien

>Congratulations TD. Yes I remember seeing that one and the other one with all the little faces in it. Both are exceptional. Keep it up. OB

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#18

Congratulations My Friend!! 8)

RevDoug

>I've loved this piece from the beginning. It has beautiful shape and wonderful design. The finish is indeed imaculate and feels so good in the hand. I've been watching this long running discussion for a long time and am coming out of the closet to say that I have to agree with you. There is art in the wood itself and we are the fortunate ones to be allowed to release it.

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#19

Barb Siddiqui

How about

Barb Siddiqui

>calling it 'Caldera?'

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#20

Re: How about

Ed Karch

>Great name Barb

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#21

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

Allen Neighbors

>Terry, I loved that piece! Only now, after seeing it anew, do I reallize how much I missed it when I tried to copy it. :o) It's gorgeous. Congratulations!

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#22

Re: How about

Lan Brady

>That sounds good to me too.

I remember seeing this for the first time. As I walked up, seeing only the side, I though what a nice big natural edge bowl. Then I saw inside and WOW!!!!. It was a great surprise!

Lan

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#23

Re: TD- I realize you have your own ....

Jamie Donaldson

>.....agenda against the AAW from some of your statements, and how you define this design as traditional and unadorned defies logic! Congratulations on a very nice piece of turning and the award, but purple dyed wood is neither traditional nor unadorned, and the natural edge vessel and traditional are not synoymous.

Re: Follow up, classical vs radical new forms

#24

no Agenda

TDaniel

>I just want to vent my feelings that turners who just turn and don't embellish are not getting recognized when they do some very nice work that may be termed traditional. I look at what is pictured in a mag that is supposed to represent all turners and I see primarily items that are extreme and way out from the ordinary. Now let me say that some of that is ok and proper; however, the majority of turners want to see some items that are more common and within their skill range. I just got back from the artists' reception at the gallery and I had a lengthy conversation with the judge after the reception was over. I cannot tell you what the discussion centered on because you would also take that as bashing but I was listening, not talking. I suggest that the AAW do a reader poll and see what their members want. I think they will find a big gap between what the members want and what the top brass wants. These are my thoughts, others may feel free to disagree.