Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Air Drill or ROS???

Posts

Air Drill or ROS???

#1

Air Drill or ROS???

MFoster

>I have about killed my Sioux Drill. Already replaced the bearings, but the old beast is just not the same. Squeals and whines and the reversing switch has always been problematic (replaced it once too).

I have air at my lathe from a 2 1/2 HP compressor (in my mind compressed air is an essential turning tool) and am considering switching to an air powered drill. Anyone have any opinions on the Grex drill or the Grex ROS?? I'm thinking the drill may be more versatile than the ROS, but not having tried either, am unsure. All opinions welcome.

Re: Air Drill or ROS???

#2

Re: Air Drill or ROS???

Sean Troy

>I don't think that compressor can put out enough air as fast as an air sander uses it.

Re: Air Drill or ROS???

#3

Re: Air Drill or ROS???

Stuart Johnson

>I have a GREX ROS and think it is great. I don't know if your compressor will handle the amount of air used. Mine is 5 hp with a 26 gallon tank and it will cause my compressor to kick on after a couple minutes. I just use it like a passive sander until it cycles.

Re: Air Drill or ROS???

#4

Re: Air Drill or ROS???

Russ Babbitt Jr.

>I purchased the Grex but went back to my Souix because it can be reversed. The Grex cannot. I do like the quality of the Grex tools.

Re: Air Drill or ROS???

#5

Re: Air Drill or ROS???

Anthony Y

>I think the best answer is you need both. I use an electric drill for the heavy grits and the Grex ros for finishing. The Grex doesn't seem to like the heavy grits.

Re: Air Drill or ROS???

#6

Re: Air Drill or ROS???

MFoster

>I was just out in the shop finishing a triangular (multi-axis) Drozda box. I attended her demo on it at the Totally Turning symposium and had to try it out. It was fun. Anyway, I checked my compressor, and it is a 6 HP, 25 Gal Oil variety. I didn't know the

Grex was not reversible, and that definitely is a limitation.

Re: Air Drill or ROS???

#7

Re: Air Drill or ROS???

eliot d

>I use both. I have a modest Porter Cable compressor, which does cycle a lot when I sand with the GREX. But I get by and get a fine finish. For the electric drill, in addition to a Milwaukee, believe it or not, I'm a fan of the really cheap HF close quarter drill ($29.95). It works just like the Milwaukee, and I haven't had any trouble with it. If it fails, I'll just buy another one. (Something I always do, by the way, is to blow out the electric drills with compressed air every time I use a sandpaper grit. I think it helps keep them going.)

Re: Air Drill or ROS???

#8

Re: Air Drill or ROS???

robo hippy

>I was surprised to find that my Sioux drills have 6 bearings in them, 3 sizes, and 4 different bearings. I get about 6 months out of one before it needs to be rebuilt. I have a Sioux pneumatic angle drill, and got about 4 months out of it. I have a 5 hp 60 gallon compressor, and with the air drill, it runs constantly, so the extra cost of the drill, and the extra electricity isn't really worth it to me. I haven't tried one of the Grex sanders, but probably will get one, just to see how long it lasts. I did get one of the $30 drills, and it lasted about a month before the casing wore out.

I am having 2 drills rebuilt now. I have a friend who works at Kaman Bearing, and he called an engineer to check out the Koyo bearing that has been recomended here. The engineer recomended some other bearings that he said were better. I will attempt to destroy them asap, and report. All said and done, I haven't seen anything better than the Sioux. A ROS just isn't as agressive as the drill.

robo hippy

Re: Air Drill or ROS???

#9

Re: Air Drill or ROS???

OB O'Brien

>I've tried all of them. I use a cheap ($26.00) Ace hardware 3/8 variable speed, reversable drill for sanding the goarser grits. Then switch over to the Grex ROS. With the Grex ROS you dont need the reversable feature. I use the Blue PSA discs and this combination is quick and effective. I tried the Metabo electric ROS and found it was heavy, cumbersome and wouldn't let you get the inside of bowls very good. I recommend the Grex ROS. Good luck in your choice. OB

Re: Air Drill or ROS???

#10

Re: Air Drill or ROS???

MFoster

>Thanks for all the input. Think I'll get a ROS as an addition to what I have.