Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Mystery wood?

Posts

Mystery wood?

#1

Mystery wood?

Allen Neighbors

>My son drove in late last night from Oklahoma City, dropped off this log. He said this was just a limb from one of the trees that they had to remove to install an electric highline. About 16" diameter, 4.5 feet long.

I blanked it out this morning, and got 4 large bowl blanks and blanks for a couple of hollowforms.

The photo color is pretty true. Any guesses as to what kind of timber it is?


img

Re: Mystery wood?

#2

Re: Mystery wood?

Sean Troy

>Looks like Cherry

Re: Mystery wood?

#3

Leo Van Der Loo

The way the bark looks, and the combination of

Leo Van Der Loo

>of the light sapwood and the color of the heart wood, I would also like Sean suggest say Cherry, get er done quick Allen, to keep that nice light sapwood from discoloring and the wood from splitting.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Mystery wood?

#4

Re: Sean and Leo, I forgot to say

Allen Neighbors

>that he told me the trunk of this tree was between 4 and 5 feet in diameter. This tree grew in the vicinity of Oklahoma City. I never knew Cherry trees could get that large. How about it?

Re: Mystery wood?

#5

Ellis Walentine

Hmm...

Ellis Walentine

>...to me, the bark looks more like ash. I'd guess swamp ash, otherwise known as black ash. Fender used to make their guitar bodies out of it. Lovely stuff to turn.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Mystery wood?

#6

Re: Sean and Leo, I forgot to say

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Cherry trees can get really large.

Re: Mystery wood?

#7

Re: Sean and Leo, I forgot to say

David Breth

>Believe me, I'm no expert, but that bark doesn't really look like Cherry to me.

Re: Mystery wood?

#8

Re: Mystery wood?

robo hippy

>If it is cherry, you will smell it right away. They can get that big, especially if they are urban, and get a lot of care, water and fertilizer. The bark doesn't quite look like cherrey to me either. A few leaves would help. Does it have any particular smell?

robo hippy

Re: Mystery wood?

#9

I agree David, not cherry

John Lucas

>

Re: Mystery wood?

#10

Definitely not cherry

TDaniel

>

Re: Mystery wood?

#11

Re: Mystery wood?

Ed Karch

>Allen get a fresh cut on the end grain with a razor and take a closeup for the best ID view for wood or get some leaves for tree ID. Logs on the ground are just guesses.

Re: Mystery wood?

#12

Don Pencil

Re: Mystery wood?

Don Pencil

>Possibly one of the acacias?

Re: Mystery wood?

#13

Re: Mystery wood?

adrien

>send a piece to:

Center for Wood Anatomy Research

USDA Forest Service, Forest Products Laboratory

One Gifford Pinchot Dr.

Madison, WI 53726-2398

or go to:

http://www2.fpl.fs.fed.us/

Re: Mystery wood?

#14

Re: Mystery wood?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Allen,

Can you post a close-up of the end-grain and the side grain? Might be easier to make a determination. I think it could be some more of your red elm, but I would want a little closer examination of the wood to be sure.

Gary

Re: Mystery wood?

#15

Re: Mystery wood?

ben d.

>Well my 2 cents worth too. I just sawed up some of the same looking wood a couple weeks ago. I believe it is Cottonwood because it hs a very thick rough bark white sap wood and a reddish heartwood. Turned a bowl about 10" left at 1" or so thick and dried in microwave and it bowed to the point when I returned it it was about 1/8" thick and it is a grayish sort of color and looks pretty good to me. Did leave just a bit of sap wood on so it has a couple little white spots on 2 sides. Where I got this from the heep there also was a log that was at least 5' in diameter also. So my bet it is Cottonwood.

I haven turned another piece since that one sprayed so much water I am going to let it sit awhile before I turn another piece.

Re: Mystery wood?

#16

Leo Van Der Loo

Allen I have seen some very large Black Cherry

Leo Van Der Loo

>trees, at a friend of mine there is a cherry tree behind his house that's at least 3 feet across at chest hight, and it's all very light sandy soil there (tobacco country) but 5 feet across is indeed humongous for any kind of tree I would say.

I just made a pic. of a black cherry half log blank that has been in my shop for longer than 1 year, haven't got to turn it yet, anyway you can have a look, and see if your bark resembles this one.

Your pic. is not very good I'm afraid, and so it's still my best guess as what it can be, cherry has a flat topped ridged bark, not very high as it likes to blather off, also how did the wood smell when you cut it, cherry has a distinctive smell, reminds me of almonds.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo


img

Re: Mystery wood?

#17

Re: Mystery wood?

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks, everyone, for your responses to this post. I'll try to get a better pic of the grain and bark tomorrow. It'll be late, though, because I have to drive my Son back to Amarillo for the last bit of surgery on his jaw tomorrow. I'll try to get it posted by dark-thirty. :o) I really do appreciate your posts.

Allen

Re: Mystery wood?

#18

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Hmm...

Leo Van Der Loo

>Hi Ellis

Black Ash (swamp ash etc) is a cool climate, and the most northerly growing Ash, I would not expect to find it growing as far south as Oklahoma, but never say never.

And yes I like turning black Ash also, one just has to watch out for the ring shake, which is very common in black Ash, probably one reason it was used so much for making baskets out of it, easy to separate the wood at the year rings.

Here's a pic. of one very large Black Ash burl.

That would make one heck of a hollow form I think.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo


img

Re: Mystery wood?

#19

Re: Mystery wood?

Ray Binnicker

>It looks a lot like some Black Locust I had sawed a few years back.

Re: Mystery wood?

#20

Re: Mystery wood?

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Looks like Willow to me, the sapwood is way too white for Cherry.

When folks post these "mystery wood" questions, you should say how hard the wood is. Willow and Cottonwood are soft, light, and easy to turn compared to Ash, Cherry, or Elm.

Try the hatchet test--does it sink into the heartwood fairly easily, or just leave a small nick and bounce off? Or even better, turn a bowl or something with it, and report how easy or hard the turning is.

Re: Mystery wood?

#21

Re: Mystery wood?

Danny Wells

>How about Chinaberry? The wood is orange colored with a kind of light to dark variation in the heartwood. Also has a very white sap wood. Growing in Oklahoma it would tend to be slower growing than in the deep South and would be more dense. The bark looks similar as well. Just guessing since the pics are really not close enough.

Re: Mystery wood?

#22

Looks Like....

W.C. Turner

>Sasafras to me. But, again, the odor would give it away, un-mistakeable.

Allen, does the wood have an odor to it?

W.C.

Re: Mystery wood?

#23

I agree

TDaniel

>It does look like Chinaberry. Chinaberry is fairly light in weight.

Re: Mystery wood?

#24

Re: Mystery wood?

Ben Aragon

>It might be Mulberry. The bark doesn�t look quite like mulberry though. If it smells like a wet dog when you cut it could be.

Ben