Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Scraper Sharpening Angle?

Posts

Scraper Sharpening Angle?

#1

Scraper Sharpening Angle?

George Van

>I am curious about the best angle for sharpening a scraper or spearpoint scraper. I have a note on my clip board that Stuart Batty recommends 70 degrees, is this the best angle to start with? I am assuming he is stating 20 degrees off vertical. Does the angle effect the size/strength/sharpness of the burr?

I will be using these on birch, maple, and cherry which I do not consider extremely hard woods. I understand ebony, blackwood, and others are "hard" woods and sometimes brittle and require different angles. I assume I will want to use the tool with the burr from the grinder without removal or honing for the woods I am using.

Thanks, any clarification will help as I have been avoiding using a scraper but realize there are times they can be helpful if not necessary.

Re: Scraper Sharpening Angle?

#2

Re: Scraper Sharpening Angle?

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>George, I don't think there is any "best" angle, it depends on the situation. A 70 degree angle will give a stronger, longer lasting edge--but for turning inside bottoms of boxes, for example, the bevel may get in the way. A 45 degree angle will cut aggressively, but have a weak edge and be more likely to catch. If there was a good scraper angle that worked for the majority of the turning I do, I'd say it would be about 60 degrees. That's the included angle between the bevel and the top face, and probably the happiest comprimise between the two extremes.

Re: Scraper Sharpening Angle?

#3

Re: Scraper Sharpening Angle?

Vincent Welch

>Hi George,

I could not tell you what angle my scrapers are sharpened at and I am sure they are sharpened differently or at slightly different angles. I simply tend to sharpen the tool so I may get it to cut the way I want it too. Sometimes I have to change the grind a bit and sometimes I just touch up the edge and put a burr on it. The way I see it is that it is O.K. because it is just a tool. I like to experment a bit and maybe learn something new. However, I do not like to turn all my HSS anyway in the process. Maybe try a couple of different grinds and see which you prefer. Vince

Re: Scraper Sharpening Angle?

#4

Re: Scraper Sharpening Angle?

Bill Howatt

>I got curious so I measured 3 scrapers, they are between 66 and 72 degrees. There is no single correct angle and if what you are using works well then fine, if you have a problem then adjust the grind.

I will take this opportunity to repeat that tools are consummables. They are made to be sharpened and adjusted if necessary and they will gradually wear away.

Bill

Re: Scraper Sharpening Angle?

#5

Re: Scraper Sharpening Angle?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>George, I set the tool rest on my grinder to grind at 60 deg. (30 deg. if you measure the other way). All scrapers are ground the same. All I need to do to bring up a new burr is a couple of passes with the tool, since it's always ground the same. Over time that saves a lot of tool steel.

If I want to remove a lot of steel for reshaping a tool, or if I want an extra heavy burr as on a neg. rake scraper, I use my 1-inch belt sander. I use a 60 grit blue zircon belt which is designed for metal, and lasts a long time.

Some turners turn up their nose at using scrapers. Properly used a scraper can get some jobs done better and faster. Use a light touch and go with the grain.

Wally

Re: Scraper Sharpening Angle?

#6

Re: Scraper Sharpening Angle?

George Van

>Thanks all.

Ken, it sounds likethey are a lot like gouges and one grind does not fit all. I guess the more I use them the better I will be able to adjust.

Vince, I will definitely be trying different grinds when the one I am using is not cutting with a fresh burr.

Bill, I am going to set one of my grinding platforms to produce a grind of 65 degrees, a compromise between Ken�s and yours. That way I will be able to have a good average grind and chance as I see fit or learn a reason to grind differently.

Re: Scraper Sharpening Angle?

#7

Re: Scraper Sharpening Angle?

George Van

>Thanks Wally, I will knock the dust and set up my belt sander as you do. I want to set one bevel for one of the tool rests also so I can keep the grinder running if necessary so I am not tempted to cut a little longer than the burr remains. If it is easy I will do it.

Re: Scraper Sharpening Angle?

#8

Leo Van Der Loo

George the same angle here, but I want to add,

Leo Van Der Loo

>If you use a narrow scraper, you should have a steeper bevel on the side, or else it will like to flip over, I have a couple that are 1/2" square and keep the side grind pretty steep, never measured but probably close to 80�.

Shear scraping does do the best job most often and can eliminate a lot of sanding, with a lot less dust.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Scraper Sharpening Angle?

#9

Re: George the same angle here, but I want to add,

eliot d

>What ever angle you settle on, you may wish, also, to look into the new trend of grinding a flat section on the TOP of the scraper. Oddly enough, this process is not simply equivalent to increasing the angle, which is what you may think at first. Scrapers ground this way tend to catch less. All my scrapers have this ground , and I find that I have more control when scraping.

Re: Scraper Sharpening Angle?

#10

I kind of go with the 60 degree bevel.

Don Henthorn

>I'm not anal about it. Once in a while instead of using the burr I will hone the bevel to get a longer lasting edge. Just depends.

Re: Scraper Sharpening Angle?

#11

Re: Scraper Sharpening Angle?

George Van

>Good point Leo; I have a narrow scraper also and would not have a lot of bearing surface on the tool rest.

Eliot, are you grinding similar to the negative rake scraper?

Don, I will try your idea also, I would think it would produce a finer less aggressive burr?

Re: Scraper Sharpening Angle?

#12

Re: Scraper Sharpening Angle?

eliot d

>George. I believe that by grinding some off the top of the scraper one is , in effect, producing a negative rake at the cutting surface-- obviously depending on the initial grinding angle and the angle on the top. I am personally convinced that for a square shaped tool, one can get the same result just by lifting the handle a bit. But for curved scrapers there is a different angle presented to the wood at the side of the cutting edge -- even with the scraper held flat on the rest.