Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

The best thing about WC

Posts

The best thing about WC

#1

The best thing about WC

justwannaturn

>The best thing about Woodcentral. There is no "cover" photo for artsy people to get their egos bloated by or get upset when someone changes their photo. "Oh no, someone changed it, what will we do!"

(a shot at WOW)

Turn something instead of worrying about your little photo!

Re: The best thing about WC

#2

Re: Return fire from WOW ...

JamieDonaldson

>... and someone who cares about images! I guess order, playing by rules, displaying ideas and disseminating information are not priorities with you, so why take a cheap shot at something which apparently means nothing to you??!!

Re: The best thing about WC

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: The best thing about WC

Keith Tompkins

>The importance of both the wow and the wc sites are that people are willing to share. Don't just look at the pictures, read the text as well. I think you will discover that most who post photos on wow don't just show their work, they also share their passion for what they create...not only how they do it but WHY.

On the wow site, the most interesting, creative or provocative pieces make the cover.....your post makes me wonder why you're so angry about that.

Re: The best thing about WC

#4

Re: The best thing about WC

Carole Valentine

>One of the nice things about WoW and WC is that *most* people are mature enough and have enough guts to post under their real name. In fact, it is a requirement on WoW - no nicknames. Choosing the cover photo on WoW is not an easy task, nor is it one that is taken lightly. Like Keith, I wonder why you are so upset about Herm's post? (I think I probably already know the answer to that question.) Why didn't you make your statement on WoW? After all, that's where your beef is. Was it because you couldn't hide behind a silly nickname there?

Re: The best thing about WC

#5

Re: The best thing about WC

Mike Nelson

>Do you show your work to others or put them in a closet when finished 'justwanaturn'?

Re: The best thing about WC

#6

Silly , childish post

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>

Re: The best thing about WC

#7

Re: The best thing about WC

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>It seems obvious to me that you're the culprit who changes the cover photo on WoW. Herm has only a couple of rules on Wow that he asks people to respect. Don't take cheap shots at other members and he asks that members leave the cover photo alone. Here on WC you feel free to hide under a nickname and take cheap shots. Grow up!!

Wally

Re: The best thing about WC

#8

The best thing about WC

DougJ in Crawfordsville, IN

>You may want to reconsider your statement. If you find that to be the best thing about WC then you live in a very small place within yourself.

.

.

For me the best thing about WC is the "family" atmosphere, the willingness of help from members, a place to learn without criticism, a place to hang out amongst friends.

Re: The best thing about WC

#9

I Would Guess Person Is Around 12 YO

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>How did he/she get access to WOW anyway?

Re: The best thing about WC

#10

Brad Vietje

Good Point -- raises other questions for me

Brad Vietje

>OK, I'll go out on a bit of a limb here...

Barbara raises a good point: How'd they get into WoW's in the first place ? Whom SHOULD we invite to WoW's ?

One good feature of WoW's is that it is somewhat exclusive -- that is, by invitation. I was flattered when Herm invited me in, and I felt privledged to be so invited. I'm not really sure of Herm's philosophy and/or intent, but it seems that we would freely invite any competent turners who we felt would abide by the rules. I don't feel obligated to invite every person who wants in -- I figure that I should only invite people I know, or those I could vouch for. Now, maybe that's being too exclusive, or snobby -- could be. But I figure someone who knows them could invite them (even in the sense that most of us "know" one another here, or at least know their work), and that if their work is of high caliber, and they have been pleasant and constructive here, then I have no problem inviting them.

So the delicate question is: Should all nice people be invited, even if they are novice turners ? I understood WoW's to be for more experienced turners -- maybe that's not so. Should people feel that an invitation is their right, and should we (or THEY) feel that we "owe" them an invitation if they ask ?

I don't pretend to know the answers to these questions, and probably ought to post them for comment at WoW's, but we often see posts here requesting an invite -- should we ? I ask this humbly and respectfully, and I sincerely hope I do not hurt anyone's feelings with my opinions, or even by posting the questions.

Most of us have been party to other on-line turning groups, many of which have been plagued by "trolls" or immature, nasty jerks. It seems to me the way to avoid that is to limit group membership to those we know to be competent, constructive, and respectful. In that light, I only invite people (to WoW's) I know to be all three, and I encourage moderators to disqualify any who aren't.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: The best thing about WC

#11

Re: Good Point -- raises other questions for me

Carole Valentine

>Brad, I think many turners, especially novice and intermediate turners, think that WoW is "exclusively" for advanced turners. I cannnot speak for Herm, but I do not believe that is his intent at all. I think the reason for the invitations is an attempt to avoid spammers and trolls. I think all turners from novice to seasoned professionals, as long as they are well behaved, are welcome at WoW. I also think it can be of particular value to new and intermediate turners - especially the critiques and the exposure to the work of more advanced turners. Should everyone who asks get an invite? I don't know the answer to that question. Personally, I try only to invite folks that I either know personally or am familiar with through this or other forums and who have proven themselves to be gentlemen and ladies through their posts.

Re: The best thing about WC

#12

Barb Siddiqui

WOW for beginners?

Barb Siddiqui

>I'm a beginner, and was recently invited to become a member of WOW. I hesitated, but am glad to be able to access the site, as it seems a place I can learn from, and participate in. I have no 'portfolio' or pieces to show yet, but can take my time going through all the helpful information and expertise available. I thought Herm made a point of wanting to include new members of all skill levels, and asked long-standing members to welcome them and help out with advice and encouragement. Don't forget, WC's turning board can be intimidating to newcomers, too, as it has a 'clubby' feel of acquaintances that all have a history together. Maybe we should make a real point of encouraging all lurkers to attend a BBQ or Festival nearest their locations, so they can see how really down-to-earth the most professional woodworkers and turners in fact are.

Re: The best thing about WC

#13

Re: I Would Guess Person Is Around 12 YO

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I too would never extend an invitation to someone with whom I wasn't familiar.

Re: The best thing about WC

#14

Re: As a WOW "long timer" I can.....

Jamie Donaldson

>,,, say that the primary criteria for an invitation is that one be a "nice person" first, such as a family member should be, then any skill level turner second. Wow'ies are very much a family group, warts and all, but we follow a code of decency and respect for our fellow members and their work. I do not invite someone unknown to me, and I would hope personal knowledge of an invitee would be a criteria for all to follow.