Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Live Centers *LINK*

Posts

Live Centers *LINK*

#1

Live Centers *LINK*

gil jones

>Has anyone purchased this live center set (see the link), and do you like it?? Woodcraft has a sale on it (in #2MT) thru October, and I need a better live center. Have been considering the OneWay live center, but it is $110, compared to the Pro Live Center Set at Woodcraft for $40. Big difference, as both are dual bearing centers.

Thanks,

Gil


http://www.woodcraft.com/family.aspx?familyid=3727&refcode=07IN10NL

Re: Live Centers *LINK*

#2

Re: Live Centers

Cyril Griesbach

>Gil,

I've got one and I bought it because I lost (and then found) the center point in my old Delta live center. It's OK which is to say that I haven't had any problems with it, but then again, I don't use it much at all. I still use the old Delta center now and then but mostly use the one that came with my PM3520B.

The various inserts have come in handy at times. I can't rave about it nor can I condem it.

Cyril

Re: Live Centers *LINK*

#3

Re: Live Centers

Bob Fawcett

>I believe that the one that comes with the 3520B is a Oneway. I have one of each and the only difference I can see is that the PM is black and the Oneway is chrome.

Re: Live Centers *LINK*

#4

Re: Live Centers

Fog Tanner

>The one that comes with the PM is a Jet, has the same dimensions as the Oneway only with better bearings and a cheaper price tag. Oneway had some issues with Jet when they first came out with.

Re: Live Centers *LINK*

#5

Re: Live Centers

John Kyler

>I would like to know about the Woodcraft one also.

The others mentioned are considerable more expensive.

Do you get what you pay for or is it a good deal.

Re: Live Centers *LINK*

#6

Re: Live Centers *LINK*

Bob Fawcett

>Gil,

Here is a link to the Jet part no on Amazon.

It sure looks like the Oneway to me, but I can't dispute Fog's comment.

Anyway, the price is about $30 cheaper than I have seen the Oneway at other sites.


Live center

Re: Live Centers *LINK*

#7

Re: Live Centers

Carole Valentine

>Gil, I have that Woodcraft set. It's OK considering the sale price. I don't use it that much. Mine runs true but I did notice that it makes a whirring noise, which I suspect is the bearings. Don't know if that is normal or not. About the only thing I use it for is the cup center which I bring up to a small square of leather when I want to remount a piece I am not happy with and don't want to mar a finished base with the point from my normal live center. I do sometimes use the point on small stuff because it gives me more room to work than my other center. The $$$ for a Oneway were not in the cards at the time.

Re: Live Centers *LINK*

#8

Re: Live Centers

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>Gil,

I always understand when $$$ are the issue, so get what you can, when you can.

I was someone the pooh-poohed the Oneway/Jet live center, until I gave in and bought one. It is the last live center you will ever need. It has a couple of accessories that have proven to be very useful once I had it. 1) the large, reversable, cone, and 2) the ability to screw on accessories that end can turn (chuck adapter, jam chucks, etc).

That is all I can add to the discussion.

Mark

Re: Live Centers *LINK*

#9

Re: Live Centers

Ed Heuslein

>Bob, I have both the Jet and the Oneway. I can't tell the difference in using them. If I had to buy another I would go for the Jet. I also have a set from Woodcraft. It is just not as handy nor as versatile as the Jet/OW for what I do.

Re: Live Centers *LINK*

#10

Brad Vietje

Re: Live Centers

Brad Vietje

>I have the set from Woodcraft, and use it very often, with no problems. Runs pretty true, except in my case the small straight pin (which I lost), which was not a real precise fit in the hollow tip. I like the interchangeable tips. I often use the small cone for re-centering pieces between centers.

Now that I have the PM 3520-B, I also have the WMH/Jet knockoff of the Oneway center, which I now used most of the time. However, mine came without the large, reversable cone that comes with the Oneway set. where can I get the cone -- anyone know ?

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Live Centers *LINK*

#11

Re: Live Centers

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>Brad,

Call Kevin at Oneway, but pretend you just lost the one for you Oneway.... ;)

Mark

Re: Live Centers *LINK*

#12

Re: Live Centers

Ed Karch

>Had the woodcraft for a year on my Jet mini and I like it. Have the Jet on my PM and like it also. I have used the various centers ocassionally when needed.

Re: Live Centers *LINK*

#13

Re: Live Centers

MountainMan

>Yes, I bought one a year or so while they were on this same sale - I use mine on a JET mini - I have not used all of the centers - but the bearings seem to be pretty solid and no wobble shown after about 400 hours...

Regards

TheMountainMan

Re: Live Centers *LINK*

#14

Re: Live Centers

gil jones

>Thanks everyone!!! for all of the info and comments, I really appreciate your inputs.

I am tempted to buy the Jet and the Woodcraft live centers, together they are close to the cost of the OneWay live center. Does anyone know if the threaded cone on the Jet center is 3/4" X 16 tpi, or is it threaded like the OneWay?

Re: Live Centers *LINK*

#15

Re: Live Centers

john lucas

>It is 3/4 x 16. I thought the Oneway was the same thread but Idon't own one of those. My favorite live center is the Nova. It comes with some really handy points. I've had it for many years and never had to replace the bearings. It's hollow so you can use it with Lamp augers. It has a short #2 morse taper for the center points. This means you can use them in the headstock for special projects. It also makes it very easy to turn special wooden mandrel points for the live center. It also comes with a screw adaptor that makes it easy to mount wood or plastic on the live center for special projects.

Re: Live Centers *LINK*

#16

Re: Live Centers

Bob Fawcett

>They both have the same thread.

I measure 3/4" OD on the threads and 10 TPI on my thread gauge. It could be a metric thread as the 10 didn't seem to be a precise fit.

Re: Live Centers *LINK*

#17

3/4" 10 TPI is correct *LINK*

Bob Fawcett

>Check out the live center adapters on Oneway's site. You can mount your chuck or faceplate to the live center for reversing your bowl.


Live Center

Re: Live Centers *LINK*

#18

Re: Live Centers

john lucas

>Your right Bob. I must have been asleep this morning. My Carbo-tec is 3/4x16.

Re: Live Centers *LINK*

#19

Re: Live Centers

Rick Bane

>I have the oneway with the cones. Its really an awesome piece. havent turned a million hours on it yet, but its a no brainer. you will never have to buy another again. I also have a oneway check and the termite toll-which is just the greatest tool known to a turner!!!! Especially those of us who are just getting going.

Rick

Re: Live Centers *LINK*

#20

Re: Live Centers

bob davis

>the oneway is 3/4-10