Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

To your eye, how does this compare

Posts

To your eye, how does this compare

#1

To your eye, how does this compare

Allen Neighbors

>with the Brazillian Pepper HF that I previously posted? I tried to continue the curvature of the lower side a little more. Did I continue the curve enough? Looking to improve my eye, here. I need some more critiques, please.

Pau Ferro, 4.25" dia X 2" tall, 1/8"thickness, 7/8" opening. Lacquer wash, Woll Wax rub, Carnauba buff.

Thanks in advance.


img

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

#2

Re: Top 

Allen Neighbors

>


img

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

#3

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

Wally Dickerman

>To my eye, the curve does flatten out at the bottom. By continuing the curve a bit more you'd have had a smaller foot which would also improve the form. However, the form is a very good one as it is. You're improving rapidly.

Wally

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

#4

Re: To add an element to the top....

JamieDonaldson

>... would strengther the appeal to me. How about a slight upward curve at the opening rather than just a hole that falls off into the interior darkness?

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

#5

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks, Wally. Still flattening out, huh? Okay. Gotta work on it somemore. Appreciate the input. Thanks for the compliment, too.

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

#6

Re: Upward curve?

Allen Neighbors

>I'm having enough trouble with the downward curve. Adding another element might cause an overload!!! :o)

I do see what you mean, though. :o) Maybe I'll try that on the next one.

Thanks for the input, Jamie. Need to paint the stone bridge blue, too, eh? :o) Sorry for the lack of good photography.

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

#7

I agree with Jamie

TDaniel

>Not only will an upward curve make the piece look better, it will give some structural strength to the top so warpage will be reduced or eliminated. The form is really nice overall. You are definitely improving.

TD

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

#8

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

jmohnike

>Looks good.

The shape shows off the wood ( what kind was it?) with the grain hinting at an upward spiral.

To add anything more or change the shape may take away from the natural beauty of the wood.

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

#9

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

Bob Fawcett

>I like it a lot as is Allen.

That is one beautiful piece of wood, and the finish is just right.

I think I can see what the others are talking about, but I am not sure I would like it better, of course I am no expert.

That piece looks like it would feel good in the hands.

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

#10

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

Carole Valentine

>Very good Allen. Personally, I would have brought the curve in a tad more at the bottom, but hey, if we all made them the same, that wouldn't be any fun would it? Keep up the good work!

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

#11

Re: I agree with Jamie

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks, TD. I didn't think about the structural asset... just another reason to add the second curve.

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

#12

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks, Bob, my wife says it looks like Cocobolo, and it does feel good.

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

#13

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

Allen Neighbors

>That's true, Carole, we don't want to all make them the same. But I do want to be able to should I desire. :o)

Tucking in the bottom more is what Wally and others suggested, too. You're right... having the bottom with a little more curvature, made your Cedar HF seem to float. That's another one of those visionary things that I'm looking for.

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

#14

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

Bill Stehman

>Beautiful bowl Allen. I tend to agree will Wally but as Carol said, do your own thing also. I like all of your work.

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

#15

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Top

Leo Van Der Loo

>Hi Allen

Allen I love this form, except for the opening, my feeling is that your eye falls off of the edge, I still think like I said before a small lip on it would give it a a what shall I call it, cant find the right word here, but it would pull your look or eye up, rather than fall off the edge into the darkness.

You're getting good though Allen, just keep at it.

and

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

#16

Beautiful

Marianne

>To my eye, the wood and form are perfect. Great job Allen! Marianne

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

#17

Re: Appreciated Bill. thanks. :o)

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: To your eye, how does this compare

#18

Re: You're too kind, Marianne, Thanks.

Allen Neighbors

>